Table 2.
Error category | Description | Example |
---|---|---|
Correct | Appropriate label for picture provided by at least two individuals in previous norming study; or any additional response judged to be accurate based on consensus judgment of the experimenters | For one picture: “jam” and “jelly” both considered correct (responses from norming study); also accepted additional response “preserves” |
Phonological – Non-word | A non-word response that shares the initial phoneme and/or at least 50% of phonemes with the target word | “Thack” for “tack” |
Phonological – Formal | A semantically unrelated real-word response that shares the initial phoneme and/or at least 50% of phonemes with the target word | “Tram” for “pram (carriage)” |
Semantic | A semantically related response. All counted as errors in Alternate Names condition; only more distantly related responses not occurring in the norming name agreement study counted as errors in the Near Semantic Neighbors Condition | Alternate Names condition: “turkey” for “chicken” Near Semantic Neighbors condition: “jar” for “beaker” |
Mixed | A semantically related response that shares the initial phoneme and/or at least 50% of phonemes with the target word (same condition differences described for semantic errors apply) | Alternate Names condition: “can opener” for “corkscrew” Near Semantic Neighbors condition: “sponge” for “squeegee” |
Superordinate | Overarching category name of the target word | “Instrument” for “tuba” |
Other | Semantically and phonologically unrelated responses or descriptions of the target word | “Marble” for “olives;” “something from under the sea” for “jellyfish” |
No response | An indication of uncertainty about identity of picture with no response provided | “I don’t know what that is” |