Skip to main content
. 2016 Jul 14;11(7):e0159138. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0159138

Table 4. Evaluation of different normalization processes.

To this end, microarray data for diseased vs. healthy samples was used and compared with respect to No. of down-regulated scFvs antibodies and No. of complete matches per target molecule, using a fold change (FC) filter of either FC > 1 or FC > 1.1 and with and without a cut-off value of q <0.05.

Diseased vs. Healthy Subtract by group mean + semi-global norm ComBat norm + semi-global norm Global VSN + Combat norm Global LOESS + Combat norm
No. of down-regulated scFvs at FC > 1 38 of 195 37 of 195 91 of 195 99 of 195
No. of down-regulated scFvs at FC > 1 and q <0.05 21 of 151 20 of 150 58 of 135 61 of 119
No. of down-regulated scFvs at FC > 1.1 and q <0.05 21 of 146 20 of 145 53 of 125 57 of 108
No. of complete matches* per target molecule (ntotal = 47) 32 33 23 21

* Each protein analyte was targeted by 2–9 individual scFv clones. A complete match is defined as when all scFvs per target gave similar results with respect to up- vs. down regulations, using a fold change (FC) filter of FC > 1.