TABLE 2.
A framework for defining and assessing the goals of NBS, by screened condition. Here, phenylketonuria (PKU) is used as an example. Data sources will vary by condition.
| CATEGORICAL UNIVERSAL AIM, (All Conditions) |
CONDITION SPECIFIC GOAL (PKU as an example) |
POTENTIAL MEASURE (PKU as an example) |
POTENTIAL Data Sources (PKU as an example) |
Key ATTRIBUTE (PKU as an example) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rapid and Reliable Detection and Diagnosis | ||||
| Condition detected by NBS | Universal detection | Newborn screening performed -Date first newborn screen collected -Phe on first screen -Tyr on first screen |
State programs NewSTEPS IBEM-IS | Universal screening |
| Condition confirmed and diagnosed | Accurate diagnosis | Diagnostic labs performed: -Blood spot -phenylalanine -Plasma amino acid profile -Plasma tyrosine -Urine organic acids -Blood spot tyrosine -Plasma phenylalanine -RBC (DHPR) activity -Urine pterins |
IBEM-IS NewSTEPs |
Universal diagnosis through screening |
| Rapid initiation of treatment | -Days of age from birth until intervention for this condition -Days of age from birth until first seen by subspecialist -Days of age at initiation of phenylalanine restriction -Days of age (after dietary phenylalanine restriction was initiated) at time first phenylalanine level was documented below 360 μmol/L (6 mg/dL) |
NewSTEPS IBEM-IS Medication-specific registries |
Universal diagnosis through screening | |
| Provision of Evidence-based Care | ||||
| Growth and development | Maintenance of normal growth | Length, weight, OFC, BMI at visits | Clinics IBEM-IS |
Evidence-based treatment |
| Maintenance of normal development | Full scale IQ obtained | IBEM-IS Medication-specific registries Parent-report registry |
Evidence-based treatment | |
| Continuing developmental assessment | -Developmental assessment at visits, who did and how – collects information if formal neuropsychometrics done -Assessment of developmental/intellectual, executive functioning, behavioral/emotional and adaptive skills and if referral made -Early Intervention Services: occupational therapy, physical therapy, speech- language therapy -Educational evaluation–type of special education services (Individualized Educational Program or 504 plan and nature of disabilities) |
IBEM-IS | Evidence-based treatment | |
| Educational/functional performance (Grade level for age, special services, employment status) | -Grade level X at age X -High school diploma or GED by age 25* - employed or in school |
Public health Department of Education databases IBEM-IS |
Evidence-based treatment | |
| Maintenance of normal nutritional status | -dietary intake -nutrient analysis, - nutrition counseling/ education -What medical food is prescribed? -How much? -Who pays? -How much phenylalanine prescribed? |
Clinics IBEM-IS |
Evidence-based treatment | |
| Genotype-based facilitation of pharmacologic management | Genotype | Clinics IBEM-IS |
Evidence-based treatment | |
| Other therapies | Optimization of management | Use of sapropterin Payment source for medications |
IBEM-IS, Medication-specific registries | Evidence based treatment |
| Coordination and Integration of Services | ||||
| Primary care provider | Patients need a medical home | Patient has primary provider (name) Distance to primary provider Receiving preventive care Immunizations Sick visits since last visit Had anesthesia? Had surgery? Complications of surgery? |
IBEM-IS Public Health LTFU |
Care coordination through a medical home |
| Metabolic care provider | Patients need access to appropriate specialty care | -Patient has had an outpatient metabolic visit -Date of last outpatient metabolic visit -Other provider seen at metabolic care visits, -Missed visits |
IBEM-IS | Care coordination through a medical home |
| Other specialty services/providers | Patients need access to appropriate specialty care | Other specialty providers seen since last visit | IBEM-IS | Care coordination through a medical home |
| Genetic counseling services | Patients should have genetic counseling | Genetic counseling provided Provider of genetic counseling |
IBEM-IS | Care coordination through a medical home |
| Other community resources | Patients require access to community resources | Receiving services (specifies what services) | IBEM-IS | Care coordination through a medical home |
| Patient-centered engagement and satisfaction | Access to care | -Locations of services -Distances to services -Type of service (e.g., telemedicine, in person) |
IBEM-IS | Care-coordination |
| Patient has coverage | Patients need insurance coverage | [Captures coverage type, list of options: unknown, commercial/private, military, none, self-pay, state program (non-Medicaid/Medicare), state/federal program (Medicaid/Medicare),other] | IBEM-IS | Care coordination through a medical home |
| Pregnancy | Prevention of maternal PKU syndrome | [special data collection tool used for pregnancy progress] | IBEM-IS | Evidence based treatment |
| Continuous Improvement of Care, Discovery and Innovation | ||||
| Engagement in research | Patient enrolled in study Which study? |
IBEM-IS | New knowledge generation | |
Health People 2020 Goal (http://www.healthypeople.gov/2020/topicsobjectives2020/objectiveslist.aspx?topicid=4)
Abbreviations:
BMI: Body Mass Index
DHPR: Dihydropteridine Reductase
IBEM-IS: Inborn Errors of Metabolism – Information System
IQ: Intelligence Quotient
NBS: newborn screening
NewSTEPS: Newborn Screening Technical Assistance and Evaluation Program
OFC: occipitofrontal circumference
RBC: red blood cell
LTFU: long-term follow-up