Table 3.
Study | n a | Mean age (range) | Therapy | Specifications | Fluence (J/cm2) | Spot Size | Outcomes | Side effects | Mean f/u (month) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Okoye et al. [21] | 11 | 36.6 (25–45) | UVB Metal halide arc lamp 290–320 nm (peak 303 and 313 nm) |
Split-scalp design 3×/week for 16 weeks on treatment side 3×/week for 8 weeks on control side |
Minimal erythema dose 0.23–0.48 Increase 20% per wk for 1st 8 weeks Cumulative dose 29.7 at 8 weeks, 82.2 at 16 weeks |
– |
Moderate to marked improvement 34% reduction at 8 weeks 49% reduction at 16 weeks |
Transient mild burning and erythema | 2 |
Dragoni et al. [19] | 1 | 23 | 595 nm PDL | PDL; 0.5 ms pulse | 6.5 | 10 mm | PDL; transient improvement with lesions recurring after 1 month | None reported | 6 |
1064 nm Nd:YAG laser |
Nd:YAG; 2 pulses (5 and 18 ms) 4 sessions, 1 month apart |
110–120 | 4 mm | Nd:YAG; Improvement in scarring and clinical picture | |||||
Esmat et al. [20] | 16 | 31.88 (22–54) | 1064 nm Nd:YAG laser |
5 sessions 1 month apart Pulse duration 10–30 ms |
35–45 | – |
Significant improvement 3 treatments 82% mean improvement after 5th session Early lesions marked (>75%) improvement Late lesions moderate to marked improvement (>51%) |
Transient crusting Decreased hair density in treated area |
12 |
Shah [18] | 2 | 36, 50 | 810 nm diode laser | 4 sessions at 4–6 weeks apart |
Sessions 1 and 2 fluence 23, pulse 100 ms Sessions 3 and 4 fluence 26, pulse 100 ms |
_ | 90–95% clearance of lesions | Transient mild burn in one patient | 6 |
Azurdia et al. [17] | 1 | 30 | 10,600 nm CO2 laser | 1 session of laser evaporation | 150 | – | Failure to respond referred for surgical intervention | – | 1 |
Kantor et al. [16] | 8 | 31 (19-40) | 10,600 nm CO2 laser | 1 session of laser excision or evaporation | Excision 64,000 W/cm2 | 0.2 mm |
No recurrence with laser excision, no general anesthesia needed Laser vaporization little benefit with recurrence |
Minimal postoperative pain | 3–47 (avg. 14.8) |
Vaporization 130–150 W/cm2, 3–4 passes | 2 mm | ||||||||
Sattler et al. [31] | 1 | 38 | 10,600 nm CO2 Laser |
1 session of laser excision Intralesional triamcinolone acetate 3 session of 400 cGY of radiation |
Excision 64,000 W/cm2 | – | No recurrence with combination therapy, regrowth of hair | _ | _ |
Avg average, cGY centigray, FP Fitzpatrick skin type, Nd:YAG neodymium-doped yttrium aluminum garnet, PDL pulse dye laser, y/o years old
aAll patients receiving light and laser therapies were male