Table 5.
Measurement | FU period | Significance | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Author, year | Grade | N of pts | tool | (months) | Level (p value) | Association | Predictor level of measurement |
Kessler, 2007 | Moderate | 76 | WOMAC | ST (3 m) | NA | No | Dich |
(1: men 2: woman) | |||||||
Nilsdotter, 2002 | Moderate | 148 | WOMAC | ST (3 m) | 0.7 | No | Dich |
SF-36 | ST (12 m) | (1: men 2: woman) | |||||
Nankaku, 2013 | Moderate | 204 | Ambulatory status ST (6 m) | 0.10 | No | Dich | |
(1: men 2: woman) | |||||||
Slaven, 2012 | Low | 40 | LEFS | ST (6 m) | 0.039 | Pos, woman | Dich |
(1: men 2: woman) | |||||||
Quintana, 2009 | Moderate | 788 | SF-36 PF | ST (6 m) | NA | Pos, men | Dich |
ST (24 m) | NA | No | (1: men 2: woman) | ||||
Bergschmidt, 2010 | Moderate | 100 | HHS | ST (12 m) | NA | No | Dich |
(1: men 2: woman) | |||||||
Stevens, 2012 | Low | 653 | WOMAC | ST (12 m) | 0.002 | Pos, men | Dich |
(1: men 2: woman) | |||||||
Dowsey, 2014 | High | 835 | HHS | ST (12 m) | 0.06 | No | Dich |
(1: men 2: woman) | |||||||
Wang, 2010 | Moderate | 97 | WOMAC | ST (16.8 m) | 0.0001 | Pos, men | Dich |
(1: men 2: woman) | |||||||
Bischoff, 2004 | Moderate | 922 | WOMAC PF | LT (36 m) | No | No | Dich |
(1: men 2: woman) | |||||||
Jones, 2012 | Moderate | 231 | WOMAC | LT (36 m) | 0.118 | No | Dich |
(1: men 2: woman) | |||||||
Smith, 2012 | Moderate | 1683 | HHS | LT (36 m) | <0.001 | Pos, men | Dich |
(1: men 2: woman) | |||||||
Gandhi, 2010 | Low | 636 | WOMAC | LT (39 m) | No | No | Dich |
SF-36 PF | <0.05 | Pos, woman | (1: men 2: woman) | ||||
Lavernia, 2011 | Low | 532 | WOMAC PF | LT (42 m) | <0.001* | Pos, woman | Dich |
(1: men 2: woman) | |||||||
Nilsdotter, 2003 | Low | 211 | WOMAC PF | LT (66 m) | 0.37 | No | Dich |
(1: men 2: woman) |
All significant results are bold; studies that used change in function as outcome are marked with *.
BMI, body mass index; Dich, dichotomous; FU, follow-up; HHS, Harris Hip Score; LEFS, Lower Extremity Functional Scale; LT, long-term; N of pts, number of patients; NA, not applicable; Neg, negative; OHS, Oxford Hip Score; Pos, positive; SF-36 PF, Short Form 36 physical function; ST, short-term; THA, total hip arthroplasty; WOMAC, Western Ontario and Mcmaster Universities Osteoarthritis Index.