Table 1.
Study | Participants | Intervention |
Outcomes |
||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Int/Ctrl | Type | Years | Diet | All deaths Int/Ctrl | CHD deaths Int/Ctrl | Change in mean serum cholesterol Int/Ctrl (%) | |
Rose Corn oil Rose Olive oil14 |
28/26* (M under 70) 26/26* (M under 70) |
S | 2 | 64 g corn oil/day 58 g olive oil/day + many banned foods |
5/1* 3/1* |
5/1* 3/1* |
−7.6/−1.2 −0.4/−1.2 |
Low-fat Diet19 | 123/129 (M under 65) | S | 3 | 40 g fat/day | 20/24 | 17/20 | −16.9/−12.4 |
MRC Soya-bean Oil18 | 199/194 (M under 60) | S | 3.4 | 85 g soya-bean oil/day + many banned foods | 28/31 | 27/25 | −16.9/−5.9 |
LA Veterans Study21 | 424/422 (M age 55+) | P/S | 8 | 40% calories from fat, 2/3 fat from veg oils | 174/177 | 41/50 | −18.0/−14.1 |
Oslo Diet-Heart Study20 | 206/206 (M 30–64 years) | S | 11 | 40% calories from fat, 72% fat from soya-bean oil | 101/108 | 79/94 | −17.6/−3.7 (5-year data) |
Sydney Diet Heart Study15 | 221/237 (M 30–59 years) | S | 5 | 10% sat/15% poly vs 14% sat/9% poly | 39/28 | 35/25 | −11.0/−7.1 |
DART Fat advice27 | 1018/1015 (M under 70) | S | 2 | Total fat 30% P/S=1 | 111/113 | 97/97 | −2.8/+1.2 |
Minnesota Coronary Survey22 Men Women |
4393 M 4664 W (all ages) 2197/2196 2344/2320 |
P | 1 | Ctrl: 39% calories fat (18% sat; 5% poly; 16% mono) Int: 38% calories fat (9% sat; 15% poly; 14% mono) |
158/153 111/95 |
62/54 43/47 |
Cholesterol not reported separately for men/women −15.5/−1.9 |
STARS28 | 27/28 (M under 66) | S | 3.25 | 27% calories fat (8–10% sat; 8% poly) | 1/3 | 1/3 | −14.0/−1.8 |
WHI29 | 19 541/29 294 (W 50–79 years) | P/S | 8.1 | 20% calories fat; 7% calories sat fat | 950/1454 | 158/234 | −4.4/−3.4 (3-year data) |
Total | 26 354/36 067 | 1701/2187 | 568/650 | Mean −11.4%/−4.7% SD 6.5/4.8 |
In ‘Int/Ctrl’: M, men; W, women.
In ‘Type’: P, primary prevention study; S, secondary prevention study.
In ‘Diet’: P/S, polyunsaturated:saturated fat ratio; poly, polyunsaturated fat; sat, saturated fat.
*Control not double counted.
DART, Diet and Reinfarction Trial; MRC, Medical Research Council; STARS, St Thomas’ Atherosclerosis Regression Study; WHI, Women's Health Initiative.