Skip to main content
. 2016 Aug 4;8(8):e723. doi: 10.7759/cureus.723

Table 1. Literature Map.

TFEI = Transforaminal epidural injections; ILEI = Interlaminar lumbar epidural injections; CEI = Caudal epidural injections; LEI = Lumbar epidural injections; NA = Not available; FU = Follow-up.

Study Study Design Injection Mean Age Sample Size Gender (%) Diagnosis Pain Duration (Weeks) Maximum FU (Months)
Females Males
Sayegh (2009) [25] Prospective, randomized, double-blind clinical trial CEI  without steroid 49.12 183 32.78% 67.23% Lumbar radicular pain and sciatica >4 12
Ghahreman (2010) [3] Prospective, randomized study TFEI with steroid 49.5 150 40.66% 59.30% Lumbar disc herniation 12 12
Manchikanti (2014 A) [17] Randomized, controlled, double-blind, active control trial TFEI with or without steroids 42.85 120 50% 50% Lumbar disc herniation and radiculitis 24 24
Manchikanti (2014 B) [12] Randomized, controlled, double-blind, active control trial. LIEI with or without steroids 44.5 120 69.20% 30.80% Lumbar disc herniation and radiculitis 24 24
Manchikanti (2011) [21] Randomized, controlled, double-blind trial CEI without steroid 45.85 120 65% 35% Lumbar disc herniation and radiculitis 24 12
Manson (2013) [18] Retrospective TFEI with steroids 45.8 91 41.75% 58.24% Lumbar disc herniation and/or radiculopathy 6 26.6
Manchikanti (2008) [26] A randomized, double-blind, equivalence trial. CEI without steroid 47.05 84 66.60% 33.33% Lumbar disc herniation and radiculitis 24 12
Owlia (2007) [28] Comparative study LEI with steroid 38.2 84 57.14% 42.80% Lumbar radicular pain >2 3
Kennedy (2014) [1] Multicenter, double-blind, prospective, randomized trial TFEI with steroids 35.75 78 34.61% 65.38% Unilateral radicular pain 8 6
Manchikanti (2010) [23] Randomized, double-blind, controlled trial LIEI with injections 41.95 70 65.71% 34.26% Lumbar radicular pain 24 12
Helvoirt (2014) [16] Prospective cohort study TFEI with steroids 47.3 69 50.70% 49.30% Lumbar disc herniation 20 12
Rados (2011) [22] Randomized prospective study TFEI & LIEI  with steroid 49.2 64 35.90% 64.10% Chronic lumbar radicular pain caused by herniated disc 12 6
Spijker-Huiges (2014) [2] Randomized controlled trial TFEI with steroids 43.7 63 47.61% 52.38% Lumbosacral radicular syndrome 2-4 13
Gomez (2007) [27] Retrospective LIEI with steroid 47 60 50% 50% Lumbosciatic pain 24-48 6
Baral (2011) [20] Prospective observational study TFEI with steroid 41.04 50 48% 52% Lumbar disc herniation NA 6
Kawu (2012) [19] Prospective-controlled observational study TFEI & LIEI with steroids 47.6 49 NA NA Lumbar disc herniation 31.2 6
Schaufele (2006) [29] Retrospective LIEI Versus TFEI without steroid NA 40 NA NA Lumbar intravertebral disc herniation 2-48 12
Laiq (2009) [24] Quasi-experimental study LEI with steroid 40.5 25 68% 32% Lumbar radicular pain 2 6
Yang (2006) [30] Prospective TFEI with steroid 50 19 42.10% 57.89% Sciatica with unilateral symptoms 8-96 24