Table 1.
Drug | Sample(s) | Study design(s) | Intervention dosing and duration |
Outcome measures | Level of Evidencea |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Alcohol Withdrawal Syndrome | |||||
Benzodiazepines | Consensus Guidelines; there are no controlled treatment studies examining pharmacotherapy for adolescent AW or AWS. |
Grade C (level 3 evidence) for AWS |
|||
Alcohol Use Disorder | |||||
Naltrexone (oral) |
Outpatient, treatment-seeking, adolescents (mean age = 13.2 years); Non-treatment- seeking heavy drinkers (ages 15– 19); 2 studies, n= 27 total subjects |
6-week, open-label, clinical study; 4-week double-blind, placebo controlled cross-over study using EMA |
Naltrexone, oral, flexible dose, 25–50 mg daily; Naltrexone, oral, fixed dose, 50 mg daily |
Self-report alcohol use (time-line follow-back methods and EMA); A- OCDS; alcohol craving; subjective- response to alcohol |
Grade C (level 3 evidence) for AUD |
Disulfiram | Post- detoxification, outpatient, treatment-seeking adolescents (ages 16–19); 1 study, n= 26 subjects |
90-day, randomized double-blind, placebo controlled study |
Disulfiram, oral, fixed dose, 200 mg daily |
Self-report alcohol use | Grade C (level 3 evidence) for AUD |
Ondansetron | Outpatient, treatment-seeking, adolescents (ages 14–20); 1 study, n= 12 subjects |
8-week, open-label, clinical study |
Ondansetron, oral, fixed dose, 4 micrograms/kg two times per day |
Self-report alcohol use; adverse events |
Grade C (level 3 evidence) for AUD |
Topiramate | Non-treatment seeking, heavy drinkers (mean age = 19 years); 1 study, n= 13 subjects |
5-week, randomized, placebo controlled, pilot study using EMA |
Topiramate, oral, escalating dose, up to 200 mg per day |
Self-report alcohol use (EMA); alcohol craving; subjective- response to alcohol |
Grade C (level 3 evidence) for AUD |
Tobacco Use Disorder | |||||
Nicotine Replacement Therapy (patch, gum, nasal spray) |
Outpatient, treatment-seeking adolescents (ages 12–19), smoking ≥ 5 CPDb; 5 studies, n= 728 total subjects |
Meta-analysis, 12-week randomized double- blind, double-placebo controlled study comparing nicotine patch to nicotine gum; 10-week randomized double-blind placebo-controlled study of nicotine patch; 6-to-9- week randomized, double-blind placebo controlled study of nicotine patch; 8-week open-label clinical study of nicotine nasal spray |
Nicotine patch, fixed dose 21 mg (participants smoking ≥ 20 CPD) or 14 mg (< 20 CPD). Nicotine patch, fixed-taper dosing, starting dose 21 mg (participants smoking > 15 CPD) or 14 mg (10–14 CPD) tapered over 10-weeks. Nicotine gum, 4 mg (participants smoking ≥ 24 CPD) or 2 mg (< 24 CPD). Nicotine nasal spray, 1 mg dosing as needed. |
CO–confirmed PPA at EOT; cotinine- confirmed PPA at EOT; nicotine craving; nicotine withdrawal |
Nicotine patch: Grade B (level 2 evidence) for TUD Nicotine gum and nasal spray: Grade C (level 3 evidence) for TUD |
Varenicline | Outpatient, treatment-seeking adolescents (ages 14–20), smoking ≥ 5 CPD; 1 study, n= 29 subjects |
8-week, randomized double-blind controlled study comparing Varenicline to Buproprion XL |
Varenicline, oral, 1 mg two times per day or Buproprione XL, oral, 300 mg daily |
Self-report smoking reduction; cotinine confirmed PPA at EOT |
Grade B (level 2 evidence) for TUD |
Buproprion | Outpatient, treatment-seeking adolescents (ages 12–21), smoking ≥ 5 CPDb; 4 studies, n= 688 total subjects |
Meta-analysis, 8-week, randomized, double- blind, placebo controlled add-on to nicotine patch; 6-week, randomized, double-blind, placebo controlled dose comparison study (150 mg vs. 300 mg) study; 6- week, randomized double-blind, placebo controlled study with added +/− CM; 8-week, randomized double-blind comparison to Varenicline |
Buproprion SR, oral, fixed dose, 150 mg daily or 300 mg daily |
Cotinine-confirmed PPA at EOT; CO- confirmed PPA at EOT; self-report smoking reduction |
Grade B (level 2 evidence) for TUD |
Cannabis Use Disorder | |||||
N-acetylcysteine (NAC) |
Outpatient, treatment-seeking, adolescents (ages 15–21); 2 studies, n= 134 total subjects |
8-week, randomized, double-blind, placebo controlled study added to brief cessation counseling and CM; 4- week open-label pilot study |
NAC, oral, fixed dose, 1200 mg two times per day (2400 mg/day) |
Negative urine cannabinoid test, self- report cannabis use, cravings for cannabis |
Grade B (level 2 evidence) for CUD |
Topiramate | Outpatient, treatment-seeking, youth (ages 15– 24); 1 study, n = 66 |
6-week, randomized, double-blind, placebo controlled pilot study medication added to 3 sessions of motivational enhancement therapy (MET) |
Topiramate, oral, fixed dose, titrated to 200 mg daily over 4 weeks and maintained at 200 mg/day over 2 weeks |
Positive urine cannabinoid test, self- report cannabis use (% days of cannabis use, grams of cannabis use per day), treatment retention, adverse events, neurocognitive functioning |
Grade C (level 3 evidence) for CUD |
Opioid Withdrawal Syndrome | |||||
