Table 3.
Priority scores of glioblastoma immunotherapeutics in preclinical studies.
| Adoptive cellular | |||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Therapeutic agent | STAT3 inhibitor | EGFRvIII × CD3 bispecific monoclonal Ab | *EGFRvIII CAR | *EGFRCAR | *IDH1 peptide vaccine | 4-1BB aptamer | *Arginine | *IDO inhibitor | Adv-TK + Adv-Flt3L | ||
| Antigen/ Target | Expression frequency | 0–33% (1)34–66% (2)66–100 (3) | 272 | 123-25 | 123-25 | 226,128,129 | 185,86 | 3201,202 | |||
| Benefit in other malignancy | 1 | 1203-211 | |||||||||
| Homogeneous expression | 1 | 126,128,129 | |||||||||
| Persistence at recurrence | 2 | 2212 | 2152,153 | 2152,153 | 226,128,129 | 285,86 | |||||
| Mechanism of resistance | 1 | 1212 | 1152,153 | 1152,153 | 126,128,129 | 1202 | |||||
| Specificity of expression in the tumor | 123-25 | 123-25 | 185,86,213 | ||||||||
| Immune activation and effector response | Immune activation | 1 | 1111,214 | 184,215 | 169,216 | 1217 | 187,218 | 1172,219-221 | 1109,110 | 195,96 | |
| Trafficking to the tumor | 1 | 1214,222 | 184,215 | 166-68,216 | 1223 | 187,218 | 1224 | 195,96 | |||
| Maintenance of effector response within tumor | 1 | 0214 | 184,215 | 166,67,216 | 187 | 1172 | 1110 | 195,96 | |||
| Agent: Preclinical | Anti-stem cell activity | 2 | 27,79-81 | 2223 | |||||||
| Efficacy in preclinical models | Other (1)Clone (1)*GEMM/Xenograft (2) | 1111,214 17,76,80,111,210,2142112,225 | 284,215 | 166-69266-69,216 | 12172223 | 1218287,218 | 1219,224,2262172,224 | 120228,202 | 195296 | ||
| Acceptable toxicity profile | 2 | 278,112,225 | 284,215 | 266-68,216 | 2217,223 | 287,218 | 2172,224,227 | 2228 | 28 | 295,96 | |
| Hits target in vivo | 2 | 2112,210,225 | 284,215 | 266-68,216 | 2223 | 287,218 | 28 | 295,96 | |||
| Score | 20 | 14 | 15 | 17 | 14 | 8 | 4 | 11 | 10 | ||
Abbreviation: *GEMM, genetically-engineered murine model (of glioma).