Table 4.
Reference | Topic | General description of intervention and treatment intensity/duration | Description of specific exercises | Conclusions specific to therapy |
---|---|---|---|---|
Agarwal et al. 2009 [23] |
Voice | All patients received counseling and voice therapy by a trained speech pathologist No specific data provided on treatment frequency/intensity |
No description of exercises provided | Forty-seven of 50 patients showed compliance to the therapy. No specific conclusions of influence of provided therapy on primary outcomes described |
| ||||
Akst et al. 2004 [46] |
Swallowing | Swallowing evaluation and intervention when clinically indicated | No description of exercises provided | No specific conclusions of influence of provided therapy on primary outcomes described |
| ||||
Buchbinder et al. 1993 [48] |
Trismus | Six to 10 exercise sessions per day for a 10-week period | Group 1: unassisted exercises: reach maximum MIO and closing, jaw motion to left, right, and protrusively Group 2: unassisted exercises: reach maximum MIO and closing, jaw motion to left, right, and protrusively. Stacked tongue depressors, to mechanically increase MIO (5 × 30 seconds per session) Group 3: unassisted exercises: reach maximum MIO and closing, jaw motion to left, right, and protrusively. Combined with the TheraBite System (5 × 30 seconds per session) |
The first four weeks no differences between groups were found. After week 4 minimal improvements in groups 1 and 2 were found and group 3 still improved. The highest increment in MIO was reached in group 3 |
| ||||
Dijkstra et al. 2007 [52] |
Trismus | Physical therapy for trismus, median of 4 sessions | Physical therapy consisting of (i) Active range of motion (ii) Hold and relax (iii) Manual stretching (iv) Joint distraction Following therapeutic tools are used in described cohort: (i) Rubber plugs (ii) Tong blades (iii) Dynamic bite opener (iv) TheraBite System |
MIO increases significantly after physical therapy. History of HNC decreases the effect of physical therapy, compared to other trismus patients |
| ||||
Frowen et al. 2010 [16] |
Swallowing | All patients were seen by a speech pathologist as an aspect of regular care | No description of exercises provided | No specific conclusions of influence of provided therapy on primary outcomes described |
| ||||
Hutcheson et al. 2014 [56] |
Swallowing | All patients received prophylactic swallowing therapy to avoid nothing by mouth periods during treatment No specific data provided on treatment frequency/intensity |
Targeted swallowing exercises | No specific conclusions of influence of provided therapy on primary outcomes described |
| ||||
Karlsson et al. 2015 [31] |
Voice | Group 1: voice therapy group received 10 × 30-minute sessions over 10 weeks Group 2: vocal hygiene group: 1 session for vocal hygiene advice |
Group 1: voice therapy consisting of relaxation, respiration, posture, and phonation exercises Group 2: vocal hygiene advice |
Patients treated with voice therapy experienced greater improvements compared to patients that only received vocal hygiene advice. Group 1 showed a significant better functional communication and HRQoL |
| ||||
Kotz et al. 2012 [57] |
Swallowing | Group 1: weekly treatment by speech pathologist and daily 3 × 10 home sessions of exercises. Group 2: swallowing assessment and treatment if necessary after treatment | Group 1: prophylactic swallowing therapy consisting of effortful swallow, tongue base retraction exercises, super supraglottic swallow, and the Mendelssohn maneuver Group 2: control group only receive symptomatic dysphagia treatment |
Prophylactic swallowing therapy improves swallowing at 3 and 6 months; later there were no group differences found |
| ||||
Kraaijenga et al. 2014 [35] |
Swallowing and voice | Daily practice from the start of the treatment until 1 year after treatment | Two combined groups: TheraBite System and standard logopedic swallowing exercises (the same cohort as van der Molen et al. 2011 [73]) | Minimal voice and swallowing difficulties were found 60 months after treatment in patients treated with prophylactic swallowing exercises |
| ||||
Sanguineti et al. 2014 [40] |
Voice | 75.8% of the patients received speech therapy. No therapy was provided to 30 patients No specific data provided on treatment frequency/intensity |
No description of exercises provided | No specific conclusions of influence of provided therapy on primary outcomes described |
| ||||
Starmer et al. 2014 [69] |
Swallowing | Patients received prophylactic swallowing and trismus exercises | No description of exercises provided | No specific conclusions of influence of provided therapy on primary outcomes described |
| ||||
van der Molen et al. 2011 [73] |
Swallowing | Patients received instructions in advance of their oncological treatment. Three times daily exercises | Group 1: range-of-motion exercises and three strengthening exercises, that is, the effortful swallow, the Masako maneuver, and the super supraglottic swallow. Stretch holding for 10–30 seconds at a point of mild discomfort Group 2: stretch of the mouth using the TheraBite System and a strengthening exercise: swallowing with the tongue elevated to the palate while maintaining mouth opening at 50% of its maximum. Stretch holding for 10–30 seconds at a point of mild discomfort |
Similar outcomes in both groups were found. Preventive rehabilitation can improve early posttreatment functional outcomes |
| ||||
van der Molen et al. 2012 [44] |
Voice | No specific speech or voice therapy | N/A | N/A |
| ||||
van der Molen et al. 2013 [74] |
Swallowing and trismus | Study was aimed at describing dose-effect relationships in two treatment groups described in earlier study. References to other published study where treatment regime is described | Group 1: standard exercises Group 2: experimental exercises |
Any possible difference between the two included treatment groups is not described, nor possible influence of the respective treatments |
HNC: head and neck cancer; HRQoL: health-related quality of life; MIO: maximum incisal opening; ROM: range of motion.