Table 5.
Algorithm | Image processing techniques | Database | Color space | Sensitivity | Specificity | Accuracy |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Ram and Sivaswamy [41] | Clustering-based method and color space features | DIARETDB1 | RGB, CIE L ∗ u ∗ v ∗, HSV, HIS |
71.96% | — | 89.7% |
| ||||||
Soares et al. [42] | Morphological operators and adaptive thresholding | DIARETDB1 | Green channel |
97.49% | 99.95% | 99.91% |
| ||||||
Jayakumari and Santhanam [43] | Energy minimization method using echo state neural network |
Private Hospital | — | 90% | — | — |
| ||||||
Karegowda et al. [44] | KNNFP and WKNNFP classifiers |
DIARETDB1 | HIS | — | — | 97.50% WKNNFP 96.67% KNNFP |
| ||||||
Amel et al. [45] | Combine the K-means clustering algorithm and mathematical morphology |
Ophthalmologic Images |
CIELab | 95.92% | 99.78% | 99.70% |
| ||||||
Rokade and Manza [46] | Haar wavelets transformation, KNN classifier |
MISP DIRETDB0, DIRETDB1, STARE |
Green channel | 37.14%, 21.87%, 12.50%, 25.47% | — | — |
| ||||||
Kayal and Banerjee [2] | Median filtering, image thresholding | DIARETDB0 DIARETDB1 |
Gray scale | 97.25% | 96.85% | — |
| ||||||
Jaya et al. [47] | Morphological operations, Circular Hough transform, Fuzzy support vector machine |
Private Hospital | — | 94.1% | 90.0% | — |
| ||||||
Rozlan et al. [48] | Morphology operation, columnwise neighborhoods operation | Sungai Buloh Hospital | Green channel | — | — | 60% |
| ||||||
Soman and Ravi [49] | Circular Hough transform and bit plane slicing, morphological operations | Standard Diabetic Retinopathy |
Green channel | 0.9362 | — | 88% |
| ||||||
Annunziata et al. [50] | Multiple scale Hessian approach |
STARE HRF |
Green channel | — | — | 95.62% 95.81% |
| ||||||
Van Grinsven et al. [51] | Bag of Words approach | Messidor EUGENDA |
HSV, YCbCr | — | — | 0.90 AUC |
| ||||||
Kaur and Mittal [52] | Dynamic region growing method |
SGHS hospital | Gray scale | — | — | 98.65% |