Table 6.
Summary of the studies examining associations of maternal iron status with offspring cognitive function
Author, Year, Sample size, Age, Country, Study design | Nutrient | Cognitive function | Results after adjustment for confounders | QS and RB |
---|---|---|---|---|
31Wehby GL; 2008 N = 6774 Age 3 years USA Population based longitudinal |
Prenatal iron supplements (3 months prior to pregnancy and/or during the following 3 months) 36.2 % used supplement |
Denver developmental screening-language, personal-social, gross motor and fine motor | Iron use was associated with improved performance in personal-social development (OR = 0.5) but not with language and motor domains Confounders adjusted for: The child’s sex, age, ethnicity, MA, ME, MS, alcohol, drug abuse, income, maternal health status |
11 High |
38Rioux FM; 2011 N = 63 Age 6 Months Canada Observational |
Hb, serum ferritin at 28-32 weeks gestation 90 % mothers took iron supplements (27 mg of iron) |
Brunet-Lezine Scale of Psychomotor Development of Early Childhood. Bayley Scales of Infant Development |
No association between maternal gestational Iron status with mental and psychomotor development. Confounders adjusted for: ME, PE, MIQ, income, BF, GA, BWT, birth head circumference, infants’ current weight and Hb |
16 Medium |
39Ferarouei. M; 2010 N = 9983 14 years N = 10474 16 years Finland Prospective Birth cohort study |
Hb concentrations at 3rd 7th and 9th gestational months Anaemia |
School performance 14 years- Self report 16 years- School report |
↑maternal HB at 9 months-↑ total school performance score (β = 0.03) and theory score at 14 years and total score at 16 years Offspring of mothers with anaemia –low school scores (OR = -0.05 at 14 years and (OR = -0.06) at 16 years Confounders adjusted for: The child’s sex, BWT, pregnancy wanted or not, ME, social class, parity, marital status, MS, maternal mental health status |
18 Low |
40Davidson PW; 2008 N = 229 Age 5, 9, 25and 30 months Republic of Seychelles Longitudinal cohort study |
Iron- total body stores at 14-24 weeks of gestation assessed before the start of iron supplementation | Bayley Scales of Infant Development: Mental Development Index (MDI) and Psychomotor Development Index (PDI) (9 and 30 months) Infant cognition (Fagan Infantest-novelty preference) and Visual Expectation Paradigm –visual recognition memory (9 and 25 months) A-not-B and Delayed Spatial Alternation: inhibition, working memory, planning and attention (25 months) |
No association between maternal iron stores and cognitive function at any age. Confounders adjusted for: The child’s sex, BWT, MA, SES, HE, MIQ and both parents living with the child (yes/no) |
19 Low |
41Lewis SJ; 2013 N = ~3,500 Age 8 years UK Population based prospective birth cohort |
Hb concentrations Before 18 weeks Hb <11.0 g/dl -8 % After 28 weeks Hb <11.0 g/dl -30 % |
Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-III- Full- scale IQ | No association between maternal Hb and child’s IQ Confounders adjusted for: GA, ME, the child’s genotype, iron supplementation, population stratification |
15 Medium |
42Tran TD; 2013 N = 378 Age 6 months Vietnam Population based prospective cohort study |
Iron deficiency anaemia (Hb <11.0 g/dl and serum ferritin <15 ng/ml) during 12-28 weeks of gestation-16 % | Bayley Scales of Infant and Toddler Development-III edition-cognitive score | Infants of anaemic mothers scored 11.6 points (0.77SD) lower in BSID cognitive scores compared to infants of non-anaemic mothers. Confounders adjusted for: parity, MA, ME, wealth index, the child’s birth and current weight, family support, BF. |
18 Low |
43Zhou SJ; 2006 N = 302 Age 4 years; Australia Double blind randomized controlled trial |
Iron supplements (20 mg/day) or placebo from 20 weeks gestation until delivery Compliance-86 % |
Stanford Binet Intelligence Scale – IQ (verbal reasoning, visual reasoning, quantitative reasoning and short-term memory) | No difference between the children of supplement group and placebo group in the mean score of composite IQ or any subscales IQ or in the proportion of children whose IQ fell 1 or 2 SD below the mean. Confounders adjusted for: sex, birth order, gestational age, MA, ME, PE, HE, BF |
20 Low |
44Li Q; 2009 N = 1305 Age 3, 6 and 12 months Double blind cluster randomized controlled trial China |
3 intervention groups (All received folic acid) Folic acid alone 400 μg (n = 471)-control Iron 60 mg + folic acid 400 μg (n = 438) Multiple micronutrients ((b vitamins (1,2,3 6 AND 12), vitamin A, D, C, E and minerals (zinc, iodine, copper, selenium) + Iron 30 mg + 400 μg folic acid)) (n = 396) Daily supplementation from enrolment until delivery; inadequate information about compliance |
Bayley Scales of Infant Development :Mental (MD) and Psychomotor development (PD) | No significant difference in infants MD and PD score at 3 and 6 months and PD score at 12 months between supplement groups Mean MD score among children of multiple micronutrient group increased by 1 to 1.22 points compared to children of folic acid alone, or folic acid + iron group at 12 months Confounders adjusted for: Infants age, sex, gestational age, apgar score, BWT, infant health, maternal age and BMI, parental education, occupation, SES, number of tablets consumed |
19 Low |
QS quality score, RB risk of bias, Hb haemoglobin, GA gestational age, MA maternal age, BWT birthweight, SES socio-economic status, ME maternal education, PE paternal education, MIQ maternal intelligence, HE home environment, MS maternal smoking, BF breast-feeding, BMI body mass index