Skip to main content
. 2016 Sep 13;3:160080. doi: 10.1038/sdata.2016.80

Table 5. A comparison of the high-throughput values to experimental and computed values for materials from the literature.

Material Surface Surface energy γ (J m−2)
   
    This work Prev. DFT Experimental
A range of values is provided based on the lowest and highest values found in the literature. 37GGA (Hamann pseudopotentials); 35GGA (FCD); 34LDA (FP-KKR); 25GGA-PBE;
       
40LDA (Vanderbilt pseudopotentials);
       
80GGA-PBEsol;
       
71GGA-PBE (FP-LAPW);
       
81GGA-PBEsol;
       
82Local Density Formulation;
       
78PWGGA (LCGTO);
       
Ni (110) 2.29 2.37 (ref. 35)–2.31 (ref. 25) 2.44* (ref. 27)
  (210) 2.4 2.43 (ref. 25)  
  (100) 2.21 2.25 (ref. 25)–2.43 (ref. 35)  
  (221) 2.17 2.2 (ref. 25)  
  (111) 1.92 2.01 (ref. 35)–1.95 (ref. 25)  
Mg (101¯0) 0.6 0.78 (ref. 35) 0.82* (ref. 28)
  (0001) 0.54 0.54 (ref. 71)–0.79 (ref. 35)  
Ba (110) 0.31 0.38 (ref. 35)–0.37 (ref. 80) 0.34* (ref. 28)
  (100) 0.32 0.37 (ref. 80)–0.35 (ref. 35)  
  (111) 0.39 0.45 (ref. 80)–0.4 (ref. 35)  
Pt (110) 1.68 2.91 (ref. 34)–2.27 (ref. 35) 2.37* (ref. 28)
  (100) 1.84 2.73 (ref. 35)–2.23 (ref. 80)  
  (111) 1.48 2.35* (ref. 71)–1.47 (ref. 71)  
Sr (110) 0.41 0.47 (ref. 80)–0.43 (ref. 35) 0.38* (ref. 28)
  (100) 0.35 0.41 (ref. 35)–0.39 (ref. 80)  
  (111) 0.34 0.5 (ref. 81)–0.4 (ref. 80)  
Mo (110) 2.8 2.92 (ref. 82)–3.69 (ref. 81) 2.07* (ref. 27)
  (100) 3.18 3.34 (ref. 82)–3.84 (ref. 35)  
  (211) 3.4 3.11 (ref. 82)–3.6 (ref. 35)  
  (111) 2.96 3.24 (ref. 82)–3.74 (ref. 35)  
Bi (0001) 0.17 NA 0.43* (ref. 28)
Li (110) 0.5 0.56* (ref. 35)–0.3 (ref. 78) 0.7* (ref. 28)
  (100) 0.46 0.52 (ref. 35)–0.32 (ref. 78)  
  (111) 0.54 0.62* (ref. 35)–0.34 (ref. 78)  
Pb (100) 0.28 0.64* (ref. 37)–0.32 (ref. 37) 0.52* (ref. 28)
  (110) 0.33 0.72 (ref. 34)–0.33 (ref. 35)  
  (111) 0.25 0.6 (ref. 34)–0.26* (ref. 37)  
Re (0001) 2.58 4.21 (ref. 35) 2.52* (ref. 27)
  (101¯0) 2.86 4.63 (ref. 35)  
Ge (110) 0.97 1.17 (ref. 40) 0.68* (ref. 27)
  (100) 0.87 1.71 (ref. 40)  
  (111) 1.11 1.3 (ref. 40)  
Lu (0001) 1.13 1.6 (ref. 35) 1.08* (ref. 28)
  (101¯0) 1.05 1.42 (ref. 35)  
Fe (110) 2.45 3.0 (ref. 80)–2.43 (ref. 35) 2.41* (ref. 27)
  (100) 2.5 3.12 (ref. 80)–2.22 (ref. 35)  
  (211) 2.61 2.59 (ref. 35)  
  (111) 2.73 3.28 (ref. 80)–2.73 (ref. 35)  
Ga (001) 0.57 NA 0.02* (ref. 27)
Dy (101¯2) 1.0 NA 0.88* (ref. 28)
Sc (101¯0) 1.2 1.53 (ref. 35) 1.16* (ref. 28)
  (0001) 1.27 1.83 (ref. 35)  

*See reference herein.