Table 1. Characteristics of the 22 included studies in this meta-analysis.
Reference | Nation | Clinical type | OLP(n/N) | Control(n/N) | Detection method | HPV genotypes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Pol CA et al., 2015 | India | 21/30 | 0/30 | IHC | HPV16 | |
Arirachakaran P et al., 2013 | Thailand | 1/37 | 0/37 | PCR | NA | |
Yildirim B et al., 2011 | Turkey | 14/65 | 0/15 | IHC | HPV16 | |
Debanth S et al., 2009 | India | 6/6 | 3/35 | PCR | HPV16, 18, 31, 33, 35, 39, 45, 51,52, 56, 58, 59,68 | |
Fehér E et al., 2009 | Hungary | 39/119 | 3/72 | PCR | HPV6.11.16.18.31.33 | |
Razavi SM et al., 2009 | Iran | 9/29 | 1/14 | PCR | HPV18 | |
Szarka K et al., 2009 | Hungary | 39/119 | 3/72 | PCR | NA | |
EA-OLP | 26/61 | 3/72 | ||||
non-EA-OLP | 13/58 | 3/72 | ||||
Yu Hong et al., 2007 | China | 33/57 | 3/20 | PCR | HPV16 | |
Cianfriglia F et al., 2006 | Italy | 3/15 | 2/10 | ISH | NA | |
Giovannelli L et al., 2006 | Italy | 12/49 | 11/49 | PCR | NA | |
Campisi G et al., 2004 | Italy | 14/71 | 5/90 | PCR | HPV16.18.31.6 | |
EA-OLP | 9/44 | 5/90 | ||||
non-EA-OLP | 5/27 | 5/90 | ||||
Ma Jian et al., 2003 | China | 26/30 | 5/18 | PCR | NA | |
OFlatharta C et al., 2003 | Ireland | 10/38 | 0/20 | PCR | HPV16 | |
Giovannelli L et al., 2002 | Italy | 9/34 | 5/90 | PCR | NA | |
Li Hui et al., 2000 | China | 9/30 | 3/40 | PCR | NA | |
Sand L et al., 2000 | Sweden | 6/22 | 0/12 | NA | NA | |
Qi Yanchun et al., 1999 | China | 9/30 | 3/40 | PCR | NA | |
Lei Lei et al., 1997 | China | 9/22 | 2/10 | PCR | NA | |
EA-OLP | 3/4 | 2/10 | ||||
non-EA-OLP | 6/18 | 2/10 | ||||
Vespe M et al., 1997 | Germany | 3/7 | 0/33 | PCR | HPV16.18.31 | |
Boyd AS et al., 1996 | USA | 11/13 | 0/10 | PCR | NA | |
Cox M et al., 1993 | UK | 3/4 | 3/5 | PCR | HPV16 | |
Maitland NJ et al., 1987 | UK | 7/8 | 5/12 | PCR | HPV16 |
n: numbers of HPV positive subjects; N: numbers of total subjects; IHC: immunohistochemical staining; PCR: polymerase chain reaction; ISH: in situ hybridization; NA: not available; EA-OLP: erosive-atrophic oral lichen planus; non-EA-OLP: non-erosive-atrophic oral lichen planus.