Buprenorphine and Buprenorphine- naloxone |
Outpatient detoxification, treatment-seeking, adolescents (ages 13–18); 2 studies, n= 188 total subjects |
Systematic review; 28- day randomized, double- blind, double-placebo, controlled study comparing clonidine and buprenorphine detoxification regimens; 12-week randomized multisite clinical trial comparing 2-week detoxification to 12-week maintenance |
Buprenorphine, sublingual, fixed-taper dosing, starting dose 8 mg or 6 mg (age based); Buprenorphine- naloxone (2 mg/0.05 mg ratio), oral, fixed-taper dosing, up to 24 mg daily |
Opiate negative urine tests, treatment retention, self-report HIV-risk behavior, opiate withdrawal symptoms |
Grade B (level 2 evidence) for OWS |
Clonidine (patch) |
Outpatient detoxification, treatment-seeking, adolescents (ages 13–18); 1 study, n= 36 subjects |
28-day randomized, double-blind, double- placebo, controlled study comparing clonidine and buprenorphine detoxification regimens |
Buprenorphine, sublingual, fixed-taper dosing, starting dose 8 mg or 6 mg (age based); Clonidine, transdermal patch, fixed- taper dosing, starting dose 0.1–0.3 mg daily |
Opiate negative urine tests, treatment retention, self-report HIV-risk behavior, opiate withdrawal symptoms |
Grade B (level 2 evidence) for OWS |
Opioid Use Disorder | |||||
Methadone | Inpatient detoxification and Specialized Opioid Treatment Programs, treatment-seeking, adolescents, heroin users (ages ≤ 20); 9 studies, n= 6,263 total subjects |
Systematic review; naturalistic study comparing methadone maintenance, detoxification, therapeutic community, and abstinence-based treatments; naturalistic studies of methadone maintenance or methadone detoxification treatment without comparator groups; methadone-based short- term detoxification (30- days) versus long-term detoxification (up to 6- months) |
Methadone, oral, flexible dosing, for 30-day detoxification or up to 6- month maintenance treatment |
Treatment retention, self-report opioid use |
Grade C (level 3 evidence) for OUD |
Buprenorphine- naloxone |
Outpatient, treatment-seeking, adolescents (ages 15–21); 1 study, n= 152 subjects |
Systematic review; 12- week, randomized, multisite, controlled study comparing 2-week buprenorphine-naloxone detoxification to 12-week buprenorphine-naloxone maintenance/extended treatment |
Buprenorphine-naloxone (2 mg/0.05 mg ratio), oral, fixed-taper dosing, up to 24 mg daily |
Opiate positive urine tests |
Grade B (level 2 evidence) for OUD |
Extended- release injectable Naltrexone (intramuscular) |
Residential treatment transitioning to outpatient treatment, treatment-seeking, adolescents (ages 16–20); 1 study, n= 16 subjects |
Retrospective, open- label, case series |
XR-naltrexone, intramuscular injection, 380 mg once every 4 weeks |
Treatment retention, abstinence, opioid use (chart abstraction of self-report and urine drug screen data) |
Grade C (level 3 evidence) for OUD |
Opioid Overdose | |||||
Naloxone (intranasal) |
Consensus guidelines; there have been no studies examining pharmacotherapy for opioid overdose in adolescents. |
Naloxone, intranasal, 2mg/2ml pre-filled luer-lock needle-less syringe |
Grade C (level 3 evidence) for Opioid Overdose |
Abbreviations: A-OCDS = Alcohol Obsessive Compulsive Drinking Scale, AW = alcohol withdrawal, AWS = alcohol withdrawal syndrome, AUD = alcohol use disorder, Buproprion SR – sustained release buproprion, Buproprion XL – extended release buproprion, CM = contingency management, CO = carbon monoxide, Cotinine = urine cotinine level (ng/dl), CUD = cannabis use disorder, EMA = ecological momentary assessment, EOT = end of treatment, HIV = human immunodeficiency virus, NAC = n-acetyl-cysteine, NRT = nicotine replacement therapy, OUD = Opioid Use Disorder, OWS = Opioid Withdrawal Syndrome, PPA = point prevalence abstinence, TUD = tobacco use disorder, XR-naltrexone = Extended-release injectable Naltrexone
Levels of evidence presented are based upon the US Preventative Services Task Force (USPSTF) Strength of Recommendation Taxonomy (SORT) approach to grading evidence in medical literature.103 Levels of evidence include: Level 1: good-quality, patient-oriented evidence including systematic reviews, meta-analyses, and well-designed randomized controlled trials with consistent findings. Level 2: limited-quality, patient-oriented evidence including lower-quality/less consistent systematic reviews, meta-analyses, or clinical trials as well as cohort and case-control series. Level 3: other evidence in the form of consensus guidelines, disease-oriented evidence, and case series. These levels of evidence are used to determine a strength of recommendation grade, which include A (good-quality, patient-oriented evidence); B (limited-quality, patient-oriented evidence); C (other evidence); and no recommendation.
For the adolescent TUD pharmacotherapy studies, and specifically the 5 NRT and 4 bupropion studies, all studies had CPD-based inclusionary criteria which ranged from ≥ 5 to ≥ 10 CPD.