Skip to main content
. 2016 Sep 26;6:34044. doi: 10.1038/srep34044

Table 2. Performance of proposed predictors on alternative datasets.

Dataset Methoda Recall Precision F1 ACC MCC AUC
EF_family Feature (Str|Seq) 0.503b (0.486)c 0.208 (0.206) 0.292 (0.289) 0.973 (0.974) 0.311 (0.305) 0.937 (0.931)
Template(Str|Seq) 0.229 (0.200) 0.303 (0.451) 0.260 (0.276) 0.986 (0.989) 0.256 (0.295) N/A
Hunter(Str|Seq) 0.489 (0.509) 0.258 (0.226) 0.336 (0.313) 0.979 (0.976) 0.345 (0.328) 0.941 (0.936)
CRHunter 0.497 0.305 0.376 0.982 0.380 0.949
EF_superfamily Feature(Str|Seq) 0.509 (0.452) 0.211 (0.193) 0.297 (0.270) 0.973 (0.972) 0.315 (0.283) 0.938 (0.924)
Template(Str|Seq) 0.032 (0.023) 0.056 (0.149) 0.040 (0.040) 0.983 (0.988) 0.034 (0.054) N/A
Hunter(Str|Seq) 0.506 (0.536) 0.189 (0.163) 0.274 (0.250) 0.970 (0.964) 0.296 (0.282) 0.937 (0.925)
CRHunter 0.523 0.218 0.307 0.974 0.326 0.944
EF_fold Feature(Str|Seq) 0.448 (0.363) 0.210 (0.182) 0.282 (0.241) 0.971 (0.971) 0.292 (0.243) 0.918 (0.907)
Template(Str|Seq) 0.017 (0.018) 0.030 (0.124) 0.021 (0.031) 0.981 (0.986) 0.013 (0.042) N/A
Hunter(Str|Seq) 0.505 (0.497) 0.178 (0.160) 0.259 (0.241) 0.964 (0.961) 0.283 (0.265) 0.918 (0.907)
CRHunter 0.504 0.211 0.293 0.970 0.311 0.926
HA_superfamily Feature(Str|Seq) 0.539 (0.497) 0.198 (0.182) 0.289 (0.266) 0.974 (0.973) 0.316 (0.290) 0.944 (0.933)
Template(Str|Seq) 0.103 (0.091) 0.150 (0.326) 0.121 (0.141) 0.986 (0.990) 0.117 (0.168) N/A
Hunter(Str|Seq) 0.557 (0.556) 0.186 (0.174) 0.278 (0.265) 0.972 (0.970) 0.310 (0.299) 0.944 (0.936)
CRHunter 0.575 0.233 0.330 0.977 0.356 0.952
NN Feature(Str|Seq) 0.475 (0.468) 0.207 (0.201) 0.286 (0.280) 0.974 (0.974) 0.301 (0.295) 0.935 (0.932)
Template(Str|Seq) 0.108 (0.088) 0.141 (0.393) 0.122 (0.139) 0.983 (0.989) 0.115 (0.177) N/A
Hunter(Str|Seq) 0.541 (0.543) 0.196 (0.178) 0.285 (0.267) 0.971 (0.968) 0.312 (0.298) 0.939 (0.934)
CRHunter 0.551 0.243 0.335 0.977 0.354 0.949
PC Feature(Str|Seq) 0.478 (0.383) 0.214 (0.181) 0.285 (0.242) 0.972 (0.972) 0.302 (0.249) 0.936 (0.923)
Template(Str|Seq) 0.061 (0.019) 0.088 (0.075) 0.072 (0.030) 0.982 (0.988) 0.064 (0.034) N/A
Hunter(Str|Seq) 0.524 (0.469) 0.189 (0.161) 0.274 (0.234) 0.967 (0.964) 0.299 (0.257) 0.937 (0.924)
CRHunter 0.493 0.231 0.306 0.974 0.321 0.945

aFeature(Str|Seq) denotes our feature predictor based on structural or sequence information. Template(Str|Seq) denotes our template predictor based on structure or profile alignment. Hunter(Str|Seq) is the combined structural or sequence module. CRHunter is our final prediction algorithm.

bResults generated by structure-based predictors.

cResults generated by sequence-based predictors.