Skip to main content
. 2016 Sep 7;6:32722. doi: 10.1038/srep32722

Table 1. Characteristics of included studies.

Study Year Number
Mean age Intervention
Duration Outcomes
experiment control (years) experiment control (weeks)
(mg/day) (mg/day)
Yang J et al.29 2012 30 30 50.7 0.5 ADV 10 48 A/B/C/D/E
30 UC LAM 100 48 A/B/C/D/E
30 UC CT 48 A/B/C/D/E
Lin XS et al.23 2011 32 32 49.7 0.5 CT 72 A/E/F
Ren WX et al.30 2014 27 27 48 0.5 CT 48 A/B/D/E
Luo HB et al.31 2009 48 48 54.9 0.5 CT 48 A/B
Ning ZH et al.32 2009 37 38 47.5 0.5 CT 24 A/B/F
Han ZQ et al.24 2009 30 30 56.2 0.5 CT 24 A/B/D/E/F
Chen FZ et al.16 2010 26 26 48.5 0.5 LAM 100 48 A/B/F
Zhang FL33 2011 28 26 45.6 0.5 CT 24 A/B/D
Zhang RL34 2010 18 18 UC 0.5 CT 24 A/B/E/F
Guo YM et al.35 2014 42 42 UC 0.5 CT 24 A/B/D/E
Yang J et al.9 2012 40 40 46.6 0.5 ADV 10 48 A/B/E/F
Li H36 2009 20 20 UC 0.5 CT 24 A/B/D/E
Xu Y22 2013 43 43 50.1 0.5 LDT 600 and ADV10 48 A/B/D
Feng J et al.37 2008 22 25 UC 0.5 LAM 100 48 A/B/D/F
25 UC ADV10 48 A/B/D/F
24 UC CT 48 A/B/D/F
Zhang DH et al.18 2011 27 27 UC 0.5 LAM 100 48 A/B/D/F
27 UC ADV 10 48 A/B/D/F
24 UC CT 48 A/B/D/F
Liaw et al.8 2011 100 91 51 1 ADV 10 96 A/B/F
Liaw yf et al.13 2011 22 45 54 0.5or1 TDF 300 48 A/B/F
Yang L38 2015 40 40 UC 0.5 LAM 100 48 C/E
Gulizire•Maola39 2015 35 35 UC 0.5 CT 48 A/B/C/D
Hu XM19 2014 36 36 46.5 0.5 LAM 100 1 year A/B/C/F
Zhang J40 2014 27 27 UC 0.5 CT 48 A/B
Zhao ZY41 2014 36 36 UC 0.5 CT 48 A/B/E
Li MX42 2014 48 48 UC 0.5 CT 48 A/B/G
Zhou XL et al.43 2015 44 44 UC 0.5 CT 24 A/B/C/E
Bi YL20 2014 43 48 UC 0.5 LAM 100 and ADV 10 48 A/B/C/D
Shao JB et al.21 2010 29 28 43.6 0.5 LAM 100 96 A/E

UC: unclear; CT: comprehensive therapy (patients who did not use any NAs); A: HBV DNA; B: Hepatic function; C: Adverse Drug Reaction; D: Mortality; E: Child-pugh; F: HBeAg seroconversion; G: hepatitis B virus mutation rate.