Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2017 Nov 1.
Published in final edited form as: Dev Sci. 2015 Aug 25;19(6):1049–1057. doi: 10.1111/desc.12342

Table 1.

Coding Categories

Aspect Definition Codes Examples of each code
Studies 1 and 2
Force Event involved the application
of abrupt force to another
person’s body
Forceful C. hits mother
C. bites sibling
Non-forceful C. flails arms but does not hit
Type of act The motoric nature of the
forceful act
Biting
Hitting w/ hand
Hitting w/ object
Shoving
Other
-
-
-
-
-
Purposeful Application of force was not
accidental
Purposeful C. looks at victim before hitting
C. kisses parent’s arm then bites
Accidental C. knocks object off table onto pet
C. runs into sibling without looking
Provocation Application of force was
preceded by a frustration of the
C.’s desire
Provoked C. is kept from toy, then hits
C. hits sibling after sibling takes toy
Unprovoked C. suddenly hits sibling
C. walks over to parent and bites
Distress C. shows facial or vocal sign of
distress
Distress C. cries before hitting
C. screams angrily while pulling hair
No distress C. shows no distress before hitting
Target Who was the target (victim) of
C.’s act of force?
Parent
Sibling
Pet
Other
-
-
-
-

Study 2 only
Type of
provocation
What type of provocation
preceded the act of force?
Physical
obstruction
C. is picked up and carried away
Mother blocks C.’s access to room
Property conflict Sibling pushes C. from computer
C. tries to take sibling’s toy
Other Parent says C. can’t have snacks
Parent refuses to let C. watch TV
Type of
unprovoked
force
What kind of unprovoked use of
force did the infant engage in?
Exploration C. looks to parent after hitting
C. simply picks up truck and hits sibling with it
Miscalibration C. pets cat, but too forcefully
C. hands object to parent so hard it hurts parent
Other C. uses force as part of a game
Reaction to
force
How did victim and others react
verbally to forceful act?
Pain (victim)
Prohibition
Gentle
“Ow! That hurts mommy”
“No, we don’t hit!”
“Gentle touch!”

Notes. C. = Child.