Table 2.
technique | shorthand | values solved | pros | cons | RNA examples | ref |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
electrophoretic mobility shift assay | EMSA | Kd | low-cost equipment | often requires P-32 radiolabel | HOTAIRb; Xistb | 71 |
filter-binding assay | Kd | straight-forward method; efficient | requires radiolabeling (P-32); nonspecific binding to filter; aggregation of materials not related to native binding event | HOTAIRb | 89 | |
surface plasmon resonance | SPR | Kd | label-free | target immobilization; cannot report on 2+ state binding model | PARTICLEb | 90 |
isothermal titration calorimetry | ITC | n, Kd, ΔH, ΔG, ΔS | label-free; kinetic and thermodynamic information; can report on 2+ state systems | high concentrations of materials | HIV-1 TARc; purine riboswitchc; 16S rRNAc | 91–93 |
Förster resonance energy transfer | FRET | n, Kd | relatively cheap; can measure distance relationship; sensitive | requires FRET pairs that do not interfere with RNA structure; depends on conformational change and may miss static binding events. | rRNAc, tRNAc | 94 |
fluorescence polarization/anisotropy | FP/FA | n, Kd, aggregation, folding dynamics | no energy transfer requirement; can be HTP | requires fluorescent labeling; binding must significantly change the size of the fluorophore-labeled molecule | Tetrahymena Group I Intron Ribozymec | 95, 96 |
HTP = high-throughput; n = Hill’s coefficient; Kd = dissociation constant; ΔH = change in enthalpy; ΔS = change in entropy; ΔG = change in Gibb’s free energy.
Long ncRNA example.
Other ncRNA example.