Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2017 Nov 1.
Published in final edited form as: Soc Sci Med. 2016 Aug 28;168:16–29. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2016.08.047

Table 1.

Summary of Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses on the Associations Between Neighborhoods and Health

Author Review/Meta Exposure definition Outcome definition Country Participants # of studies Conclusion
Ding et al, 2011 (Ding et al., 2011) Review Environmental attributes Physical activity Global Youth (3–18 years) 103 - The strongest correlates for children were walkability, traffic speed/volume, access/proximity to recreation facilities, land-use mix, and residential density.
- The most supported correlates for adolescents were land-use mix and residential density.
- Observed associations varied by the mode of measurement (perceived, objective or combination)
Foster & Giles-Corti, 2008 (Foster & Giles-Corti, 2008) Review Real and perceived neighborhood safety Physical activity Global Adults 41 - Results are inconsistent because much of the research relies on inadequate conceptualization and operationalization of safety. Many neighborhood characteristics may not directly affect PA.
Koohsari, et al 2015 (Koohsari et al., 2015) Review Neighborhood environmental attributes: walkability-related, urban/regional, social/crime, aesthetics, destination-related, route-related Sedentary behaviors Global Adults 17 - There is modest, but mixed evidence: 28% of the analyses found significant associations between neighborhoods environmental attributes with adults’ sedentary behaviors, whereas 56% found nonsignificant associations.
- The most consistent association was for lower levels of sedentary behavior among residents of urban compared to regional areas.
Bancroft et al 2015 (Bancroft et al., 2015) Review Parks or trails Objectively measured physical activity USA No restriction 20 - There is inconsistency even among studies with objectively measured physical activity: 5 out of 20 articles reported a significant positive association between parks and physical activity; 9 found no association; and 6 had mixed findings.
Owen et al 2004 (Owen et al., 2004) Review Objectively assessed and perceived environmental attributes Walking Global No restriction 18 - Aesthetic attributes, convenience of facilities for walking (sidewalks, trails); accessibility of destinations (stores, park, beach); and perceptions about traffic and busy roads were found to be associated with walking for particular purposes.
Feng et al, 2010 (Feng et al., 2010) Review Built environment: physical activity environment; land use/transportation environment; food environment Obesity Global No restriction 63 - Of the 22 contextual papers (defined place based on contextual effects derived from shared pre-determined administrative units) that have evaluated 80 relations, 38 relations did not achieve statistical significance.
- Of the 15 buffer papers (defined place based on individually unique geographic buffers) that have evaluated 40 relations, 24 relations did not achieve statistical significance.
Corral et al, 2015 (Corral et al., 2015) Review Residential segregation Overweight/obesity USA African American adults 11 - Only 4 of the 11 studies used valid measures of both segregation and overweight/obesity and also controlled for area-poverty. Though not without methodological limitations, those 4 studies suggested that segregation contributes to overweight and obesity among African American adults.
Black & Macinko 2006 (Black & Macinko, 2008) Review Neighborhood level factors Obesity Global No restriction 37 - In 15 studies, neighborhood-level measures of economic resources were associated with obesity. Also, neighborhood features that discourage physical activity were consistently associated with increased body mass index.
- Inconsistent results for neighborhood income inequality, racial composition, and availability of healthy food.
de Vet et al 2011 (de Vet et al., 2011) Umbrella review Environmental factors Physical activity and dietary behaviors Global Children and adolescents 18 reviews (671 studies) - Consistent evidence supporting the associations between school and neighborhood characteristics and physical activity, but not for dietary behaviors.
Safron et al, 2011 (Safron et al., 2011) Umbrella review Social and physical micro-environmental (neighborhood, school) characteristics Diet, physical activity, and body weight Global Children and adolescents 8 reviews (132 studies) - Stronger support for several neighborhood and school characteristics (e.g., community opportunities to exercise, lower costs of physical activity facilities, physical activity built environment, low crime level) and adolescent physical activity.
Kramer and Hogue, 2009 (Kramer & Hogue, 2009) Review Black-white residential segregation Health outcomes USA African Americans 39 - The health effects of segregation are relatively consistent: isolation segregation is associated with poor pregnancy outcomes and increased mortality, but clustered segregation (black neighborhoods) seemed to have health-protective effects.
