Table 1.
Model | Benefits | Limitations | Example references |
---|---|---|---|
Conventional cultures/cocultures | (i) High-throughput (ii) Sandwich cultures can maintain cell polarity |
(i) Usually lack liver stromal cells (ii) Loss of drug metabolizing capacity occurs within hours |
[6, 10–13] |
| |||
Micropatterned cocultures |
(i) Controlled architecture allows for higher functions for 1-2 months (ii) Coculture allows for the study of drug toxicity in a diseased background (iii) Compatible with high content imaging readouts |
(i) Usually lack all liver stromal cells (ii) Use nonhuman supporting cells |
[14, 17, 18, 20, 27] |
| |||
Spheroidal cultures/cocultures | (i) Multicellular interactions (ii) Maintenance of major liver functions for 1–3 months |
(i) Difficult to control disorganized cell type interactions over time (ii) Necrosis in center of larger spheroids (iii) Size variability (iv) Incompatible with standard high content imaging equipment |
[30–38] |
| |||
Bioprinted cultures/cocultures | (i) Precise control of cell placement (ii) Multicellular interactions |
(i) Printing resolution does not allow placement of individual cells (ii) Low-throughput (iii) Heterogeneous distribution of drugs across the bioprinted tissues |
[39, 53, 54] |
| |||
Perfused biochips | (i) Dynamic fluid flow for nutrient and waste exchange (ii) Sustained functionality for at least 1 month (iii) Can be combined with module for real-time toxicity endpoint readouts |
(i) Binding of drugs to tubing (ii) Large dead volume requiring higher quantities of novel compounds (iii) Low-throughput (iv) Shear stress may cause lower hepatic functions (v) Can wash away built-up beneficial molecules |
[44–52, 55–66] |
| |||
Precision cut liver slices | (i) Retains native liver architecture and all liver cell types (ii) Can be combined with flow to improve functional lifetime |
(i) Low-throughput (ii) Rapid decline in liver functions (iii) Heterogeneous distribution of drug within the slice |
[67–72] |
| |||
Humanized rodents | (i) Human-relevant toxicity profiles in vivo
(ii) Can look at organ-organ interactions with a humanized liver background |
(i) Variability in human hepatocyte engraftment efficiency (ii) Low-throughput (iii) Residual murine liver cells can cause confounding results (iv) Interactions with murine organs |
[73–85] |