Table 2.
Incidence and prevalence of active TB disease and latent TB infection in health care workers in South Africa
| Study ID | Study characteristics | Study outcomes | General comments |
|---|---|---|---|
| National | |||
| Claassens et al. [15] (URC report) |
Study date: 2009 133 primary health care facilities in Limpopo, Eastern Cape, Kwazulu-Natal, Mpumalanga and North-West provinces. No information provided on the health care workers |
Incidence of active TB disease (smear positive) 2006: 834 (95%CI 431–1457) per 100,000 persons 2007: 1092 (95%CI 647–1725) per 100,000 persons 2008: 887 (95%CI 517–1420) per 100,000 persons |
To compare the TB incidence rate among healthcare workers with the general population the incidence rate was combined for all facilities. For comparison with the general population a standardised incidence ratio was calculated. The standardised incidence ratio for smear positive TB in healthcare workers in: 2006: 2.4 (95%CI 1.2–4.2) 2007: 3.0 (95%CI 1.8–4.7) 2008: 2.3 (95%CI 1.3–3.7) |
| Dwadwa et al: Health worker access to HIV/TB prevention, treatment and care services in Africa: situational analysis and mapping of routine and current best practices, unpublished Situational analysis |
Study date: 2006 Publicly funded health care facilities in KZN, Limpopo, North West, Northern Cape and Western Cape Number of participants: 173 health care workers from 10 facilities Age: Not reported Sex: Not reported HIV status: Not reported Method of TB diagnosis: Unclear |
Incidence of active TB disease 2006: Between 1130 and 1470/100,000 staff had been treated for TB during 2006. |
In 2006 the national TB case notification rates of South Africa were 719.9 per 100,000. |
| KwaZulu-Natal | |||
| Wilkinson et al. [21] | Study date: not reported Study setting: A district hospital in rural KwaZulu-Natal Number of participants: 725 total number of staff at risk 22 TB cases from 1991 to 1996 Age: Mean age of staff at risk = 37 years; Mean age of TB cases = 29.6 years Sex: 36 % of staff at risk was female. 64 % of TB cases were female HIV status: 59 % of the staff at risk who were tested for HIV were HIV+ 54.5 % of TB cases who were tested for HIV were HIV+ Method of diagnosing TB: Smear microscopy, chest X-RAY |
Annual incidence of active TB disease 138/100 000 (1991/1992) Annual incidence of active TB disease 690/100 000 (1993–1996) |
1991–1996: Annual incidence of TB in the surrounding community was 1543/100 000. Mean age of affected health care workers was 29 years No significant difference in incidence of TB disease between occupational categories Of the 14 HCWs who were tested for HIV, 12 were HIV-positive |
| Naidoo et al. [16] | Study date: 2004/2005 Study setting: Eight public sector hospitals in Ethekwini municipality, KwaZulu-Natal Number of participants: 583 cases of HCWs with TB during the study period Age: HCWs with TB: mean = 37.9 years (range: 21–64) Sex: HCWs with TB: 64 % female HIV status: Not reported Method of diagnosing TB: Not reported |
Mean incidence of active TB disease 1133/100 000 (standard deviation: 282.8, 1999–2004) |
Mean incidence of TB disease among general population in KZN over study period: 497/100 000 Highest incidence of TB disease in 25–29 year olds (2468/100 000; p = 0.003) and paramedical staff (1558/100 000; not statistically significantly different to the incidence in the other occupational categories). |
| O’Donnell et al. [17] | A public TB referral hospital in KwaZulu-Natal Number of participants: 4941 total admissions of M(X) DR-TB 231 confirmed HCWs (MDR-TB = 208; XDR-TB = 23) Age: Median = 35 years Sex: 78 % female HIV status: 55 % of HCW with M(X) DR-TB were HIV+ Method of diagnosing TB: Culture confirmed TB with MTB drug susceptibility testing |
