Table 1.
Year | Author(s) | Journal | Sample | Location | Study Period |
Alcohol Policies |
Outcome | Design | Main Findings |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1999 | Birckmayer & Hemenway |
AJPH | Decedents aged 18–20 |
U.S. 48 states |
1970–1990 | MLDA; beer excise tax |
Number of suicides |
Repeated cross-sectional |
The suicide rate of 18- to 20-year- old youths living in states with an 18-year MLDA was 8% higher than the suicide rate among 18- to 20- year-old youths in states with a 21- year MLDA (p<0.01). |
2002 | Escobedo & Ortiz |
Accid Anal Prev. |
Decedents | New Mexico (U.S.) |
1990–1994 | Liquor store outlet density |
County- specific suicide rates |
County panel data |
Greater availability of liquor outlets was associated with higher suicide rates (p=0.03). |
2003 | Markowitz et al |
J Ment Health Policy Econ |
Youth decedents aged 10–24 |
U.S. states | 1976–1999 | Beer excise tax; outlet density; blood alcohol content (BAC); zero tolerance. |
Suicide rates |
State panel data |
Increases in the excise tax on beer were associated with a reduced number of male suicides, but has no impact on female suicides. Suicides by males aged 20–24 are positively related to the availability of alcohol and negatively related to the presence of a 0.08 BAC law and zero tolerance laws for youth impaired driving. Female suicides were not impacted by the availability of alcohol. |
2004 | Carpenter | JPAM | Youth decedents aged 15–29 |
U.S. states | 1981–1998 | Adoption of Zero Tolerance Laws |
Suicide rates |
State panel data |
The presence of a zero tolerance policy was associated with a 10.3% reduction in suicides among 15–17- year-old males and a 7.7% reduction in suicides among 18–20- year-old males, and both were significant. No effects were found among 21–29-year-old males, and no consistent effects were found among females. |
2005 | Yamasaki et al |
Psychol Rep |
Decedents | Switzerland | 1965–1994 | Alcohol specific tax |
Suicide rates |
Time series analysis |
The tax on alcohol was positively correlated with male suicide rate in an autoregressive model (p<0.01), but no association was detected for female suicide rate. |
2006 | Värnik et al | Addiction | Decedents | Estonia | Before, during and after a major Soviet anti- alcohol reforms in 1985 |
Reduction of state alcohol production and sales by some 60%; raising prices by 45%; propaganda campaign to change attitudes; improving alcoholism treatment; punishing alcohol misuse |
BAC level among decedents |
Pre-post comparison |
During the reforms, BAC-positive suicides decreased by 39.2% for males and 41.4% for females, and the largest fall occurred at the BAC 2.5‰ plus level for both sexes. However, after the reform ended, suicide rates started to rise. |
2007 | Zalcman & Mann |
Contemp Drg Probl |
Decedents | Alberta, Canada |
1976–1999 | Three stages of privatization of retail sale: opening of privately owned wine stores in 1985; opening of privately owned cold beer stores and selling spirits and wine in hotels in rural areas in 1989; privatization of all liquor stores in 1994 |
Suicide rates |
Interrupted time series design |
Significant increase in male and female suicide rates were found after both 1985 and 1989 privatization, and significant increase in male suicide rate was found in 1994, but not among female. |
2009 | Johnson et al |
ACER | Decedents | California (U.S.) |
1995–2000 | Outlet density | Suicide rates |
Repeated cross-sectional at zip code level |
Completed suicide rates were higher in zip code areas with greater local and lagged bar densities, and those with greater local but not lagged off-premise outlet densities. Completed suicide rates were lower in zip code areas with greater local restaurant densities. Completed suicide rates were lower among blacks and Hispanics, but higher among rural, older, low income whites. |
2009 | Pridemore & Snowden |
AJPH | Decedents | Slovenia | 1997–2005 | New national alcohol policy in 2003 that limited alcohol availability with MLDA and hours of sale |
Monthly suicide counts |
Interrupted time series design |
There was a significant overall decrease in the number of monthly suicides following the policy’s implementation. A significant association was detected among men, but not women. |
2009 | Carpenter and Dobkin |
AEJ: Applied Economics |
Decedents aged 19–22 |
U.S. states | 1997–2004 | MLDA | Suicide rates |
Regression discontinuity design |
The suicide rate increased by over 16 percent at age 21. |
2011 | Son & Topyan |
Eur J Health Econ |
Decedents | U.S. states | 1995–2004 | State excise taxes |
Number of suicides |
State panel data |
Wine excise taxes were negatively associated with suicides rates, but no association was detected for spirit tax or beer tax. |
2012 | Grucza et al | ACER | Decedents | U.S. states | 1990–2004 | MLDA | Suicide (Y/N) |
Repeated cross-sectional |
Significant policy-by-sex interactions were observed: women exposed to permissive drinking age laws were at higher risk for suicide, with stronger effect for those born after 1960; no significant effects were observed for women born prior to 1960. No overall effect or effect on men was observed. |
2012 | Sauliune et al |
Alcohol Alcoholism |
Decedents aged 15–64 |
Lithuania | 2006–2009 | Implementation of comprehensive alcohol control policy in 2007- 2008 that increased excise taxes and restricted alcohol advertising, availability, drunk driving, and illegal imports and sales |
Years of potential life lost (YPLL) due to alcohol- related suicide |
Pre-post comparison |
Years of potential life lost due to alcohol-related suicides showed significant increase among males, but was stable among females. |
2013 | Pridemore et al |
AJPH | Decedents | Russia | 2000–2010 | Policies restricting sales volume and quality, requiring registration of production and distribution, requiring new fee, equipment costs and new excise tax stamp |
Number of suicides |
Interrupted time series design |
No impact of on female suicide mortality but a reduction of about 9% in male suicides (p=0.01). |
2013 | Zupanc et al |
Eur Addict Res |
Decedents | Slovenia | Before, during and after policy change in 2003 |
New national alcohol policy in 2003 that limited alcohol availability with MLDA and hours of sale |
BAC level among decedents |
Pre-post comparison |
Among BAC-positive suicide victims, BACs were lower after the policy change compared to those tested in the period before the change. |
2014 | Berman | AJPH | Alaska native men aged 15–34 in rural communities |
Alaska (U.S.) |
1980–2007 | Dry status (1 = sale and importation or possession prohibited, 0 = any other status); any local option adopted (1 = yes, 0 = no) |
Number of suicides |
Repeated cross-sectional |
Suicide rates were higher in communities prohibiting alcohol importation under state law, but the effect was not significant after controlling for other community characteristics. |
2014 | Giesbrecht et al |
Addiction | Decedents | U.S. states (14 states) |
2003–2011 | Outlet density | Alcohol Involveme nt (Y/N) among suicide decedents |
Repeated cross-sectional |
Higher off-premises alcohol outlet density was associated with greater proportions of alcohol-related (BAC>0) suicides among men. There was a significant interaction between off-premises alcohol availability and American Indian/Alaska Native race such that this subgroup had highest BAC positivity. On-premises density was also significantly associated with BAC >0 and BAC ≥0.08 among male decedents. |