Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2017 Jul 1.
Published in final edited form as: Environ Int. 2015 Dec 13;92-93:597–604. doi: 10.1016/j.envint.2015.10.011

Table 1. Characteristics and Risks of Bias of Included Studies by Sponsorship Source (n=51).

Characteristic Category Sponsorship Source
Any Industry (N =12) Non-Industry (N =29) No Disclosure (N =10)
Risk of Bias3 Randomization 6 15 5
Concealment of allocation 0 0 0
Blinded outcome assessment 4 4 0
Inclusion/exclusion criteria 0 2 0
Sample size calculation 0 0 0
Test animal description 12 29 10
Animal environment described 12 29 9
Exposure levels justified 4 19 5
Optimal time window investigated 1 0 0
All animals accounted for 2 3 2
Compliant with animal welfare requirements 7 16 3
Financial conflict of interest Yes 1 0 0
No 4 4 1
No disclosure 7 25 9
Author affiliation Combined 3 1 1
Non-industry employed 9 28 8
Industry 0 0 1