Table 1.
Environmental intervention studiesa | Setting | Sample size | Age (years) | Outcome measurements (Pooled risk ratios attributed to intervention) RR (95% CI) |
||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Urgent care clinic visits | ER Visits | Hospitalizations | ||||
Environmental education using medical providers | ||||||
Hughes et al. (20) Level 2 Randomized control trial |
Urban (Canada) | 47 | 6–16 | .63 (.41, .95) | .44 (.28, .67) | .71(.42, 1.16) |
Stout et al. (21) Level 4 Pre-post trial |
Urban (USA) | 23 | 1–9 | |||
Shelledy et al. (22) Level 4 Pre-post trial |
Urban (USA) | 18 | 3–18 | |||
Environmental education using non-medical providers | ||||||
Prinomo et al. (23) Level 49 Pre-post trial |
Urban (USA) | 104 | ≤18 | .66 (.53, .82) | .56 (.44, .73) | .50 (.33,.77) |
Largo et al. (24) Level 4 Pre-post trial |
Urban (USA) | 243 | 0–17 | |||
Margellos-Anast et al. (25) Level 4 Pre-post trial |
Urban (USA) | 50 | 2–16 | |||
Multi-component intervention (education using non-medical providers, allergen-impermeable covers, pest management) | ||||||
Carter et al. (26) Level 1 Randomized control trial |
Urban (USA) | 30 | 5–16 | .36 (.32, .41) | .63 (.53, .74) | .83 (.64, 1.08) |
Sullivan et al. (27) Level 1 Randomized control trial |
Urban (USA) | 515 | 5–11 | |||
Bryant-Stephens and Li (28) Level 2 Randomized control trial |
Urban (USA) | 153 | 2–16 |
Evidence level is calculated from a modified Sackett scale containing five levels (e-Appendix 3).