Table 2.
Base Case Median Incremental Cost-Effectiveness Ratio ($/QALY*) | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Publication Year |
Reference |
Vaccine Type |
Societal Perspective |
Payer Perspective |
Study Conclusion |
2002 | 25 | Meningococcal | 68,000 | NR | Cost-effective‡ |
2004 | 26 | Meningococcal | 42,000 | NR | Cost-effective |
2005 | 27 | Hepatitis C | D§ | NR | Dominant |
2007 | 28 | Hepatitis A | NR† | D | Dominant |
2007 | 29 | HPV | NR | 25,786 | Probably Cost-effective‡ |
2007 | 30 | Meningococcal | 113,000 | NR | Not Cost-effective |
2008 | 31 | Herpes Zoster | NR | 33,000 | Probably Cost-effective |
2008 | 32 | HPV | NR | 1,249-3,291 | Cost-effective |
2009 | 33 | Herpes Zoster | NR | 41,709 | Probably Cost-effective |
2009 | 34 | HPV | NR | 27,398 | Probably Cost-effective |
2009 | 35 | Pneumococcal | 466 | 18,000 | Cost-effective |
2010 | 36 | Influenza | NR | 9,388 | Cost-effective |
2010 | 37 | Influenza | NR | 12,154 | Cost-effective |
2010 | 38 | Pneumococcal | NR | D | Dominant |
2011 | 39 | Hepatitis B | NR | 3,648,123 | Not Cost-effective‡ |
2011 | 40 | HPV | NR | 1,839 | Cost-effective |
2011 | 41 | Influenza | NR | 1,612 | Cost-effective |
2011 | 42 | Influenza | D | NR | Dominant |
2011 | 43 | Pertussis | NR | D | Dominant |
2012 | 44 | HPV | NR | D | Dominant |
2012 | 45 | Rotavirus | NR | 2,400 | Cost-effective |
2012 | 46 | Rotavirus | D | 115,000 | Dominant |
QALY: Quality-adjusted Life Years
NR: Not reported
D: Dominant: The intervention costs less and is at least as effective as the comparator.
Cost-effectiveness: defined by Canada's implicit threshold of $20,000/QALY – 100,000/QALY
Categories of cost-effectiveness:
Cost-effective – less than $20,000 CAD/QALY;
Probably cost-effective – between $20,000 CAD/QALY –$100,000 CAD/QALY;
Not cost-effective – greater than $100,000 CAD/QALY.