Table 1.
Reference # | n | Study group | Days between intubation and onset of | Outcomes | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Intervention | Control | Intervention | Control | |||
[2] | 104 | Exercise and mobilization | Standard care | 1.5 | 7.4 | Primary: number of patients returning to independent functional status (ability to perform 6 daily activities and walking independently) at time of discharge from hospital. Secondary: (1) number of hospital days with delirium (2) number of ventilator-free days during first 28 days of hospitalization (3) length of stay in ICU and in hospital |
[3] | 90 | Usual care + bicycle ergometer, 20 min/day, at an intensity level adjusted individually ×5 days/week | Respiratory therapy adjusted to the individual needs + standardized sessions of upper and lower extremities mobilization 5 days/week | 14 | 10 | Primary: distance covered in 6 min at time of discharge from the hospital Secondary: isometric quadriceps strength and functional status |
[4] | 150 | Mechanically ventilated patient: physical therapy 15 min/day Non-mechanically ventilated patients: physical therapy 2 × 15 min Exercises: walking in place, moving from sitting to standing, arm and leg active and active resistance motion |
Physical therapists provided respiratory and mobility management, based upon individual patient assessment according to unit protocols Usual care was available 7 days/week, 12 h/day |
5 | 5 | Primary: distance covered in 6 min at 12 months Secondary: Timed Up and Go Test, physical function in ICU test, assessment of QOL Instrument utility and short form 36 health survey |
[5] | 120 | Delivered for 30 min/day, 7 days/week, while in ICU. Intensive physical therapy program included: 1. Proper breathing techniques during exercise 2. Progressive range of motion; 3. Muscle strengthening exercises 4. Exercises to increase core mobility and strength 5. Retraining of functional mobility |
Standard of care physical therapy programs based on national survey Range of motion exercises, positioning, and functional mobility retraining 3 days/week for 20 min in ICU |
8 | 8 | Primary: short form of the continuous scale physical functional performance test at 4 weeks Secondary: number of ICU- and hospital-free days on day 28; discharged home, all-cause mortality on day 28, and institution-free days on days 90 and 180 |
[6] | 50 | Early goal-directed mobilization comprised functional rehabilitation treatment at the highest level of activity possible for that patient assessed by the ICU mobility scale while receiving mechanical ventilation. | Not based on protocol All usual unit practices were continued, without restrictions to physical therapy or sedation practice |
3 | 3 | Primary: higher maximum level of activity measured using the ICU mobility scale, increased duration of activity measured in min/day during the ICU stay compared with standard care Secondary: time from admission to first mobilization; duration of mechanical ventilation, ICU and hospital length of stay, and overall duration of hospitalization; serious adverse events, number of ventilator- and ICU-free days on day 28; measurement of physical function with the physical function in ICU, the functional status score in ICU, and the Medical Research Council Manual Muscle Tests; ICU-acquired weakness |
[7] | 300 | Standardized rehabilitation therapy 7 days a week from enrollment through hospital discharge protocol contained 3 exercise types: passive range of motion, physical therapy, and progressive resistance exercises |
Usual care; received routine care as dictated by the patient’s attending physician from Monday through Friday | 1 | 7 | Primary: hospital length of stay Secondary: Short Performance Physical Battery score, muscular strength, short form Functional Performance Inventory score, 36-Item Short Form Health Survey physical health survey and mental health survey, mini-mental state examination score (measure of physical function were obtained at ICU discharge, hospital discharge and 2, 4, and 6 months after enrollment, health-related quality-of-life measures were obtained at hospital discharge and 2,4, and 6 months after enrollment) |