Table 3.
Secondary outcome analyses with observed dataa.
|
|
iTAU (a) mean (SD) |
CSG (b) mean (SD) |
LITG (c) mean (SD) |
g
(a-b) |
P
(a-b) |
B (95% CI) (a-b) |
g
(a-c) |
P
(a-c) |
B (95% CI) (a-c) |
g
(b-c) |
P
(b-c) |
B (95% CI) (b-c) |
|
| Mental SF-12 | n=64 | n=55 | n=64 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Time 0 | 29.13 (11.18) |
28.59 (8.90) |
27.95 (8.78) |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Time 1 | 35.41 (12.19) |
34.72 (12.46) |
36.97 (12.57) |
0.06 | .380 | -1.83 (-5.91 to 2.25) |
-0.13 | .682 | 0.85 (-3.20 to 4.89) |
-0.18 | .216 | 2.63 (-1.54 to 6.80) |
|
|
Adjusted |
|
|
|
|
.341 | -1.94 (-5.94 to 2.06) |
|
.589 | 1.10 (-2.87 to 5.06) |
|
.187 | 3.01 (-1.06 to 7.07) |
|
|
Time 2 | 36.05 (12.38) |
42.35 (11.03) |
42.22 (13.24) |
-0.53 | .003 | 6.49 (2.26 to 10.72) |
-0.48 | .005 | 5.97 (1.80 to 10.13) |
0.01 | .801 | -0.56 (-4.89 to 3.78) |
|
|
Adjusted |
|
|
|
|
.002 | 6.67 (2.53 to 10.81) |
|
.002 | 6.41 (2.33- 10.49) |
|
.863 | -0.37 (-4.59 to 3.85) |
|
|
Time 3 | 36.35 (12.12) |
43.44 (11.66) |
43.65 (13.41) |
-0.59 | .002 | 6.78 (2.46 to 11.11) |
-0.57 | .003 | 6.53 (2.29 to 10.76) |
-0.02 | .901 | -0.28 (-4.69 to 4.12) |
|
|
Adjusted |
|
|
|
|
.001 | 7.03 (2.80 to 11.26) |
|
.001 | 7.09 (2.95 to 11.24) |
|
.989 | -0.03 (-4.31 to 4.25) |
| Physical SF-12 | n=64 | n=55 | n=64 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Time 0 | 48.74 (11.67) |
47.83 (12.29) |
47.98 (10.87) |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Time 1 | 47.91 (10.31) |
48.84 (11.89) |
49.20 (10.58) |
-0.08 | .443 | 1.13 (-1.76 – 4.02) |
-0.12 | .638 | 0.69 (-2.17 – 3.54) |
-0.03 | .760 | -0.44 (-3.26 – 2.38) |
|
|
Adjusted |
|
|
|
|
.382 | 1.23 (-1.53 – 4.00) |
|
.542 | 0.85 (-1.89 – 3.60) |
|
.799 | -0.35 (-3.02 – 2.33) |
|
|
Time 2 | 47.56 (10.74) |
47.42 (12.18) |
46.87 (10.79) |
0.01 | .820 | 0.35 (-2.66 to 3.35) |
0.06 | .906 | -0.18 (-3.13 to 2.77) |
0.05 | .727 | -0.52 (-3.46 – 2.41) |
|
|
Adjusted |
|
|
|
|
.677 | 0.61 (-2.26 to 3.47) |
|
.946 | 0.10 (-2.72 to 2.92) |
|
.727 | -0.49 (-3.27 – 2.28) |
|
|
Time 3 | 47.53 (11.78) |
47.65 (11.89) |
48.05 (9.85) |
-0.01 | .864 | 0.27 (-2.81 to 3.34) |
-0.05 | .655 | 0.68 (-2.32 to 3.68) |
-0.04 | .781 | 0.42 (-2.56 to 3.41) |
|
|
Adjusted |
|
|
|
|
.830 | 0.32 (-2.61 to 3.25) |
|
.620 | 0.73 (-2.14 to 3.59) |
|
.755 | 0.45 (-2.37 to 3.27) |
| EuroQol VAS | n=66 | n=57 | n=65 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Time 0 | 57.80 (15.81) |
53.56 (20.05) |
57.46 (18.23) |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Time 1 | 62.12 (18.12) |
63.11 (21.61) |
65.85 (21.34) |
-0.05 | .924 | 0.30 (-5.91 to 6.52) |
-0.19 | .418 | 2.55 (-3.61 to 8.70) |
-0.13 | .495 | 2.24 (-4.19 to 8.66) |
|
|
Adjusted |
|
|
|
|
.816 | 0.71 (-5.32 to 6.75) |
|
.385 | 2.66 (-3.33 to 8.64) |
|
.541 | 1.94 (-4.28 to 8.17) |
|
|
Time 2 | 62.33 (20.83) |
65.81 (21.44) |
69.83 (20.21) |
-0.16 | .152 | 4.73 (-1.73 to 11.19) |
-0.36 | .016 | 7.73 (1.38 to 14.09) |
-0.19 | .381 | 2.99 (-3.70 to 9.68) |
|
|
Adjusted |
|
|
|
|
.088 | 5.45 (-0.81 to 11.71) |
|
.013 | 7.84 (1.68 to 14.01) |
|
.478 | 2.34 (-4.13 to 8.81) |
|
|
Time 3 | 62.59 (20.37) |
68.89 (22.79) |
72.45 (15.93) |
-0.29 | .028 | 7.39 (0.82 to 13.97) |
-0.54 | .014 | 8.10 (1.65 to 14.54) |
-0.18 | .842 | 0.69 (-6.09 to 7.47) |
|
|
Adjusted |
|
|
|
|
.011 | 8.31 (1.94 to 14.44) |
|
.010 | 8.19 (1.95 to 14.44) |
|
.970 | -0.13 (-6.68 to 6.43) |
ag: Hedge’s g as an effect size measure; B: regression coefficients; adjusted: adjusted analysis controlling baseline, sex, and age; a-b: iTAU vs CSG comparison; a-c: iTAU vs LITG comparison; b-c: CSG vs LITG comparison.