Table 1. Characteristics of studies.
Reference | Year | Study design | Participants | No. of subjects | Geographic regions | Baseline endometrial thickness1_T2 (mm) | Baseline endometrial thickness1_C2(mm) | Isoflavone dose (mg/d) | Source of isoflavone | Study duration (week) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
D.H.Upmlis et al. | 2000 | Double-blind RCT | postmenopausal | 122 | USA | 3.5±1.9 | 3.7±2.7 | 50 | Soy | 12 |
G. E. Hale et al. | 2001 | Double-blind RCT | Perimenopausal | 24 | Austria | 7.09±2.85 | 6.46±1.7 | 50 | Red clover | 12 |
Kyung K.Han et al. | 2002 | Double-blind RCT | Perimenopausal | 80 | Brazil | 3.3±0.1SE | 2.6±0.1SE | 100 | Isoflavone tablet | 16 |
A.Sammartino et al. | 2003 | RCT | postmenopausal | 63 | Europe | 3.2(2.3-4.5) | 3.1(2.3-4.2) | 36 | Genistein | 48 |
M.J.Murray et al. | 2003 | RCT | postmenopausal | 15 | USA | 3±1 | 3.6±1.6 | 120 | Isoflavone tablet | 24 |
M.Penotti et al. | 2003 | Double-blind RCT | postmenopausal | 62 | Europe | 2.6±1.8 | 3.2±1.8 | 36 | Soy | 24 |
A.Crisafulli et al. | 2004 | Double-blind RCT | postmenopausal | 60 | Europe | 3.2±0.25SE | 3.3±0.33SE | 54 | Isoflavone tablet | 48 |
E.Nikander et al. | 2005 | double blind cross over RCT | postmenopausal | 56 | Europe | 2.4±1.5 | 2.1±1.1 | 114 | Isoflavone tablet | 12 |
M.Imhof et al. | 2006 | crossover RCT | postmenopausal | 109 | Austria | / | / | 80 | Red clover | 13 |
E.A.P.Nahas et al. | 2007 | Double-blind RCT | postmenopausal | 76 | Brazil | 3median(2.2-4.1) 25-75th | 3.7median(2.6-4.1) 25-75th | 100 | Glycine max | 40 |
G.Cheng et al. | 2007 | Double-blind prospective randomized study | postmenopausal | 51 | Europe | 2.3±1.1 | 2±1 | 60 | Soya beans | 12 |
H.Marini et al. | 2007 | Double-blind RCT | postmenopausal | 389 | Italy | 3.1±1.5 | 3.2±1.8 | 54 | Isoflavone tablet | 104 |
G.Zhang et al. | 2007 | Double-blind RCT | postmenopausal | 100 | China | 1.82±0.62 | 1.75±0.58 | 18 | Isoflavone tablet | 12 |
J.Manonai et al. | 2008 | Double-blind RCT | postmenopausal | 71 | Asia | 4.07±1.48 | 4.07±1.39 | 20,30,50 | Pueraria mirifica | 24 |
T.J.Powles et al. | 2008 | Double-blind RCT | postmenopausal | 401 | England | / | / | 40 | Red clover | 156 |
A.M.Kenny et al. | 2009 | Double-blind RCT | postmenopausal | 66 | USA | 2.97±0.81 | 3.14±0.81 | 57 | Soy | 52 |
R.D'Anna et al. | 2009 | RCT | postmenopausal | 397 | Europe | 3.1±0.1SE | 3.2±0.1SE | 54 | Isoflavone tablet | 104 |
F.M.Steinberg et al. | 2011 | Double-blind RCT | postmenopausal | 268 | Multicenter | 1.8±0.98 | 2±1.22 | 102.3 | Synthetic | 104 |
M.Evans et al. | 2011 | Double-blind RCT | postmenopausal | 83 | Canada | 4.28±1.98 | 3.66±1.21 | 30 | Synthetic | 12 |
A.Oyama et al. | 2012 | Double-blind RCT | postmenopausal | 68 | Japan | 0.2±0.8 | 0.1±0.5 | 5 | Soy germ fermentation | 12 |
A.M.Quaas et al. | 2013 | Double-blind RCT | postmenopausal | 224 | USA | 2.4±1 | 2.5±1.1 | 154 | Isolated soy protein | 156 |
N.Colacurci et al. | 2013 | RCT | postmenopausal | 124 | Europe | 3.35±0.95 | 3.47±1.07 | 60 | Isoflavone tablet | 48 |
D.L.Alekel et al. | 2014 | Double-blind RCT | postmenopausal | 168 | USA | 1.7±1.1 | 1.3±0.65 | 120 | Soy bean | 156 |
All values are the means ±SDs, means ±SEs, mean (range), median (25th-75th range), or mean (95%CI) reported in the trial
T: treatment group, C: control group