Skip to main content
. 2016 Sep 22;11(9):e0163534. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0163534

Table 1. Characteristics of studies included in the study.

Case Control Control source Control sample
Author Year Region Age (case, years) M U M U Method
Onerci Celebi[16] 2016 Turkey mean = 56.6; range: 40–75 64 18 3 8 Pyrosequencing H tissue
Yang[17] 2015 China 27 50 12 50 MSP A tissue
Asokan[18] 2014 India 4 6 0 5 MSP H tissue
Bhatia[19] 2014 India mean = 53.0; sd: 12.97 58 18 34 36 MSP H tissue
Rettori[20] 2013 Brazil 14 53 2 55 QMSP H saliva
Koutsimpelas[21] 2012 Germany mean = 62.0; range: 45–83 13 10 0 3 MSP H tissue
Paluszczak[22] 2011 Poland mean = 58.3; range: 41–75 22 19 15 26 MSP A tissue
Weiss[23] 2011 Germany mean = 63.7; sd: 11.8 13 39 3 28 MSP H tissue
Su[24] 2010 Taiwan mean = 54.94; range:37–82 7 23 3 27 QMSP A tissue
0 12 H buccal cell
Kordi[25] 2010 Iran mean = 54.14 56 20 31 26 MSP H tissue
Steinmann[26] 2009 Germany mean = 57.0; range: 41–77 29 25 7 16 MSP A tissue
De Schutter[27] 2009 Belgium 17 23 0 5 MSP H tissue
Righini[28] 2007 France median = 57.0; range: 33–7 20 70 0 30 MSP A tissue
0 30 H saliva
13 47 A saliva
Martone[29] 2007 Italy mean = 60.9; range: 27–89 10 10 5 6 MSP A tissue
Kato[30] 2006 Japan 27 24 0 18 MSP H tissue
9 13 A tissue
Maruya[31] 2004 USA mean = 58.3; range: 31–81 10 22 7 25 MSP A tissue
1 5 MSP H tissue
Kulkarni[32] 2004 India mean = 50.0; range:25–71 31 29 16 44 MSP A tissue
0 20 MSP H buccal cell
Viswanathan[33] 2003 India 21 30 0 25 MSP A tissue
Rosas[34] 2001 USA 7 23 4 3 MSP A saliva
1 29 H saliva
Sanchez[35] 2000 USA 31 64 14 15 MSP A serum

M: MGMT promoter methylated, U: MGMT promoter unmethylated

A: Autologous, H: Heterogeneous

sd: standard deviation