Table 2.
Common analysis methods to study functional connectivity in focal epilepsy
A) Model-based methods | Summary | Considerations |
---|---|---|
coherence | measures the degree of linear dependency of signals between brain regions by examining similar frequency components | requires selection of a specific frequency band, risking overlooking dependencies in other bands; frequency-specific analysis may be more likely to uncover true, not spurious, neural connections |
cross-correlation analysis | measures degree of similarity of signals amongst brain regions as a function of the time lag between these signals | does not require frequency band selection; correlation measurements at zero-time lag are more likely to detect artifact or shared source connections |
phase synchrony | compares only the phase of neural oscillations between brain regions to estimate cross-talk | time resolved, with better temporal resolution than coherence; only sensitive to signal phase and not amplitude |
model-based methods, overall | non-exploratory, often seed-based methods built upon prior hypotheses | less likely to uncover spurious relationships than data-driven methods, but necessitates prior knowledge for specific hypothesis testing |
B) Data-driven methods | Summary | Considerations |
| ||
principle component analysis (PCA) | uses orthogonal transformation to convert possibly correlated neural signals into a set of uncorrelated signals (principal components) in order to uncover network patterns | may reveal novel network patterns and interdependencies; requires selection of regions of interest given otherwise unmanageable amount of data; may be preprocessing step for ICA for further analysis |
independent component analysis (ICA) | identifies a linear combination of components (brain region signals) like PCA, but is restricted to those that are statistically independent | can identify statically independent neural sources (unlike PCA), but statistical dependence between neural signals would degrade results; can be used to further interrogate components identified in PCA |
clustering analysis | identifies groups of brain regions with similar neural signals (clusters) based on the time courses of those signals | useful for novel identification of neural networks and included brain regions; the number of clusters must be chosen, and this may affect connectivity results |
data-driven methods, overall | exploratory, non-seed-based analysis methods free of prior hypotheses | may uncover novel networks given lack of prior knowledge, but more likely to uncover spurious relationships |