Table 2.
Category | Ivanovski et al. [ 34 ] | Donos et al. 2011 [ 35 ] | Bryington et al. [ 36 ] | Thalji et al. [ 37 ] |
---|---|---|---|---|
Study design | ||||
Comparison | None (only SLActive) | SLA vs. SLActive | TiOBlast vs. Osseospeed | TiOBlast vs. Osseospeed |
Setting | University | University | University | University |
Population, inclusion criteria | 9 healthy volunteers with no mandibular third molars, no contraindications for oral surgery; age 21 to 48, median 29 years | 9 healthy volunteers with no mandibular third molars; age 21 to 48, median 29 years | 6 women, 4 men; implant patients, systemically healthy (no HTN, diabetes, CVD); age 25 to 58, mean 36.2 years | 9 women, 2 men; implant patients, systemically healthy; age 47 to 69, mean 60.2 years |
Exclusion criteria | Smokers | Smokers | Smokers, pregnancy, periodontal/periapical disease, subjects taking bisphosphonates, hormone replacement therapy, corticosteroids | Smokers, uncontrolled diabetes, history of head/neck radiotherapy, taking corticosteroids, bisphosphonates |
Comparability of groups | Unclear | Unclear | Unclear | Unclear |
Potential confounders, e.g., post-op medication | Unclear | Unclear | Unclear | Unclear |
Power calculation | No | No | No | No |
Statistical correction | For multiple sampling | For multiple sampling | Unclear | For multiple sampling |
Methods | ||||
Tissue analyzed | Peri-implant tissue | Peri-implant tissue | Implant-adherent cells | Implant-adherent cells |
Genetic material analyzed | Total RNA | Total RNA | Total RNA | Total RNA |
Success rate | Unclear | 16/18 samples (88.8%) | 7/10 subject samples (70%) | Unclear |
Genotyping method | Microarray | Microarray | RT-PCR | Whole-genome microarray |
Genotype counts | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Blinding | Unclear | Unclear | Yes | Unclear |
Reproducibility, validated genotyping accuracy | No | No | No | No |
All studies were judged to be at a high risk of bias with substantial heterogeneity across studies.