Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2016 Oct 13.
Published in final edited form as: AIDS. 2012 Oct 23;26(16):2039–2052. doi: 10.1097/QAD.0b013e328359590f

Table 1.

Overall characteristics of included studies

First Author Publica
tion
year
Type of
publicat
ion
Study
year
Study
design
Country Income
group
ARTs Thres
hold
Adherence
measure
Sam
ple
Stage
Turner[38] 1998 Abstract NR Obs. USA High cART 80 Pharmacy-
based
323 AN
Dabis[25] 1999 Journal 1995–
1998
RCT Burkina
Faso
Low ZDV 80 Pill count 214 AN
Shaffer[69] 1999 Full 1996–
1997
RCT Thailand Middle ZDV 100 Pill count 383 AN
Wiktor[68] 1999 Full 1996–
1998
RCT Côte
d’Ivoire
Middle ZDV 100 Self-reported 134 AN
Laine7 2000 Full 1993–
1996
Obs. USA High ZDV 80 Pharmacy-
based
549 AN
Turner[39] 2000 Full 1993–
1996
Obs. USA High ZDV 80 Pharmacy-
based
292 PN
Wilson[67] 2001 Full 1998 Obs. USA High AZT 100 Pill count 247 AN
Chaovarindr[27] 2002 Abstract 1999–
2001
Obs. Thailand Middle ZDV 100 Self-reported 350 AN
Ickovics[64] 2002 Full 1997–
1998
Obs. USA High ZDV
or
cART
NR MEMS 53 AN&P
N
Durante[58] 2003 Full 1998 Obs. USA High cART 100 Self-reported 63 AN
Kiarie[45] 2003 Full 1999–
2001
Obs./R
CT
Kenya Low cART 80 Self-reported 61/63 AN
Stringer[44] 2003 Full 2000–
2001
RCT Zambia Middle sdNV
P
NR Cord blood 98/10
3
AN
Zorilla[55] 2003 Full NR Obs. USA High cART 100 Self-reported 37 AN
Lallemant[70] 2004 Full 2001–
2003
Obs//R
CT
Thailand Middle ZDV 90 Pill count 724/7
21
AN
Chung[40] 2005 Full 2003 RCT Kenya Low ZDV 100 Pill count 32 AN
Louis[42] 2005 Full 1999–
2004
Obs. USA High cART 100 Self-reported 114 AN
Stringer[50] 2005 Full 2003 Obs. Zambia Middle sdNV
P
100 cord blood 1112 AN
Albrecht[63] 2006 Full 2001–
2003
Obs. Zambia Middle sdNV
P
100 Self-reported 711 AN
Shapiro[60] 2006 Full 2002–
2003
RCT Botswana Middle ZDV 100 Self-reported 354/3
55
AN
Teldaldi[46] 2006 Full 1997–
1998
Obs. USA High cART 100 Self-reported 29 PN
Bii[66] 2007 Full 2005 Obs. Kenya Low sdNV
P
100 NR 146 AN
Cohn[65] 2007 Full 2002–
2005
Obs. USA High cART 95 Self-reported 149 AN&P
N
Kingston[32] 2007 Full 2004–
2005
Obs. UK High cART 100 NR 32 AN
Vaz[57] 2007 Full 2001–
2002
Obs. Brazil Middle cART 95 Pill count 72 AN&P
N
Bardequez[34] 2008 Full 2002–
2005
Obs. USA High cART 100 Self-reported 445 AN&P
N
Chi[28] 2008 Full 2005–
2007
RCT Zambia Middle ZDV 100 pharmacy
refills
355 AN
Chung[56] 2008 Full 2003–
2006
RCT Kenya Low cART NR NR 58 AN&P
N
Ciambrone[29] 2008 Full 2003 Obs. USA Middle cART 100 Self-reported 17 AN
Demas[36] 2008 Full 1997–
1998
Obs. USA High ZDV NR red blood cell 78 AN
Imbaya[30] 2008 Abstract NR Obs. Kenya Low sdNV
P/
ZDV
100 NR 326 AN
Peltzer[54] 2008 Full 2006–
2007
Obs. South
Africa
Middle sdNV
P
100 Self-reported 66 AN
Quava-
Jones[26]
2009 Abstract 2002–
2008
Obs. Trinidad &
Tobago
High cART NR Self-reported 461 AN &
PN
Peltzer[49] 2010 Full 2008–
2009
Obs. South
Africa
Middle sdNV
P
100 Self-reported 815 AN
Barige[62] 2010 Full 2002–
2007
Obs. Uganda Low sdNV
P
100 Self-reported 102 AN
Chasela[59] 2010 Full NR RCT Malawi Low cART 100 Self-reported 849 PN
Conkling[47] 2010 Full 1986–
1994
Obs. Rwanda/
Zambia
Low/
Middle
sdNV
P
100 Self-reported 185/3
19
AN
Kesho
Bora[51]
2010 Full 2005–
2006
Obs. Burkina
Faso &
Kenya
Low ZDV/
sdNV
P
100 Self-reported 116/3
19/12
7
AN
Kuonza[61] 2010 Full 2008 Obs. Zimbabwe Low sdNV
P
100 Self-reported 212 AN
Megazzini[43] 2010 Full 2005–
2006
RCT Zambia Middle sdNV
P
100 Cord blood 234/2
64
AN
Mellins[33] 2010 Full 2001–
2005
Obs. USA High cART 100 Self-reported 309 AN&P
N
Shapiro[37] 2010 Full 2006–
2008
Obs./R
CT
Botswana Middle cART 100 Self-reported 170/2
85/27
5
AN
Stringer[74] 2010 Full 2007–
2008
Obs. Cameroon,
Cote
d’Ivoire,
South
Africa &
Zambia
Low &
Middle
sdNV
P
100 Blood
concentration
739/
196/
663/
670
AN
Caswell[73] 2011 Full 2004–
2007
Obs. UK High cART 100 NR 73 AN
Kesho
Bora[71]
2011 Full 2005–
2008
RCT Burkina
Faso,
Kenya,
South
Africa
Low/Mid
dle
cART 100 Self-reported 389/4
05/39
6
AN
Kirsen[35] 2011 Full 2008–
2009
Obs. Tanzania Low cART 95 Pill count 86 AN&P
N
Leisegang[75] 2011 Abstract NR Obs. South
Africa
Middle cART NR Pharmacy-
based
293 NR
Manenti[52] 2011 Full 2007 Obs. Brazil Middle cART NR Self-reported 36 AN
Mempham[41] 2011 Full 2008 Obs. South
Africa
Middle cART 95 Pill count 94 AN
Mirkuzie[48] 2011 Full 2009 Obs. Ethiopia Low cART 100 Self-reported 282 AN
Peltzer[53] 2011 Full 2009 Obs. South
Africa
Middle AZT 100 self-reported AN:
139/
PN:6
07
AN
Thomas[72] 2011 Full 2003–
2009
RCT Kenya Low ZDV 100 Pill count 522 PN

cART: combined antiretroviral therapy, sdNVP: single dose nevirapine, ZDV: Zidovudine; NR: not reported; AN: antepartum; PN: postpartum; MEMS: Medication Events Monitoring System; Obs: Observation studies; RCT: randomised controlled trial; NR: not reported