Table 3.
Cochrane risk of bias assessment tool
Paper | Sequence generation | Allocation concealment | Blinding | Incomplete data | Selective outcome reporting | Other validity threats | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Anderson et al41 | L | Randomly assigned to orthosis test condition | U | No indication of allocation concealment process | U | No indication of blinding process for participants or assessors | U | The study did not address this outcome | L | Protocol is available and reports include expected outcomes | H | Males and females did not complete the same protocol, flaw in study design |
Bousie et al39 | L | Randomly assigned to orthosis test condition | U | No indication of allocation concealment process | U | No indication of blinding process for participants or assessors | U | The study did not address this outcome | L | Protocol is available and reports include expected outcomes | L | The study appears to be free of other sources of bias |
Boyd et al23 | L | Randomly assigned to pedal test condition | U | No indication of allocation concealment process | U | No indication of blinding process for participants or assessors | U | The study did not address this outcome | L | Protocol is available and reports include expected outcomes | L | The study appears to be free of other sources of bias |
Cruz et al42 | H | No random allocation to pedal test condition | U | No indication of allocation concealment process | U | No indication of blinding process for participants or assessors | U | The study did not address this outcome | L | Protocol is available and reports include expected outcomes, although with limited methodology and data analysis details | L | The study appears to be free of other sources of bias |
Dinsdale et al58 | L | Randomly assigned to insole test condition | U | No indication of allocation concealment process | U | No indication of blinding process for participants or assessors | U | The study did not address this outcome | L | Protocol is available and reports include expected outcomes | L | The study appears to be free of other sources of bias |
Gregersen et al9 | L | Randomly assigned to pedal test condition | U | No indication of allocation concealment process | U | No indication of blinding process for participants or assessors | U | The study did not address this outcome | L | Protocol is available and reports include expected outcomes | L | The study appears to be free of other sources of bias |
Hennig et al40 | H | No random allocation to shoe test condition | U | No indication of allocation concealment process | U | No indication of blinding process for participants or assessors | U | The study did not address this outcome | -1 | Protocol is available and reports include expected outcomes | L | The study appears to be free of other sources of bias |
Jorge et al59 | H | No random allocation to shoe test condition | U | No indication of allocation concealment process | U | No indication of blinding process for participants or assessors | U | The study did not address this outcome | L | Protocol is available and reports include expected outcomes | L | The study appears to be free of other sources of bias |
Koch et al56 | L | Randomly assigned to orthoses test condition | L | Participants were blinded to the allocation | L | Participants were blinded to the group allocation | U | The study did not address this outcome | L | Protocol is available and reports include expected outcomes | L | The study appears to be free of other sources of bias |
O’Neill et al15 | H | No random allocation to orthoses test condition | U | No indication of allocation concealment process | U | No indication of blinding process for participants or assessors | U | The study did not address this outcome | L | Protocol is available and reports include expected outcomes | L | The study appears to be free of other sources of bias |
Sanderson et al31 | L | Randomly assigned to pedal test condition | U | No indication of allocation concealment process | U | No indication of blinding process for participants or assessors | U | The study did not address this outcome | L | Protocol is available and reports include expected outcomes | L | The study appears to be free of other sources of bias |
L = Low bias risk, U = Unclear bias risk, H = High bias risk