Skip to main content
. 2016 Jun 30;13:E84. doi: 10.5888/pcd13.150559

Table 5. Impact Evaluations of Selected Individual Health Impact Assessments (HIAs) in Various Countries, 2004–2013.

Author and Year of Publication Name and Location of HIA Sector Example of HIA Recommendation Adopted in Final Project or Plan Selected Feature, Finding, or Impact
Mindell et al, 2004 (23) London’s draft transport strategy HIA, United Kingdom Transportation Giving priority to infrastructure and services that benefit London’s economically deprived communities Achieved policy changes and raised awareness of health issues among policy makers
Mathias and Harris-Roxas, 2009 (24) Christchurch Urban Development Strategy HIA, New Zealand Land use 17 actions (not specified) in final strategy addressed HIA recommendations Included process and impact evaluation; strong cross-sector relationships contributed to HIA success
Quigley and Watts, Ltd, 2010 (25) Evaluation of the Whānau Ora HIA of the Draft Wairarapa Alcohol Strategy, New Zealand Alcohol policy HIA recommendations led to revisions of draft strategy Public health team conducting HIA increased its knowledge and skills with HIA
Clark County, 2011 (26) Clark County Bicycle and Pedestrian Master Plan HIA, Clark County, Washington Transportation Health and equity incorporated as project selection criteria Of 11 HIA recommendations, 8 were fully adopted and 3 partially adopted
Harris-Roxas et al, 2011 (27) Equity-focused HIA on health promotion policy implementation plan, New South Wales, Australia Health promotion policy Change in resource allocation split between rural and urban services Focused on equity aspects of a health-sector plan
Ross et al, 2012 (28) Atlanta BeltLine transit, parks, and redevelopment project HIA, Atlanta, Georgia Land use and transportation Public health professional added to project advisory board Explicitly tied findings to recommendations and to subsequent impacts
O’Mullane and Quinlivan, 2012 (29) Four policy HIAs on transport, housing, community development, air quality plan, Ireland Multiple sectors Transport HIA “was used to plan further health promotion and community planning activities” Found local government can be an enabler or barrier to success of HIA
Canterbury District Health Board, 2013 (30) Evaluation of the HIA of the Canterbury Regional Land Transport Strategy, New Zealand Transportation Committing future funding to policies supporting active transport and public transport Noted that HIA report recommendations did not include effective monitoring for health issues