Skip to main content
. 2016 Jul;8(7):1587–1600. doi: 10.21037/jtd.2016.06.01

Table S4. Baseline characteristics of included studies.

Authors [year] (Ref.) Language Origin Study design Study period NOS Categories No. samples Mean age (years) Histological subtypes Stages Material Detection Positive site Cut-off value Outcomes Extractions Analysis Endpoint Follow-up (months)
CP features Prognosis Total PE NE AC SCC Others
Chen et al. [2013] (18) English Taiwan ROS 2004–2009 8 × 20 18 2 70.4 20 III–IV Paraffin embedded tissue IHC NI 10% staining HR Reported U OS 60
Chen et al. [2012] (13) English China mainland ROS 2003–2004 8 113 57 56 57.2 58 52 3 I–IV Paraffin embedded tissue IHC Nucleus Median histoscore OR, HR DDE U OS 60
Chiou et al. [2010] (19) English Taiwan ROS NI 7 × 118 78 40 58.8 118 I–IV Paraffin embedded tissue IHC NI NI HR DDE U OS 80
Dong et al. [2013] (33) Chinese China mainland ROS 2009–2012 7 × 60 37 23 68.0 17 43 I–IV Paraffin embedded tissue IHC Nucleus 25% staining OR DDE U
Li et al. [2016] (14] English China mainland ROS 2013–2014 7 × 65 38 27 53.0 NI NI NI I–IV Paraffin embedded tissue IHC Membrane 25% staining OR DDE U
Li et al. [2012] (15) English China mainland ROS 2008–2011 7 44 24 20 62.6 23 21 I–IV Paraffin embedded tissue IHC Nucleus 10% staining OR, HR DDE U OS 12
Li et al. [2013] (16) English China mainland ROS 2004–2007 8 102 29 73 NI 60 42 I–IV Paraffin embedded tissue IHC Nucleus 25% staining OR, HR DDE U OS 60
Ni et al. [2012] (34) Chinese China mainland ROS 2007–2009 7 × 50 21 29 53.0 18 29 3 I–IV Paraffin embedded tissue IHC Nucleus 20% staining OR DDE U
Qiao et al. [2012] (35) Chinese China mainland ROS 2003–2009 7 × 40 15 25 NI 19 21 I–III Paraffin embedded tissue IHC Nucleus 5% staining OR DDE U
Sun et al. [2012] (36) Chinese China mainland ROS 2008–2010 6 × 186 87 99 55.0 81 105 I–IV Paraffin embedded tissue IHC Cytoplasm NI OR DDE U
Tang et al. [2015] (17) English Taiwan ROS NI 9 133 92 41 NI 97 22 14 I–IV Paraffin embedded tissue IHC NI 50% staining OR, HR DDE, reported U & M OS 120
Wei et al. [2011] (37) Chinese China mainland ROS 2002–2005 8 × 51 27 24 55.0 NI NI NI I–IV Paraffin embedded tissue IHC Nucleus 0% staining HR DDE U OS 98
Xiang et al. [2015] (38) Chinese China mainland ROS 2010–2013 7 × 60 43 17 53.9 20 30 10 I–IV Paraffin embedded tissue IHC Nucleus 50% staining OR DDE U
Yang et al. [2014] (39) Chinese China mainland ROS 2008–2013 7 × 60 36 24 61.0 23 37 I–IV Paraffin embedded tissue IHC NI 10% staining OR DDE U
Zhang et al. [2013] (40) Chinese China mainland ROS 2005–2006 9 126 52 74 NI NI NI NI I–IV Paraffin embedded tissue IHC NI 1% staining OR, HR DDE, reported U & M OS 90
Zhou et al. [2011] (41) Chinese China mainland ROS 2000–2010 6 × 135 44 91 60.0 70 49 16 I–IV Paraffin embedded tissue IHC Nucleus NI OR DDE U

AC, adenocarcinoma; CP, clinicopathological; DDE, demographic data extrapolated; HR, hazard ratio; IHC, immunohistochemistry; M, multivariate; NE, negative expression; NI, no information; OR, odds ratio; OS, overall survival; PE, positive expression; ROS, retrospective observational study; U, univariate.