Annual estimated incidence of MDR-TB hospital admissions among health care workers (2003–2008) 64.8/100 000 Annual estimated incidence of XDR-TB hospital admissions among health care workers (2003–2008) 7.2/100 000 |
Annual incidence of MDR-TB hospital admissions among the adult general population in KwaZulu-Natal: 11.9/100 000 (I.R.R. 5.56; 95 % CI: 4.86–6.35). Annual incidence of XDR-TB hospital admissions among adult general population in KwaZulu-Natal: 1.1/100 000 (I.R.R. 6.69; 95 % CI: 4.38–10.2) |
| Tudor et al. [18] | Study date: 2011 Three district hospitals in KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa, with specialized drug-resistant tuberculosis (TB) wards Number of participants: 1427 HCW occupational health records Age: Median = 39 years Sex: 78.05 % female HIV status: 24 % of HCWs with TB HIV+ Method of diagnosing TB: Not reported |
Incidence of active TB disease 1958/100 000 (2010) 2006–2010: 112 (8.53 %) cases of TB, of which 14 (12.5 %) cases were drug-resistant TB. |
Incidence of TB disease among the general population of KwaZulu-Natal was 1142/100 000 (2011). Throughout the study period health care workers had significantly higher annual TB incidence rate ratios (IRR) for each year of the study compared to that of the general population in KwaZulu-Natal. Incidence of active TB in South Africa: 981/100 000 (2010) |
| Western Cape | |||
| Adams: Prevalence and determinants of TB infection in health care workers, unpublished | Study date: 2009–2011 7 primary and secondary level health care facilities in the Western Cape province Number of participants: 505 Age: <30 years (25 %); 31–40 years (27 %); 41–50 years (27 %); >50 years (22 %) Sex: 74 % female HIV status: Primary level staff 19 % HIV+; Secondary level staff 2 % HIV+ Method of diagnosing TB: TB infection: TST, QFT-GIT, TSPOT.TB. TB disease: TB symptom screen, Chest X-Ray and 2× sputum culture. |
Annual incidence of active TB disease 900/100 000; 95 % CI: 0.2–2.6 (2009–2011) Prevalence of active TB disease 1400/100 000 (2009–2011) Prevalence of latent TB infection 84 % (TST; 2009–2011) Annual incidence of latent TB infection 38 % of HCWs converted from TST negative to positive (2009–20110) |
Annual incidence rate in Cape Town 799/100 000 population and Western Cape 935/100 000 population (2008–2011) 3/5 HCWs with active TB were HIV+ 9 % of HCWs reported being diagnosed with or on treatment for diabetes Annual incidence of latent TB infection QFT-GIT conversion rate 22 % reversion rate 7 % T-SPOT.TB conversion rate 22 % reversion rate 16 % |
| Ayuk et al. [20] | Study date: 2008–2011 Tygerberg Academic Hospital, Western Cape province Number of participants: 249 Age: Mean = 43.8 (range: 23–60) years Sex: 71.4 % female HIV status: 30 % HIV+; 63 % HIV-; 6 % unknown Method of diagnosing TB: smear+; culture+, histology and symptoms |
Mean annual incidence rate of active TB disease 2008–2011: 397/100 000 population (95%CI: 307–505 per 100 000; all health care workers) Incidence rate of active TB disease Housekeeping staff: 1181/100 000 Nurses: 324/100 000 Doctors: 194/100 000 |
Annual incidence rate in Cape Town 799/100 000 population and Western Cape 935/100 000 population Housekeeping staff incidence rate of active TB disease approximately 3 times (95%CI: 2.7–3.3) that of the entire workforce, 3.6 times (95%CI: 3.2–4.1) that of nurses and 6.1 times (95%CI: 5.2–7.1) that of doctors. |
| Kranzer et al. [6] | Study date: 2008/2009 Mobile HIV testing unit (the TUTU tester) provided HIV testing, CD4 counts and TB screening to TB and antiretroviral adherence supporters employed by the TB/HIV Care Association in Cape Town on 8 days in 8 venues in the Western Cape province Number of participants: 215 community health workers (CHW) were offered HIV and TB testing Age: Most common age group was 40–49 years old (N = 72, 33 %) Sex: All female HIV status: 42 CHW HIV+ (20 %) Method of diagnosing TB: Smear and culture testing |
