Table 5.
First Author and Reference |
Study Design | No. Treated With FLQ/Total |
Age | Indication | FLQ | Duration of FLQ Exposure |
Duration of Follow-Up |
Incidence of FLQ-Associated MSK Event |
Description of Events |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Schaad 198775 | Retrospective observational study | 11 | 0.3–9.6 years | Urinary tract infections (UTI) | Nalidixic acid | 9–600 days | 3–12 years | No difference with comparator group | Episodes of arthralgia were judged to have no relation to the drugs. |
Rumler 198774 | Retrospective study | 207/408 | 1–7.2 years, mean 6.5 years | Chronic UTI | Nalidixic acid | 27–1689 days, mean 168 days | 10 years | 0% | No adverse effects to hip or knee joints. |
Adam 198972 | Retrospective study | 50/100 | 0.1–11 years, mean 4.8 years | Unknown | Nalidixic acid | 10–815 days, mean 118 days | 2 years | 0% | Neither group showed evidence of joint damage confirmed by radiographic imaging. |
Kuhn 1990108 | Retrospective study | 396 | <18 years | Cystic fibrosis (CF) | Ciprofloxacin | 5–48 days, mean 9.2 days | Unknown | 2.5% | Reversible arthralgia, all tolerated subsequent courses with FLQ. |
Schaad 199278 | Prospective review | 18 | 6–24 years | CF exacerbation | Ciprofloxacin | 90 days | 22 months | 0% | No evidence of arthropathies or joint abnormalities confirmed by radiological and MRI studies. |
Danisovicova 1994109 | Prospective observational study | 14/29 | 4–18 years | CF-related infections | Ciprofloxacin Ofloxacin | 4–28 days 1 | week–16 months | 43% | Transient arthralgia. Changes on MRI were seen in both groups at high rates. |
Nuutinen 199473 | Controlled follow-up | 78 | <15 years | Recurrent UTI | Nalidixic acid | 6–570 days, mean 86 days | 14.8–24.7 years, mean 19.6 years | No difference with comparator group | No growth disturbances were found. |
Pradhan 199566 | Case series | 58 | 8 months–13 years | Fever ≥7 days, Salmonella typhi infection | Ciprofloxacin | 9–16 days | 10–15 days to 37 months | 0% | No evidence of joint swellings, arthralgia or restriction of movements. |
Bethell 1996110 | Prospective cohort study | 326/549 | 1–14 years | Typhoid fever | Ciprofloxacin Ofloxacin | 3–7 days | 2 years | 0% | No evidence of acute joint toxicity. Height velocity was similar to control group at end of follow-up. |
Richard 199777 | Randomized, controlled trial | 55/108 | 5–17 years | Bronchopulmonary infections, CF | Ciprofloxacin | 14 days | 20–30 days | No difference with comparator group | Arthralgia and extremity pain. |
Church 1997111 | Prospective, randomized trial | 41/84 | 5–17 years | CF exacerbation | Ciprofloxacin | Median 13 days | 14–28 days | No difference with comparator group | Arthralgia of mild to moderate severity, majority resolved without intervention. |
Jick 1997112 | Retrospective study | 1733 | <17 years | Variety of infections | Ciprofloxacin | Unknown | 45 days | 0% | No new cases of acute arthritis or joint toxicity. |
Hampel 199739 | Safety report | 1795 | <17 years | Compassionate use | Ciprofloxacin | 1–303 days | Unknown | 1.50% | Mild to moderate arthralgia, typically self-resolving. |
Salam 1998113 | Randomized, controlled trial | 71/143 | 2–15 years | Shigellosis | Ciprofloxacin | 5 days | 180 days | 18%, no difference with comparator group | Arthralgia, no patients had signs of arthritis. |
Leibovitz 200027 | Randomized, controlled trial | 95/201 | 6 months–10 years | Acute invasive diarrhea | Ciprofloxacin | 3 days | 21 ± 5 days | 1% | One patient developed bilateral knee arthralgia within hours of treatment, but subsided without intervention after a few hours. Therapy was not discontinued. |
Saez-Llorens 200236 | Randomized trial | 108/203 | 3–12 years | Bacterial meningitis | Trovafloxacin | 5–14 days | 6–12 months | No difference with comparator group | Transient arthralgia and joint abnormalities. MRI in patient with joint inflammation negative for arthropathy, later resolved. |
Yee 2002114 | Observational | 7897 | <19 years | Variety of infections | Ofloxacin, Levofloxacin, Ciprofloxacin | Unknown | 60 days | 50 verified cases (<1%) | Most frequently involved the joint, tendon, cartilage and gait disorder. |
Zimbabwe BSADSG 2002115 | Randomized, controlled trial | 253 | 1–12 years | Shigella | Ciprofloxacin | 3–5 days | 14 days | 3.5% | Mild arthralgia with normal joint function at follow-up. |
Chalumeau 200340 | Prospective, comparative cohort study | 264/525 | <19 years | Variety of infections | Ciprofloxacin Ofloxacin Pefloxacin | 1–327 days | 15 days | 3.8% vs 0.4% (greater than comparator group) | Transient arthralgia of large joints or myalgia; no tendinopathy was observed. |
Ciprofloxacin Package Insert 200523 | Prospective, comparative study | 335/684 | 1–17 years | Complicated UTIs and pyelonephrtitis | Ciprofloxacin | 10–21 days | 1 year | 13.7% vs 9.5% (statistically greater than comparator group) | Mild to moderate arthralgia, typically self-resolving within 30 days of end of treatment. |
Sher 2005116 | Randomized, comparative study | 176/354 | 6 months–7 years | Otitis media (AOM) | Gatifloxacin | 10 days | 12 months | 0% | No evidence of abnormal joint or gait findings. |
Pichichero 200588 | Review of data from clinical trials | 867 | 6 months–7 ears | AOM | Gatifloxacin | 10 days | 12 months (n = 671) | No difference with comparator group | Transient arthralgia, self-resolving. No evidenceof arthropathy. |
Bradley 200728 | Open-label, active-comparator, non-inferiority trial | 405/539 | 6 months–16 years | Community acquired pneumonia (CAP) | Levofloxacin | 10 days | 25–35 days | No difference with comparator group | Arthralgia and myalgia. |
Noel 200782 | Database review of three clinical trials | 2233 | 6 months–16 years | CAP or AOM | Levofloxacin | 7–14 days | 1 year | 3.4% vs 1.8% (statistically greater than comparator group) | Myalgia, arthralgia, pathologic fracture, arthropathy, and pain in extremity. Incidence appeared to increase over time. |
Pinon 201084 | Case series | 2 | 11,23 months | Multidrug-resistant tuberculosis (TB) | Moxifloxacin | Unknown | 18 months | 0% | No evidence of adverse effects. |
Chauny 201285 | Case series | 6 | 9 months–14 years | TB | Moxifloxacin, Levofloxacin | 1–16 months | Unknown | 2 patients | Patient 1 had polyarthritis 1 month after starting therapy, which resolved after stopping. Patient 2 had arthralgia after 4 days, but symptoms spontaneously resolved while on treatment. |
Garazzino 201486 | Case series | 9 | 6 months–13 years | Pulmonary TB | Moxifloxacin | 3–13.4 months | 0–36 months | 1 patient | One case of ankle arthritis after 3 months of therapy that spontaneously resolved after discontinuation. |
Bradley 201483 | Follow-up safety study | 124/207 | 6 months–16 years | CAP or AOM | Levofloxacin | 7–14 days | 5 years | <1% | Transient arthralgia of knee and elbow, synovitis of hip. |
FLQ, fluoroquinolone; MSK, musculoskeletal.