Skip to main content
. 2016 Oct;41:26–41. doi: 10.1016/j.seizure.2016.07.002

Table 2.

Summary of autoimmune epilepsy studies. Studies are derived from search criteria in methods and details have been included only when they were available in the article. MRI findings: increased T2/FLAIR signal in structures listed within the table otherwise stated and studies showing multiple regions of brain involvement are further described in Supplementary Table 2. AEDs = Antiepileptic drugs; CPS = Complex partial seizures; CLN = Cortical laminar necrosis; CI = Cognitive impairment; DN = Double negative VGKC-complex antibody (without LGI1 or CASPR2 reactivities); EPC = Epilepsia partialis continua; FBDS = Faciobrachial dystonic seizures; FS = Focal seizure; FS+ = Focal seizure with impaired awareness; FM = Figural memory; FU = Follow-up; FLAIR = Fluid attenuated inversion recovery; GTC = Generalized tonic clonic seizures; GS = Generalized seizures; GAD = Glutamic acid decarboxylase; GABA = Gamma amino butyric acid; IT = Immunotherapy; IGE = Idiopathic generalized epilepsy; IVIG = Intravenous immunoglobulins; IgG = Immunoglobulin G; MDZ = Midazolam; MMSE = Mini-mental state examination, MTL = Medial temporal lobe; MTS = Mediotemporal sclerosis; MRI = Magnetic resonance imaging; mRS = Modified rankin score; N/A = Data not available; OCB = Oligoclonal bands; PCPC = Paediatric cerebral performance category scale; PL = Pleocytosis; PLEX = Plasma exchange; PPF = Propofol; ⿿Prot = Protein elevation; SGTCS = Secondary generalized tonic clonic seizure; SPS = Simple partial seizures; SE = Status epilepticus; SIADH = Syndrome of inappropriate ADH secretion; SCLC = Small cell lung cancer; TLE = Temporal lobe epilepsy; TICS = Telephone interview of cognitive status (scored out of 41); VM = Verbal memory.

Author Type of study/number of patients/antibody type Clinical presentation Types of seizure EEG MRI CSF AED given before IT? (Number/duration) Number of AEDs used with IT IT used/outcome FU duration (range, median)/drug side effects
a. LGI1/CASPR2/VGKC-complex antibody studies
Vincent et al., 2004 Observational
n = 1
0
Female = 1
LGI1 (100%, retrospective)
Amnesia, Seizures, Confusion GTC (n = 3), FS (n = 3), GTC + CPS/SPS (n = 3) Normal (n = 2), Diffuse slowing + focal activity (n = 4), Focal activity (n = 2), Diffuse slowing (n = 1), Focal activity + diffuse slowing (n = 1) Normal (n = 2), Unilateral MTL (n = 3), Bilateral MTL (n = 5) OCB (n = 5), Mild PL (n = 5) N/A N/A IT:n = 10; steroids, PLEX, IVIG Outcome: Neuropsychology: marked recovery (n = 6), slight recovery (n = 3), no recovery (n = 1) 2 weeks⿿12 months/N/A
Thieben et al., 2004 Retrospective
n = 7
Female = 2
VGKC-complex specificity unknown
Seizures, Amnesia, Irritability, Apathy SPS (n = 2), CPS (n = 5), GTC (n = 2), SE (n = 1) Epileptiform discharges (n = 4), Mild bitemporal slowing (n = 1), Diffuse/generalized slowing (n = 2) Unilateral MTL (n = 1), Bilateral MTL (n = 6) OCB (n = 1), ⿿Prot (n = 2) N/A N/A IT: n = 6; steroids. One spontaneous recovery. Outcome. TICS: Good recovery (n = 3; TICS = 34⿿35/41), Partial recovery (n = 3; TICS = 27-33/41), Spontaneous (n = 1; TICS = 36/41)) 7⿿36 months (median = 24)
Mcknight et al., 2005 Case control
n = 16
Female = 9
VGKC-complex specificity unknown
Amnesia, Seizures, Depression GTC (n = 9), CPS (n = 7) N/A Normal (n = 9), Hippocampal (n = 3), Claustrum (n = 1) N/A N/A N/A IT:n = 6; steroids and IVIG. Outcome: Good response (n = 5), No response (n = 1) 2⿿60 months (median = 18)
Lai et al., 2010 Observational
n = 57
Female = 2
0 LGI1 (100%)
CASPR2 (2%)
Amnesia, Seizures Temporal lobe seizures (n = 42), Myoclonus (n = 18) Epileptiform discharge (n = 4), Diffuse or focal slowing (n = 11), Seizures (n = 11) Temporal lobe (n = 43) PL (n = 8), ⿿Prot (n = 13) N/A N/A IT: n = 48; steroids, PLEX, IVIG. Outcome: Full recovery (n = 12), Moderate disability (n = 8), Mild disability (n = 27), Death (n = 3).
Irani et al., 2011 Observationa
n = 29
Female = 10
LGI1 (88%)
CASPR2 (12%)
Double negative (12%)
Amnesia, Confusion, Hallucinations, Depression, Dysautonomia, Seizures FBDS Normal (n = 9), Diffuse slowing (n = 9), Bilateral frontotemporal slowing (n = 6), Temporal sharp waves (n = 2) Normal (n = 12), Unilateral MTL (n = 3), Bilateral MTL (n = 10) Mild PL and ⿿Prot (n = 5) N/A 1⿿6 (median = 2.6) IT:n = 27; steroids PLEX, IVIG and rituximab. Outcome: Reduction in seizure frequency >50% (n = 14), 20⿿50% (n = 12), <20% (n = 1) 4 years AEDs: Localized rash (n = 8), Erythroderma (n = 2), Steven Johnson syndrome (n = 2) IT: Steroid induced psychosis (n = 1); infection (n = 2)
Suleiman et al., 2011 Case control
n = 4
Female = 3
Double negative (100%)
Encephalopathy, Fever, Behavioural, Seizures GTC (n = 2), SE (n = 4), GS (n = 2) Generalized slowing (n = 2), Focal slowing (n = 2), Epileptic activity (n = 1) Normal (n = 2), Left parietal and bifrontal (n = 1), Cerebral oedema (n = 1) PL (n = 4), ⿿Prot (n = 2) N/A N/A IT: steroids and IVIG. Outcome: Good recovery (n = 1), TLE + CI (n = 1), TLE + CI + psychiatric (n = 1), CI (n = 1) 1⿿66 months (median = 15.5)
Quek et al., 2012 Observational
n = 32
Female = 19
LGI1 (78%)
CASPR2 (6%)
Double negative (17%)
Seizures, Personality changes, Anxiety/Depression SPS (n = 27), CPS (n = 26), GTC (n = 17), EPC (n = 3) Epileptiform discharge (n = 20), Focal slowing (n = 13), Electrographic seizures (n = 15), Generalized slowing (n = 12) Normal (n = 15), Temporal/extratemporal (n = 22) Normal (n = 11), PL (n = 5), ⿿Prot (n = 17), OCB (n = 5) >2 for 3 weeks⿿12 years (median = 5) >2 (median = 3) IT:n = 27; steroids, PLEX. IVIG. Outcome: Seizure freedom (n = 18), Seizure improvement (n = 4), No change (n = 5) 3⿿72 months (median = 17)
Shin et al., 2013 Observational
n = 14
Female = 6
LGI1 (100%)
Seizures, Cognitive dysfunction, Dysautonomia FBDS (n = 10), SE (n = 4) Epileptiform discharge (n = 8), Focal slowing (n = 2) Unilateral MTL (n = 4), Bilateral MTL (n = 5) Normal (n = 10), ⿿Prot (n = 3), PL (n = 1) N/A N/A IT:n = 14; steroids, PLEX, IVIG, rituximab, tacrolimus, cyclophosphamide, azathioprine. Outcome: n = 11 (mRS: 0⿿2), n = 1 (mRS >2); relapse (n = 2) 1⿿24 months (median = 4.5)
Toledano et al., 2014 Observational
n = 12
Female = 5
LGI1 (92%)
CASPR2 (8%)
Seizures FS (n = 6), FBDS (n = 4). FS+ (n = 10). GTC (n = 7) Normal (n = 1), Epileptiform discharges (n = 6), Focal slowing (n = 2), Excessive beta activity (n = 1), Temporal activity (n = 1), Extratemporal discharge (n = 1) Normal (n = 2), Bilateral MTL (n = 3), Right MTL (n = 1), Left MTL (n = 1), Right MTS (n = 1) Normal (n = 5), ⿿Prot (n = 6), PL (n = 1) >2 (median = 3) >1 IT:n = 12; steroids, PLEX, IVIG, mycophenolate mofetil, azathioprine Outcome: Seizure freedom (n = 10); reduced frequency (n = 2) 2⿿86 months With IT: Steroid induced psychosis; aseptic meningitis
Malter et al., 2014 Retrospective
n = 18
Female = 6
LGI1 (50%)
CASPR2 (17%)
Double negative (33%)
Amnesia, Confusion, Depression, Seizures, Anxiety FBDS (n = 2) N/A Bilateral MTL (n = 12) Right MTL (n = 2) Left MTL (n = 5) ⿿Prot (n = 5), PL (n = 2) N/A >1 IT:n = 18; steroids, mycophenolate mofetil Outcome: Seizure free (n = 13); Persistent seizures (n = 5). No deficit in VM + FM (n = 6); Deficit in VM + FM (n = 4); Deficit in FM (n = 5); Deficit in VM (n = 1) 5⿿70 months (median = 26) Steroid-induced liver failure (n = 1)
Newey et al., 2014 Observational
n = 6
Female = 3
VGKC-complex specificity unknown
Seizures, Altered mental state, Depression. CPS (n = 1) N/A Unilateral MTL (n = 2), Bilateral MTL (n = 1) Normal (n = 3), ⿿Prot (n = 2), N/A (n = 1) N/A >2 IT:n = 5 (steroids, PLEX, IVIG). Outcome: Complete/partial response (n = 3) N/A
b. NMDAR-antibody studies
Dalmau et al., 2007 Observational
n = 12
Female = 12
Psychiatric features, Seizures, Movement disorders, Autonomic instability, Reduced level of consciousness GTC or CPS (n = 11) Diffuse slowing (n = 7), Generalized slowing/epileptiform activity (n = 3) Normal (n = 3), Bilateral MTL, (n = 3), Punctate cortical hyperintensites+/⿿meningeal enhancement (n = 5) PL (n = 14), OCB (n = 3), ⿿Prot (n = 7) N/A >2 IT: steroids, PLEX, IVIG (n = 3); Tumour resection (n = 2); IT and tumour resection (n = 7). Outcome: Full recovery (n = 8, MMSE = 28/30), partial recovery (n = 2, MMSE = 24/30), Death (n = 3) 7 months⿿6 years
Dalmau et al., 2008 Observational
n = 100
Female = 91
Psychiatric features, Seizures, Movement disorders, Dysautonomia, Hypoventilation GTC (n = 45), CPS (n = 10), SE (n = 6), FS (n = 7), SGTCS (n = 8), EPC (n = 2), Myoclonus (n = 9) Slow activity (n = 71), Epileptic discharge (n = 21) MTL (n = 22) PL (n = 91), ⿿Prot (n = 32), OCB (n = 26) N/A N/A IT:n = 92 (steroids, PLEX, IVIG, cyclophosphamide, rituximab, azathioprine); Tumour resection (n = 51). Outcome: Full recovery (n = 47; mRS = 0; MMSE = 29⿿30), Mild stable deficit (n = 28 mRS = 1⿿2; MMSE = 25 ⿿28) Severe deficit (n = 18), Death (n = 7) 1⿿194 months (median = 17)
Iizuka et al., 2008 Observational
n = 4
Female = 4
Psychiatric symptoms, Seizures, Dyskinesia, Hypoventilation Convulsive seizure (n = 2), Tonic (n = 1) Diffuse delta activity no Paroxymal discharge (n = 3), Irregular slowing no paroxysmal discharge (n = 1) Normal (n = 3), MTL (n = 1) PL (n = 4), OCB (n = 1) N/A >2 IT:n = 2 (steroids, IVIG) Outcome: Full recovery (n = 2); Gradual recovery over 3⿿4 years (n = 2) 4⿿7 years
Niehusmann et al., 2009 Prospective cohort
n = 5
Female = 5
Psychiatric symptoms, Extratemporal epilepsy Dyskinesia, Dystonia, Hypoventilation, Reduced consciousness SGTC (n = 2), CPS (n = 1), SPS + CPS (n = 1) Focal slowing (n = 4), Generalized slowing (n = 1), Epileptic activity (n = 3) Normal (n = 2), White matter (n = 1) Cortex (n = 1) PL (n = 5), OCB (n = 3) 2 months N/A IT: n = 3 (steroids, IVIG); no treatment (n = 2). Outcome: None relapsed on IT; 2 did not relapse without IT 15⿿36 months (median = 26)
Florance et al., 2009 Observational
n = 32
Female = 26
Seizures, Behavioural/personality changes, Movement disorders FS/CPS (n = 19), GTC (n = 2) SE (n = 1), FS/SE (n = 1) Epileptic activity (n = 7), Focal or diffuse delta/theta (n = 22) MTL, periventricular and cerebellar (n = 5) PL (n = 27), ⿿Prot (n = 4), OCB (n = 5) N/A >2 IT: n = 30 (Steroids, PLEX. IVIG, rituximab, cyclophosphamide); Tumour resection (n = 8); Electroconvulsive therapy (n = 2). Outcome: Full recovery (n = 9), Substantial recovery (n = 14), Limited improvement (n = 8) 2⿿14.4 months (median = 4.5)
Irani et al., 2010 Observational
n = 44
Female = 31
Seizures, Confusion, Psychiatric symptoms, Behavioural changes, Movement disorders, Dysautonomia GTC (n = 33) CPS (n = 16), SPS (n = 12) Epileptiform discharge (n = 22), Generalized slowing in delta or theta range (n = 35) Normal (n = 34), Hippocampi (n = 4) or white matter (n = 6) PL (n = 30), OCB (n = 23) N/A N/A IT: n = 35 (steroids, PLEX, IVIG, cyclophosphamide, rituximab, azathioprine, mycophenolate mofetil). Outcome: 75% good recovery (mRS 0 ⿿2) 3.6⿿121 months (median = 16)
Armangue et al., 2013 Observational
n = 20
Female = 14
Seizures, Psychiatric symptoms, Movement disorders Seizures (n = 12) Generalized slowing (n = 7), Focal slowing (n = 3), Generalized slowing/focal activity (n = 6). Extreme delta brush (n = 1). Epileptiform discharge (n = 1) Temporal lobe (n = 6) PL (n = 14), OCB (n = 3), ⿿Prot (n = 1) N/A >2 IT: n = 20 (steroids, PLEX, IVIG, rituximab, cyclophosphamide). Outcome: Full recovery (n = 12, PCPC = 1 or 2), Mild disability (n = 5, PCPC = 1 or 2), Severe disability (n = 2, PCPC = 3 or 4), Death (n = 1) 4⿿149 months (median = 17.5)
Titulaer et al., 2013 Observational
n = 577
Female = 468
Seizures, Psychiatric symptoms, Movement disorders, Behavioural changes, Speech problems, Dysautonomia, Reduction in consciousness Seizures (n = 55) Slow pattern (n = 398), Epileptic features (n = 115) Normal (n = 360), Abnormal (n = 180), Unknown (n = 37) Normal (n = 114), PL (n = 402), ⿿Prot (n = 93), Unknown (n = 45) N/A N/A IT: n = 472 (steroids, PLEX, IVIG, rituximab, cyclophosphamide, and tumour removal); no treatment (n = 29). Outcome: Good in 1st 24 months (n = 394; mRS = 0⿿2), Good in 2nd 24 months (n = 203; mRS = 0⿿2), Poor (n = 29; mRS = 3⿿5), One or multiple relapse (n = 45) 4⿿186 months (median = 24)
Viaccoz et al., 2014 Observational
n = 13
Seizures, Amnesia, Dyskinesia, Psychiatry, Cognitive FS (n = 5). GTC (n = 3) Normal (n = 2), Slow waves (n = 4), SE/seizure (n = 6) Normal (n = 6), Hippocampus (n = 4), Occipital (n = 1), Cerebellar (n = 1) PL (n = 10), ⿿Prot/OCB (n = 4) N/A N/A IT:n = 12 (steroids, IVIG, cyclophosphamide, rituximab, mycophenolate mofetil). Outcome: Favourable (n = 10; mRS = 0⿿1), Complete recovery (n = 6; mRS = 0⿿1), Death (n = 1) 6⿿44 months (median = 14)
Lim et al., 2014 Observational
n = 40
Female = 15
Seizures, Psychiatric symptoms, Amnesia, Dysautonomia, Movement disorders Non- convulsive status (n = 6) Epileptic discharge (n = 12), Generalized or predominantly frontotemporal slowing (n = 10) MTL (n = 3) PL (n = 15), ⿿Prot (n = 13) N/A N/A IT: IT and/or tumour resection (n = 22); No treatment (n = 7). Outcome: Favourable outcome (n = 14; mRS = 0⿿2); Poor outcome (n = 7; mRS = 3⿿6) 1⿿12 months (median = 4)
c. GAD-antibody studies
Malter et al., 2010 Observational
n = 9
Females = 7
Temporal lobe Seizures TLE (n = 9) N/A Unilateral hippocampal atrophy (n = 3), Bilateral amygdalo-hippocampal signal (n = 3) OCB (n = 5), PL (n = 2), ⿿Prot (n = 2) N/A 2 (1⿿5) IT: n = 9 (steroids, IVIG, cyclophosphamide). Outcome: Abnormal VM (n = 5); Abnormal FM (n = 4). None seizure free 18 months
Haberlandt et al., 2011 Retrospective
n = 4
Females = 4
Amnesia, Depression, Ataxia, Seizures, Cognitive decline TLE (n = 3). FS (n = 1) N/A Unilateral MTL (n = 2), Bilateral (n = 1) MTL OCB (n = 2) N/A N/A IT: n = 3 (steroids or IVIG). Outcome: Memory impairment + TLE (n = 2), restitution (n = 1), memory impairment + epilepsy (n = 1) 13⿿67 months
Lilleker et al., 2014 Observational
n = 6
Females = 6
Seizures FS + GTCS (n = 5), FS (n = 1) Focal slowing, sharp and slow waves (n = 6) Normal (n = 6) OCB (n = 6), ⿿Prot (n = 1) 2⿿4 over 9.5 years >2 IT: n = 5 (steroids, PLEX, IVIG, azathioprine). Left anterior temporal lobe resection (n = 1). Outcome: No improvement in seizures (n = 4); N/A (n = 1) Optic neuritis (n = 1); Transverse myelitis (n = 1); Hepatotoxicity (n = 1)
d. GABABR-antibody studies
Lancaster et al., 2010 Observational n = 15 Female = 7 Seizures, Amnesia, Confusion, Psychosis CPS (n = 2), FS (n = 2), GS(n = 5), GTC (n = 2), SGTC (n = 1). SE (n = 3) Normal (n = 1). Temporal lobe seizures, Epileptiform discharge or temporal lobe slowing (n = 9). Generalized slowing (n = 2) Normal (n = 4), MTL (n = 10), Corpus callosum (n = 1) Normal (n = 1). PL (n = 8), OCB (n = 3) N/A N/A IT: n = 6 (steroid PLEX, IVIG), Tumour resection (n = 3), No treatment (n = 4). Outcome: Good response to IT (n = 6) or IT + Tumour resection (n = 3), No clinical improvement in untreated patients 3⿿72 months (median = 10)
Boronat et al., 2011 Observational
n = 10
Female = 1
Seizures, Confusion, Amnesia, Disorientation, Behavioural changes SE (n = 1) N/A Normal (n = 3). Hippocampus and amygdala (n = 7) PL (n = 4) N/A N/A IT:n = 7 (steroids and/or IVIG), Chemotherapy (n = 4). Outcome: Complete recovery (n = 3), Partial response (n = 4), No response (n = 3) N/A
Hoftberger et al., 2013 Observational
n = 20
Female = 8
Seizures, Amnesia, Confusion, Hallucinations, Cerebellar ataxia, Opsoclonus myoclonus Seizures (n = 17), SE (n = 1) Normal (n = 5). Epileptic activity with or without generalized slowing (n = 7) Normal (n = 7), Unilateral or bilateral MTL (n = 9), Pial enhancement (n = 1) PL (n = 6), ⿿Prot (n = 1), PL/⿿Prot (n = 7) N/A N/A IT: n = 19 (steroids, PLEX, IVIG, rituximab, cyclophosphamide or, mycophenolate mofetil), Chemotherapy (n = 4), No treatment (n = 3). Outcome: Complete recovery (n = 7), Partial recovery (n = 8) 0.75-45 months
