Skip to main content
. 2016 Jul 22;11(7):e0159615. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0159615

Table 1. Proportion of colonies (in two wintering methods) with detectable levels of parasites or pathogens.

Wintering method Season Number of colonies Varroa (%) Tracheal mite (%) Nosema* (%) # DWV (%) BQCV (%) SBV* (%) # IAPV* (%) KBV* (%) CBPV (%) ABPV (%)
Indoor Fall 45 69 4 53a 100 98 40a 13 11 13 2
Mid-winter 45 56 9 87b 87 82 84b 33 18 13 16
Spring 40 58 10 90b 98 88 73b 20 20 13 10
Outdoor Fall 30 83 3 47 100 100 50 13 13 10 3
Spring 26 73 8 96 96 92 85 50 46 35 8
Pooled Fall 75 76 3.5 50 100 99 45 13 12 11.5 2.5
Pooled Spring 66 65.5 9 93 97 90 79 35 33 24 9

The levels of parasites or pathogens as measured by the alcohol wash method for Varroa on adult bees collected in the brood area (250 bees) and from colony entrances (200 bees approximately), spore count for Nosema spp (from 100 bees), thoracic slice method for tracheal mite (100 bees), and RT-PCR for viruses using 50 bees for brood area and 10 bees for entrance samples.

* = Overall seasonal change in prevalence (see results for statistics) from fall to spring averaged over both wintering methods.

# = Comparisons within indoor-wintered colonies for changes in seasonal prevalence (see results for statistics) proportions followed by the same letter within indoor-wintering hives are not significantly different (P > 0.05).

DWV = deformed wing virus; BQCV = black queen cell virus; SBV = sacbrood virus; IAPV = Israeli acute paralysis virus; KBV = Kashmir bee virus; CBPV = Chronic bee paralysis virus; ABPV = acute bee paralysis virus.