Skip to main content
. 2016 Jun 8;12(3):261–271. doi: 10.1007/s11420-016-9505-9

Table 2.

Functional and clinical outcomes

Study Functional assessment Outcome Follow-up time (months) Radiologic assessment Outcome Mean follow-up time (months)
Gangji, 2011 [11] VAS + 24 MRI Delay to collapse: + NA
Lesquene + Delay to THR: ND
WOMAC +
Zhao, 2012 [54] HHS + 24 MRI Delay to collapse: + NA
Delay to THR: ND
Sen, 2012 [45] HHS 24 MRI, X-rays Delay to THR: −
Koo, 1995 [24] MAP + 13 MRI, X-rays Delay to collapse: ND 24
Delay to THR: ND
Neumayr, 2006 [38] CHOHES I 27 MRI, X-rays Delay to THR: ND CD group: 37.2
Control group: 36
Delay to collapse: ND
Stulberg, 1991 [49] HHS + 13 MRI, X-rays Delay to THR: + 26.8
Chen , 2012 [9] HHS ND 24 MRI, X-rays Delay to collapse: ND NA
SF-36 ND Delay to THR: ND
Lai, 2005 [26] HHS I 24 MRI, X-rays Delay to collapse: + 8
Delay to THR: +
Lee, 2015 [27] HHS 24 MRI, X-rays Delay to collapse: ND 24
WOMAC 24 Delay to THR: ND
Hsu, 2010 [18] HHS 26 MRI, X-rays Progression: ND NA
MAP Delay to THR: ND
WOMAC
SF-12
Wang, 2008 [51] HHS 6.5 MRI, X-rays Progression: ND 24.87–26.14
Kang, 2012 [23] HHS 15.75 MRI, X-rays Delay to collapse (+) 62.5

Outcomes: (+) significant improvement, (−) no significant improvement; (ND) no difference, and (I) statistics not reported

MAP Multidimensional Assessment Pain Scale, WOMAC Western Ontario and McMaster Universities Arthritis, CHOHES Children’s Hospital Oakland Hip Evaluation Scale, HHS Harris Hip Scores, VAS visual analogue score, SF-36 Short-Form 36 Health Survey, SF-12 Short-Form 12 Health Survey