Table 2.
Study | CtDNA platform | Markers | Stage of disease | Time of sampling | Number of patients, n | Markers detected, n |
Zhou et al[32] 2011 | Nested RT-PCR | H-tert, C-MET, CK20, CEA mRNAs | All stages | Pre-treatment | 25 | H-TERT 25/25 (100%) |
CMET 20/25(80%), CK20 21/25 (84%), CEA 20/25 (80%) | ||||||
de Albuquerque et al[22] 2012 | Immunomagnetic RT-PCR | KRT19, MUC1, EpCAM, CEACAM5, BIRC5 | Stage III and IV | Pre-treatment | 34 | 16/34 (47%) |
Chausovsky et al[33] 1999 | RT-PCR | CK20 | Metastatic | Not stated | 28 | 22/28 (79%) |
Sausen et al[28] 2015 | Digital PCR | KRAS | Localised | Pre-treatment | 51 | 22/51 (43%) |
Earl et al[27] 2015 | Digital PCR | KRAS | All stages | Pre-treatment (NB 7 patients had received chemotherapy) | 31 | 8/31 (26%) |
Sergeant et al[31] 2011 | RT-PCR | EpCAM | Stage I,II and 4 | Pre and post treatment | 40 | 10/40 (25%) preoperatively, |
10/35(28.6%) D1, 9/39 (23.1%) at D7, 8/34 (23.5%) at 6 wk | ||||||
Bettegowda et al[26] 2014 | Digital PCR | KRAS, NRAS, PIK3CA, BRAF | Localised and metastatic | Not stated | 155 | 48% of those with localised and > 80% metastatic disease |
Zill et al[30] 2015 | NGS | KRAS, TP53, APC, SMAD4, FBXW7 | Localised and metastatic | Post-treatment | 17 | 17/17 (100%) |
Kinugasa et al[29] 2015 | Digital PCR | KRAS | All stages | Pre-treatment | 75 | 47/75 (62%) |
CtDNA: Circulating tumour DNA; RT-PCR: Reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction.