Skip to main content
. 2016 Sep 19;2016:6086894. doi: 10.1155/2016/6086894

Table 4.

Overview of speech pathology interventions aimed at addressing problems in dysphagia, speech, voice, and trismus (n = 14).

Reference Topic General description of intervention and treatment intensity/duration Description of specific exercises Conclusions specific to therapy
Agarwal et al.
2009 [23]
Voice All patients received counseling and voice therapy by a trained speech pathologist
No specific data provided on treatment frequency/intensity
No description of exercises provided Forty-seven of 50 patients showed compliance to the therapy. No specific conclusions of influence of provided therapy on primary outcomes described

Akst et al.
2004 [46]
Swallowing Swallowing evaluation and intervention when clinically indicated No description of exercises provided No specific conclusions of influence of provided therapy on primary outcomes described

Buchbinder et al.
1993 [48]
Trismus Six to 10 exercise sessions per day for a 10-week period Group 1: unassisted exercises: reach maximum MIO and closing, jaw motion to left, right, and protrusively
Group 2: unassisted exercises: reach maximum MIO and closing, jaw motion to left, right, and protrusively. Stacked tongue depressors, to mechanically increase MIO (5 × 30 seconds per session)
Group 3: unassisted exercises: reach maximum MIO and closing, jaw motion to left, right, and protrusively. Combined with the TheraBite System (5 × 30 seconds per session)
The first four weeks no differences between groups were found. After week 4 minimal improvements in groups 1 and 2 were found and group 3 still improved. The highest increment in MIO was reached in group 3

Dijkstra et al.
2007 [52]
Trismus Physical therapy for trismus, median of 4 sessions Physical therapy consisting of
(i) Active range of motion
(ii) Hold and relax
(iii) Manual stretching
(iv) Joint distraction
Following therapeutic tools are used in described cohort:
(i) Rubber plugs
(ii) Tong blades
(iii) Dynamic bite opener
(iv) TheraBite System
MIO increases significantly after physical therapy. History of HNC decreases the effect of physical therapy, compared to other trismus patients

Frowen et al.
2010 [16]
Swallowing All patients were seen by a speech pathologist as an aspect of regular care No description of exercises provided No specific conclusions of influence of provided therapy on primary outcomes described

Hutcheson et al.
2014 [56]
Swallowing All patients received prophylactic swallowing therapy to avoid nothing by mouth periods during treatment
No specific data provided on treatment frequency/intensity
Targeted swallowing exercises No specific conclusions of influence of provided therapy on primary outcomes described

Karlsson et al.
2015 [31]
Voice Group 1: voice therapy group received 10 × 30-minute sessions over 10 weeks
Group 2: vocal hygiene group: 1 session for vocal hygiene advice
Group 1: voice therapy consisting of relaxation, respiration, posture, and phonation exercises
Group 2: vocal hygiene advice
Patients treated with voice therapy experienced greater improvements compared to patients that only received vocal hygiene advice. Group 1 showed a significant better functional communication and HRQoL

Kotz et al.
2012 [57]
Swallowing Group 1: weekly treatment by speech pathologist and daily 3 × 10 home sessions of exercises. Group 2: swallowing assessment and treatment if necessary after treatment Group 1: prophylactic swallowing therapy consisting of effortful swallow, tongue base retraction exercises, super supraglottic swallow, and the Mendelssohn maneuver
Group 2: control group only receive symptomatic dysphagia treatment
Prophylactic swallowing therapy improves swallowing at 3 and 6 months; later there were no group differences found

Kraaijenga et al.
2014 [35]
Swallowing and voice Daily practice from the start of the treatment until 1 year after treatment Two combined groups: TheraBite System and standard logopedic swallowing exercises (the same cohort as van der Molen et al. 2011 [73]) Minimal voice and swallowing difficulties were found 60 months after treatment in patients treated with prophylactic swallowing exercises

Sanguineti et al.
2014 [40]
Voice 75.8% of the patients received speech therapy. No therapy was provided to 30 patients
No specific data provided on treatment frequency/intensity
No description of exercises provided No specific conclusions of influence of provided therapy on primary outcomes described

Starmer et al.
2014 [69]
Swallowing Patients received prophylactic swallowing and trismus exercises No description of exercises provided No specific conclusions of influence of provided therapy on primary outcomes described

van der Molen et al.
2011 [73]
Swallowing Patients received instructions in advance of their oncological treatment. Three times daily exercises Group 1: range-of-motion exercises and three strengthening exercises, that is, the effortful swallow, the Masako maneuver, and the super supraglottic swallow. Stretch holding for 10–30 seconds at a point of mild discomfort
Group 2: stretch of the mouth using the TheraBite System and a strengthening exercise: swallowing with the tongue elevated to the palate while maintaining mouth opening at 50% of its maximum. Stretch holding for 10–30 seconds at a point of mild discomfort
Similar outcomes in both groups were found. Preventive rehabilitation can improve early posttreatment functional outcomes

van der Molen et al.
2012 [44]
Voice No specific speech or voice therapy N/A N/A

van der Molen et al.
2013 [74]
Swallowing and trismus Study was aimed at describing dose-effect relationships in two treatment groups described in earlier study. References to other published study where treatment regime is described Group 1: standard exercises
Group 2: experimental exercises
Any possible difference between the two included treatment groups is not described, nor possible influence of the respective treatments

HNC: head and neck cancer; HRQoL: health-related quality of life; MIO: maximum incisal opening; ROM: range of motion.