Table 3.
Experimental condition | Rank | RefFinder | ΔCt | geNorm | NormFinder | BestKeeper | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Gene | GMa) | Gene | SDb) | Gene | Mc) | Gene | SVd) | Gene | re) | ||
Acaricide resistance selection | 1 | CycA | 1.86 | CycA | 0.27 | Rp49/Rpl18 | 0.20 | CycA | 0.10 | GAPDH | 0.911 |
2 | Rp49 | 2.56 | GAPDH | 0.28 | - | - | GAPDH | 0.15 | CycA | 0.894 | |
3 | GAPDH | 2.63 | Rp49 | 0.29 | GAPDH | 0.21 | Rp49 | 0.19 | Rp49 | 0.858 | |
4 | Rpl18 | 3.13 | Rpl18 | 0.32 | CycA | 0.22 | Rpl18 | 0.24 | Actin | 0.828 | |
5 | TUB | 3.34 | TUB | 0.34 | TUB | 0.27 | TUB | 0.26 | Rpl18 | 0.790 | |
6 | Ef1α | 5.12 | Actin | 0.37 | Actin | 0.30 | Actin | 0.31 | TUB | 0.504 | |
7 | Actin | 6.24 | Ef1α | 0.37 | Ef1α | 0.32 | Ef1α | 0.31 | Ef1α | 0.332 | |
Host plant shift | 1 | GAPDH | 2.00 | GAPDH | 0.82 | Rp49/Rpl18 | 0.10 | GAPDH | 0.20 | GAPDH | 0.989 |
2 | Rp49 | 2.06 | CycA | 0.87 | - | - | CycA | 0.44 | Ef1α | 0.980 | |
3 | Rpl18 | 2.63 | Rp49 | 0.87 | CycA | 0.34 | Rp49 | 0.62 | CycA | 0.973 | |
4 | CycA | 2.78 | Rpl18 | 0.88 | GAPDH | 0.42 | Rpl18 | 0.65 | TUB | 0.963 | |
5 | Actin | 4.30 | TUB | 1.16 | TUB | 0.75 | TUB | 0.93 | Rp49 | 0.953 | |
6 | TUB | 5.23 | Ef1α | 1.26 | Ef1α | 0.90 | Ef1α | 1.08 | Rpl18 | 0.949 | |
7 | Ef1α | 6.24 | Actin | 1.36 | Actin | 1.03 | Actin | 1.16 | Actin | 0.838 | |
Both conditions | 1 | GAPDH | 2.11 | GAPDH | 0.61 | Rp49/Rpl18 | 0.21 | GAPDH | 0.22 | GAPDH | 0.987 |
2 | Rp49 | 2.28 | CycA | 0.62 | - | - | CycA | 0.29 | CycA | 0.984 | |
3 | Rpl18 | 2.38 | Rp49 | 0.64 | CycA | 0.31 | Rp49 | 0.42 | Ef1α | 0.979 | |
4 | CycA | 2.63 | Rpl18 | 0.67 | GAPDH | 0.35 | Rpl18 | 0.47 | Rp49 | 0.973 | |
5 | Actin | 4.30 | TUB | 0.82 | TUB | 0.56 | TUB | 0.63 | Rpl18 | 0.969 | |
6 | TUB | 5.23 | Ef1α | 0.92 | Ef1α | 0.67 | Ef1α | 0.79 | TUB | 0.967 | |
7 | Ef1α | 6.24 | Actin | 1.00 | Actin | 0.76 | Actin | 0.86 | Actin | 0.901 |
a)GM: Geometric Mean; b) SD: Standard Deviation of comparative ΔCt; c) M: Average of expression stability values; d) SV: Stability Value; e) r: Pearson's correlation coefficient.