Skip to main content
. 2016 Jul 7;11(7):e0158373. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0158373

Table 1. Characteristic of included studies.

No Author Year Country Study type Male% Median age EUS frequencies MHz EUS method Sample size Confirmatory test
1 Binmoeller 1995 Germany prospective 73.6 61 7.5 radial 38 surgery
2 Catalano(End) 1994 America retrospective 72.0 69 7.5,12 radial 100 surgery
3 Catalano(Eva) 1999 America prospective 72.4 66 7.5,12 radial 145 surgery
4 Choi 2010 Korea prospective 94.5 62.7 5,12,20 radial 109 surgery
5 Gheorghe 2006 Romania prospective 92.7 61 N* N* 41 surgery
6 Goda 2009 Malaysia retrospective 61.4 65 20 mini-probe 101 EMR
7 Grimm 1993 America prospective 85.7 59 7.5 radial 63 surgery
8 Hasegawa 1996 Japan retrospective 86.4 61.5 7.5,12 radial 25 surgery
9 He 2014 China retrospective 65.3 58 7.5,12 radial 72 surgery
10 Heintz 1991 Germany retrospective 72.5 63 7.5,12 radial 40 surgery
11 Hunerbein.C 2003 Germany retrospective 59.5 61 7.5,12.5 R/M a 97 surgery
12 Hunerbein.M 1996 Germany prospective 58.2 62 7.5 radial 19 surgery
13 Kawano 2003 Japan retrospective N* N* 20 radial 85 surgery
14 Kienle 2002 Germany prospective N* N* 7.5,12.5 radial 117 surgery
15 kutup 2007 Germany retrospective 76.2 N* 20 radial 214 surgery
16 Lee 2014 Korea retrospective 78.9 68.1 N* N* 19 surgery
17 Lok 2008 China retrospective 81.1 65.8 20 mini-probe 59 surgery
18 Massari 1997 Italy retrospective N* N* 7.5,12 radial 40 surgery
19 May 2004 Germany prospective 89.0 63.9 7.5 radial 100 S/EMR b
20 Murata 1988 Japan retrospective N* N* 7.5,10 radial 173 surgery
21 Murata. Y 1996 Japan prospective 88.7 67.4 15,20 mini-probe 53 surgery
22 Natsugoe 1996 Japan prospective 89.2 62 7.5 radial 37 surgery
23 Nesje 2000 Norway prospective 82.3 66 7.5,12 linear/radial 68 surgery
24 Nishimaki 1999 Japan prospective 88.4 62 7.5,12 radial 224 surgery
25 Pham 1998 Australia prospective 71.4 67.5 N* radial 28 surgery
26 Sandha 2008 Canada retrospective 82.8 68 N* N* 29 surgery
27 Shin 2014 Korea retrospective 95.0 63 N* radial 240 surgery
28 Shinkai 2000 Japan retrospective 87.6 60 7.5,12,20 radial 113 S /EMR b
29 Takemoto 1986 Japan retrospective 87.5 63.4 N* linear array 12 surgery
30 Takizawa 2009 Japan prospective 85.1 63 5,7.5 radial 121 surgery
31 Tekola 2014 America retrospective 89.5 65.8 7.5 radial 38 surgery
32 Tio(End) 1990 Netherland retrospective 71.7 61 7.5,12 radial 113 surgery
33 Tio(Endo) 1989 Netherland prospective 68.9 62 7.5,12 radial 74 surgery
34 Tio(Eso) 1989 Netherland prospective 74.7 62 7.5,12 radial 91 surgery
35 Toh 1993 Japan retrospective 88.5 61.3 7.5,12 radial 26 surgery
36 Vazquez 2001 America retrospective 62.2 64 7.5,12 R/M a 37 surgery
37 Vickers J 1998 England prospective N* N* 7.5,12 radial 50 surgery
38 Vickers J, AD 1998 England retrospective N* N* N* mini-probe 50 surgery
39 Wakelin 2002 England prospective N* N* 7.5,12.5 radial 36 surgery
40 Wu 2003 China retrospective 65.1 62 12,15 mini-probe 86 surgery
41 Yanai. H 1996 Japan retrospective 64.7 64 N* radial 16 S/EMR b
42 Yen 2012 China retrospective 96.4 60.5 N* R/M a 28 surgery
43 Yoshikane 1994 Japan retrospective 92.9 58 7.5,12 radial 28 surgery
44 Ziegler 1991 Germany prospective 71.2 57.5 N* linear array 52 surgery

N* for not metioned

aR/M for radial/ mini-probe

bS/EMR for surgery/ EMR.