Dogan Onugoren et al., 2014 Retrospective
n = 10
Female = 2
Amnesia, Confusion, Apraxia, Aphasia, Catatonia, Cerebellar dysfunction GTC (n = 9), SE (n = 2) Generalized or focal slowing(n = 6), Epileptic activity without slowing (n = 2), Epileptic activity with focal or generalized slowing (n = 2) Normal (n = 1), Unilateral MTL (n = 6), Bilateral MTL (n = 3), CLN (n = 3) PL (n = 6), OCB (n = 7) N/A N/A IT:n = 8 (Steroids, PLEX, IVIG, rituximab, cyclophosphamide, azathioprine), Chemotherapy (n = 4), Radiotherapy (n = 1). Outcome: Full recovery (n = 1), Slight recovery (n = 1), Decline in cognitive function (n = 5), Death (n = 3) 2⿿9 months
e. AMPAR-antibodies studies
Lai et al., 2009 Observational
n = 10
Female = 9
Amnesia, Confusion, Behavioural changes, Disorientation, Seizures FS (n = 1), GTC (n = 2) Normal (n = 2), Slow activity (n = 2), Sharp waves (n = 2), Theta activity (n = 1), Epileptic activity (n = 1) Normal (n = 1), MTL (n = 8), Changes in the anterior septal nuclei (n = 2) OCB (n = 3), PL (n = 9), ⿿Prot (n = 7) N/A N/A IT:n = 9 (steroids, PLEX, IVIG, azathioprine), Tumour resection + IT (n = 6). Outcome: Good recovery (n = 9), Relapses (n = 5), Death (n = 1) 8⿿50 months (median = 16)
Graus et al., 2010 Retrospective
n = 4
Female = 4
Confusion, Agitation, Personality changes, Aphasia, No seizures N/A Diffuse slowing with occasional sharp waves over the frontal region (n = 1), Episodic slow waves in frontal region (n = 1) Normal (n = 2) Normal (n = 2) N/A N/A IT: n = 2 (steroids). Outcome: Full recovery (n = 2) N/A
Dogan Onugoren et al., 2014 Retrospective
n = 3
Female = 1
Amnesia, Psychiatric symptoms, No seizures N/A Normal (n = 3) Bilateral MTL (n = 3), CLN (n = 2) PL (n = 1) N/A N/A IT: n = 2 (steroids, PLEX, IVIG, azathioprine, rituximab), IT + chemotherapy (n = 1). Outcome: Good recovery (n = 2), Mild recovery (n = 1) 5⿿14 months
Hoftberger et al., 2015 Retrospective
n = 22
Female = 14
Amnesia, Confusion, Insomnia, Seizures SE (n = 1) Normal (n = 4) Epileptiform activity (n = 4) Focal activity (n = 5) Generalized activity (n = 5) Slow activity (n = 1) Lateralized periodic slowing (n = 1) Normal (n = 4), Unilateral MTL (n = 2), Bilateral MTL (n = 9) Normal (n = 6), PL (n = 11), ⿿Prot (n = 10) N/A N/A IT:n = 25 (steroids, PLEX, IVIG, rituximab, cyclophosphamide), Tumour resection (n = 7), Chemotherapy (n = 8), Radiotherapy (n = 6). Outcome: Good response (n = 5, mRS score, 0⿿1), Partial response (n = 10, mRS score, 2⿿3), Poor response (n = 6) 5⿿266 weeks (median = 72)
Joubert et al., 2015 Observational
n = 7
Female = 4
Amnesia, Confusion, Insomnia, Seizures, Cerebellar signs, Tumours FS (n = 1) Normal (n = 4) Focal activity (n = 3) Normal (n = 1) Bilateral MTL (n = 4) Diffuse T2 hyperintensities (n = 2) Normal (n = 1) OCB (n = 3), PL (n = 5) 1 N/A IT:n = 7 (steroids, PLEX, IVIG, rituximab, cyclophosphamide, azathioprine). Outcome: Good response (n = 3, mRS score = 1), Poor response (n = 3, mRS score = 3), Death (n = 1) 2⿿31 months (median = 12)