Skip to main content
. 2016 Sep 12;113(39):10908–10913. doi: 10.1073/pnas.1602145113

Table 1.

Model results for the fossil mammalian diversity–productivity relationship

Estimate Std. error/std. dev. z P
Continents
 NPP 1.109 0.373 2.97 0.003
 Area 0.535 0.081 6.59 <0.001
 Stage duration 0.237 0.084 2.83 0.005
 Continent identity 0.062 0.249
 Stage midpoint 0.001 0.026
Regions
 NPP 0.912 0.318 2.87 0.004
 Area 0.628 0.089 7.04 <0.001
 Stage duration 0.251 0.083 3.03 0.002
 Region identity 0.346 0.588
 Stage midpoint 0.004 0.062

Models were GLMMs with Poisson error functions, fitted across stratigraphic stages in either the two continents or the three focal regions. The response variable was fossil mammalian diversity (γ diversity estimates rounded to integers). Variables fitted as fixed effects were NPP in grams of dry matter per square meter per year, log-transformed; area (minimum convex hull around all mammalian locations in each stage, in square kilometers log-transformed); and stage duration (My, log-transformed). Variables fitted as random effects were continent or region identity (random intercept) and stage midpoint (age in Mya, random slope). The random effects therefore accounted for temporal trends and spatial structure in the data (see SI Materials and Methods and Table S2). Model statistics were as follows: model across continents: n = 12 observations; residual df = 5; marginal R2 (variance explained by the fixed effects) = 0.68; conditional R2 (variance explained by entire model, i.e., both the fixed and random effects) = 0.89; Akaike Information Criterion (AIC) = 116.6; model across regions: n = 17; residual df = 10; marginal R2 = 0.39; conditional R2 = 0.82; AIC = 183.3. Std. dev., SD of the variance estimate for random effects; Std. error, SE of the slope estimate for fixed effects.