Table 2.
Citation | Initial enrollmenta | Analytical sample sizeb | Average answered EMA survey prompts (per participant) M (SD)c | Average compliance ratee | Average latency (>15 minutes)f |
Berkman et al [22] | 44 | NRfg | NRfg | Electronic: 96% Paper and pencil: 70% |
Electronic: 40.1% Paper and pencil: 73.2% |
Biddle et al [14] | 991 | 948 | NRfg | NRfg | 71.7% |
Biddle et al [15] | 623 | 550 | NRfg | NRfg | NRfg |
Carels et al [23] | 30 | NRfg | Lapses: 11.8 (10.9) Temptations: 8.7 (8.3) Random prompts: 18.3 (8.3) |
NRfg | N/A |
Dunton et al [16] | 568 | 524 | 24.3 (3.4) | 83% (SD=9.4) | 0% |
Dunton et al [24] | 121 | 108 | 31.2a | 78% | NRfg |
Gorely et al [17] | 1604 | 1371 | NRfg | 50% | 74.1% |
Grenard et al [25] | 158 | 158 | Random: 11.8a Eating events: 13.4a Evening report: 6.58a | Random: 71% Evening reports: 95% |
NRfg |
Mak et al [18] | - | 642 | N/A | NRfg | N/A |
Rouse et al [26] | 147 | 84 | NRfg | 57% | NRfg |
Rusby et al [19] | 82 | 80 | 74.9a | Total: 69%a | 0% |
Spook et al [20] | 30 | 30 | 4.3 | 44% | NRfg |
Thomas et al [27] | 43 | 39 | 31.3%a | 71% | NRfg |
aInitial enrollment: number of participants who consented to the study.
bAnalytical sample size: number of participants in the main analysis.
cAverage answered EMA survey prompts (per participant): average of number of survey prompts each participant responded to.
dAverage compliance rate: average of number of answered surveys out of total planned EMA surveys per participant, can include compliance for each monitoring period.
eAverage latency (>15 minutes): the average time between prompting to participants answered the prompt.
fNumbers were hand calculated from information available.
gNRg: not reported in paper.