Papas et al., 2007 (Papas et al., 2007) Review Objective measure of the build environment Overweight/obesity USA, Australia, Europe No restriction 20 -Most (17/20) studies reported associations between the built environment and BMI, though the direction of the association was mixed. Most (18/20) studies were cross-sectional. One of the two longitudinal studies found a negative association between produce prices and weight gain; the other (sprawl and BMI) was null.
Pickett and Pearl, 2001 (Pickett & Pearl, 2001) Review Local area social characteristics Health outcomes Developed countries No restriction 25 ML studies - Consistent evidence to support modest neighborhood effects on health.
Casagrande et al. 2009 (Casagrande et al., 2009) Review Built environment Health behaviors USA African American adults 17 - Inconsistent relationships found between physical activity and light traffic, presence of sidewalks, and safety from crime.
- Perceived barriers to physical activity were associated with obesity.
Yen et al 2009 (I. H. Yen et al., 2009) Review Objective and perceived neighborhood environment Health outcomes Global Older adults 33 - Among different categories of neighborhood characteristics (socioeconomic composition, racial composition, demographics, perceived resources and/or problems, physical environment, and social environment), neighborhood level socioeconomic status was the strongest and most consistent predictor for elderly’s mortality and morbidity, self-reported health or quality of life, mental health, cognition, disability, and physical activity/body mass index.
Kim, 2008 (Kim, 2008) Review Neighborhood characteristics Depression Global Adults 28 - In general, studies support for harmful effects of social disorder and, to a lesser extent, protective effects for neighborhood socioeconomic status.
Mair et al, 2008 (Mair et al., 2008) Review Neighborhood characteristics Depression/depressive symptoms Global No restriction 45 - 37 studies reported associations of at least one neighborhood characteristic with depression/depressive symptoms.
- The associations of depressive symptoms/depression with structural features (socioeconomic and racial composition, stability and built environment) were less consistent, smaller in number of studies, than with social processes (disorder, social interactions, violence).
Truong & Ma 2006 (Truong & Ma, 2006) Review Neighborhood characteristics Mental health Developed countries Adults 29 - 27studies found statistically significant associations between mental health and at least one measure of neighborhood characteristics (sociodemographic characteristics, physical environment). Though the effect estimates attenuated after adjusting for individual-level characteristics, they still remained significant.
Christian et al, 2015 (Christian et al., 2015) Review Neighborhood built environment, green spaces, and the home outdoor area Child health outcomes Global Children 32 - The presence of child relevant neighborhood destinations and services and parents’ perceptions of neighborhood safety were positively associated with general health and social-emotional development during early developmental periods.
Sellstrom & Bremberg 2006 (Sellstrom & Bremberg, 2006) Review Neighborhood context Child health outcomes High-income countries Children and adolescent 13 ML studies - Neighborhood socioeconomic status and social climate were shown to have small to moderate effects on birth weight, injuries, behavioral problems, and child maltreatment.
- On average, 10% of variation in health outcomes was explained by neighborhood determinants, after controlling for important individual and family variables.
Vos et al 2014 (Vos et al., 2014) Review and meta-analysis Neighborhood deprivation Birth outcomes Global Birth outcomes 24 in review; 7 in meta-analysis - Living in a deprived neighborhood was consistently associated with increased odds for preterm delivery (OR: 1.23, 95% CI: 1.18–1.28), small-for-gestational age (OR: 1.31, 95% CI: 1.28–1.34), and stillbirth (OR: 1.33, 95% CI: 1.21–1.45).
Meijer et al, 2012 (Meijer et al., 2012) Review and meta-analysis Area-level socioeconomic status All-cause mortality Global No restriction 40 in review; 18 in meta-analysis - No clear evidence to support the associations for area-level income inequality or social capital and all-cause mortality.
- There was a significantly higher risk of mortality for individuals living in neighborhoods with low socioeconomic status.
Jackson et al, 2014 (Jackson et al., 2014) Review Neighborhood environment Alcohol use Global Adolescents 23 - The majority of studies found no associations with residential mobility, neighborhood disorder or crime, employment or job availability, neighborhood attitudes to drinking, social capital and collective efficacy.
- There were mixed results in studies examining neighborhood-level socio-economic disadvantage and alcohol use.
Beyer et al, 2015 (Beyer et al., 2015) Review Neighborhood environment Intimate partner violence Global Adults 36 - 30 studies reported a positive association between one or more neighborhood characteristics and intimate partner violence. This was true for majority of the 17 studies that adequately adjusted for individual and neighborhood variables.