Table 1. Comparison of SF hydrogels.
Ref. | Method | Shortest gelation time | Modulus (kPa) | Main conformation | SF concentration |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
16 | Storing SF solution at 4 °C | ~3 days | — | β-sheet | 2 wt.% |
16 | Addition of glycerol in SF solution | ~2 days | — | β-sheet | 2 wt.% |
44 | Addition of citric acid in SF solution and storing at 50 °C | Overnight | — | β-sheet | 2 wt.% |
15 | Increasing SF concentration or temperature, decreasing pH, addition of ions, or polyethylene glycol | <1 day | ~200–6000 (C) | β-sheet | 4–20 wt.% |
17 | Freezing the SF solution with organic solvents at −20 °C | > 6 hours | ~3–50 (C) | β-sheet | 6 wt.% |
37 a | Sonication treatment on SF solution | >0.5 hour | 369–1712 (C) | β-sheet | 4–12 wt.% |
45 | Vortex treatment on SF solution | ~35 minutes | 0.1–70 (S) | β-sheet | 1.3–5.2 wt.% |
27 | Electrical (direct current) treatment on SF solution | ~3 minutes | ~1 (S) | Amorphous | 8.4 wt.% |
46 | Addition of ethylene glycol diglycidyl ether in SF solution at 50 °C | Within 2 hours | 0.01–100 (S) | β-sheet | 4.2 wt.% |
47 | Addition of sodium dodecyl sulfate in SF solution | ~15 minutes | — | β-sheet | 4% (wt/vol) |
48 | Addition of methylcellulose in SF solution at 50 °C | ~40 hours | — | β-sheet | 2 wt.% |
49 | Freezing the SF solution, and then immersion them in ethanol | Overnight | — | β-sheet | 5 wt.% |
39 b | HRP mediated crosslinking of SF solution | 1 hour | 0.2–10 (S) | Random coil | 1–6 wt.% |
Ref.: reference; (C): compressive modulus; (S): storage modulus tested in rheometer.
aAqueous SF solution was mixed with cells (final concentration: 0.5 million/mL). The mixture would gel in 0.5–2 hours. The compression modulus was tested without cells.
bThe hydrogels was allowed to cure for 1 hour at 37 °C for cell seeding, while the shortest gelling time was not mentioned.