Prevalence of active TB disease 5 % (10/215; 2008–2009) |
|
| Naidoo et al. [24] | Date of study not reported Western Cape Number of participants: 100 randomly selected practicing dentists; 78 % response rate. Age: Mean = 40 years Sex: 80 % male HIV status: Not reported Method of diagnosing TB: Mantoux and multipuncture tests |
Prevalence of latent TB infection 33 % (No dates provided) |
|
| Mehtar et al. [29] | Study date: 2010 Retrospective review of OATB case reports at Tygerberg Academic Hospital in the Western Cape Number of participants: 67 cases of OATB reported during study period 2008–2010 Age: Not reported Sex: Not reported HIV status: Not reported Method of TB diagnosis: Smear microscopy |
Number of occupationally acquired TB cases 2008: 27 TB cases (17 ancilliary staff) 2009: 21 TB cases (7 ancilliary staff) 2010: 19 TB cases (13 ancilliary staff) Pulmonary TB among health care workers 38.5 % (2008) 27.8 % (2010) |
|
| Jarand et al. [25] | Study date: 1996–2008 Retrospective case record review of patients with XDR-TB from Eastern and Western Cape provinces Number of participants: 334 XDR-TB patients (10 HCWs with XDR-TB) Median age: 41 (26–50) Sex: 90 % female HIV status: 2/10 HIV+ Method of TB diagnosis: sputum culture |
10 of the 334 patients with diagnosed with XDR-TB between 1996 and 2008 were health care workers | 5/10 were nurses 4/10 HCWs died HCW with XDR TB: 26–50 years old; 60 % nursing staff; 80 % HIV-negative |
| Gauteng | |||
| McCarthy et al. [22] Van Rie et al. [23] |
Study date: 2008–2009 Gauteng Number of participants: 79 medical students and 120 healthcare workers Age: Medical students median age 22 (22–24) HCW median age 36 (28–46) Sex: Medical students = 44 % males HCW = 10 % males HIV status: Medical students = 0 % HIV+; HCW = 18.3 % HIV+ Method of diagnosing latent TB: TST and IGRA assay (Quantiferon-TB Gold In-tube) |
Incidence of latent TB infection (2008–2009) 26 % (29 per 100 personyears, 95%CI: 20–44, IGRA) 27 % (29 per 100 person years, 95%CI: 19–42, TST) Prevalence of latent TB infection (2008) 45 % (95%CI: 38–53; IGRA+) 48 % (95%CI: 42–57; TST+) Incidence of active TB disease (2008–2009) 1.8/100 person years (95%CI: 0.45–7.2) among HCWs |
HCWs LTBI prevalence was two-to four-fold higher than medical students TST: 56.7 % vs. 26.6 % IGRA: 69.2 % vs. 15.2 % |
| Limpopo | |||
| Malangu et al. [5] | Study date: not reported Data on health care acquired infection submitted to the Compensation Commissioner of the Limpopo province by a health care worker Number of participants: 56 cases of infectious diseases reported over 2 years. Age: 42.7 years (mean) Sex: 67.9 % female HIV status: Not reported Method of TB diagnosis: Unclear |
2007–2009: Of the 56 reported cases of infectious diseases 47 (83.9 %) were TB cases. 30/47 TB cases were nurses 8/47 TB cases were cleaning staff |
Among health professionals, nurses most likely to acquire TB disease; Among non-health professionals cleaning staff most likely to acquired TB disease Cases were defined as reports about any healthcare acquired infection as submitted for compensation by healthcare workers of Limpopo province. |
| Mpumalanga | |||
| Balt et al. [26] | Study date: Not reported Study setting: 4 dedicated TB centres (SANTA centres) in Mpumalanga Details of study participants and method of TB diagnosis not reported |
Annual incidence of TB disease (1986–1997) 275/100 000 (95 % confidence interval: 33–991) Between 1986 and 1997: 2 nurses with active TB |
The incidence of TB in the general population of Mpumalanga at the time estimated to be 286/100 000 Affected nurses were 36 and 56 years old; both nurses had non-insulin dependant diabetes |