Skip to main content
. 2015 Sep 24;36(31):2271–2290. doi: 10.1002/jcc.24195

Table 5.

Comparison between analytical and numerical forces (a.u.) for the Formamide–Water complex, computed for the B3LYP/6‐31+G* equilibrium geometry.

Analytic Numeric
Atoms x‐comp y‐comp z‐comp x‐comp y‐comp z‐comp
TD‐B3LYP/FQ
C −0.064662163 0.146337317 −0.030789285 −0.064662114 0.146337323 −0.030789281
H 0.009247938 −0.010031637 0.002242626 0.009247943 −0.010031635 0.002242618
O 0.098527562 −0.105630706 0.023396645 0.098527555 −0.105630734 0.023396652
N −0.043791024 −0.026063875 0.004134635 −0.043791029 −0.026063889 0.004134623
H 0.004953252 −0.003285285 0.000762794 0.004953251 −0.003285259 0.000762799
H −0.002206063 0.005865218 −0.001177980 −0.002206067 0.005865207 −0.001177972
OW −0.000788163 −0.002201577 0.000391206 −0.000788188 −0.002201594 0.000391190
HW −0.000717674 −0.005376463 0.001127487 −0.000717635 −0.005376466 0.001127493
HW −0.000563665 0.000387007 −0.000088130 −0.000563666 0.000386963 −0.000088149
B2PLYP/FQ
C −0.002959734 0.005558747 −0.001173929 −0.002959733 0.005558749 −0.001173932
H −0.000488653 −0.001723402 0.000317073 −0.000488656 −0.001723403 0.000317071
O 0.003410427 −0.003708308 0.000846802 0.003410429 −0.003708311 0.000846796
N −0.001151459 −0.000232885 −0.000029289 −0.001151455 −0.000232881 −0.000029294
H 0.000830283 −0.000692713 0.000164568 0.000830282 −0.000692715 0.000164569
H 0.000391927 0.000701231 −0.000075504 0.000391922 0.000701234 −0.000075499
OW 0.000027634 0.000111627 −0.000047147 0.000027636 0.000111624 −0.000047142
HW −0.000061537 −0.000009129 −0.000004089 −0.000061538 −0.000009135 −0.000004088
HW 0.000001110 −0.000005167 0.000001514 0.000001109 −0.000005171 0.000001512
MP2/FQ
C −0.007895800 0.011603102 −0.002499396 −0.007895815 0.011603106 −0.002499397
H −0.000202653 −0.001386633 0.000255970 −0.000202661 −0.001386627 0.000255971
O 0.009168345 −0.009790195 0.002200098 0.009168350 −0.009790187 0.002200099
N −0.001093861 −0.000183241 −0.000036583 −0.001093861 −0.000183227 −0.000036588
H 0.000101851 0.000418741 −0.000075773 0.000101857 0.000418734 −0.000075787
H −0.000038435 −0.000840722 0.000223471 −0.000038435 −0.000840720 0.000223468
OW 0.000042998 0.000147207 −0.000054897 0.000042987 0.000147233 −0.000054886
HW −0.000068893 0.000035101 −0.000013776 −0.000068873 0.000035107 −0.000013783
HW −0.000013553 −0.000003361 0.000000887 −0.000013555 −0.000003350 0.000000898

The basis set is 6‐31+G* in every case, the x‐, y‐ and z‐components are projected on the axes shown in Figure 1a