Table 1.
Summary of Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses on the Associations Between Neighborhoods and Health
Author | Review/Meta | Exposure definition | Outcome definition | Country | Participants | # of studies | Conclusion |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Ding et al, 2011 (Ding et al., 2011) | Review | Environmental attributes | Physical activity | Global | Youth (3–18 years) | 103 | - The strongest correlates for children were walkability, traffic speed/volume, access/proximity to recreation facilities, land-use mix, and residential density. - The most supported correlates for adolescents were land-use mix and residential density. - Observed associations varied by the mode of measurement (perceived, objective or combination) |
Foster & Giles-Corti, 2008 (Foster & Giles-Corti, 2008) | Review | Real and perceived neighborhood safety | Physical activity | Global | Adults | 41 | - Results are inconsistent because much of the research relies on inadequate conceptualization and operationalization of safety. Many neighborhood characteristics may not directly affect PA. |
Koohsari, et al 2015 (Koohsari et al., 2015) | Review | Neighborhood environmental attributes: walkability-related, urban/regional, social/crime, aesthetics, destination-related, route-related | Sedentary behaviors | Global | Adults | 17 | - There is modest, but mixed evidence: 28% of the analyses found significant associations between neighborhoods environmental attributes with adults’ sedentary behaviors, whereas 56% found nonsignificant associations. - The most consistent association was for lower levels of sedentary behavior among residents of urban compared to regional areas. |
Bancroft et al 2015 (Bancroft et al., 2015) | Review | Parks or trails | Objectively measured physical activity | USA | No restriction | 20 | - There is inconsistency even among studies with objectively measured physical activity: 5 out of 20 articles reported a significant positive association between parks and physical activity; 9 found no association; and 6 had mixed findings. |
Owen et al 2004 (Owen et al., 2004) | Review | Objectively assessed and perceived environmental attributes | Walking | Global | No restriction | 18 | - Aesthetic attributes, convenience of facilities for walking (sidewalks, trails); accessibility of destinations (stores, park, beach); and perceptions about traffic and busy roads were found to be associated with walking for particular purposes. |
Feng et al, 2010 (Feng et al., 2010) | Review | Built environment: physical activity environment; land use/transportation environment; food environment | Obesity | Global | No restriction | 63 | - Of the 22 contextual papers (defined place based on contextual effects derived from shared pre-determined administrative units) that have evaluated 80 relations, 38 relations did not achieve statistical significance. - Of the 15 buffer papers (defined place based on individually unique geographic buffers) that have evaluated 40 relations, 24 relations did not achieve statistical significance. |
Corral et al, 2015 (Corral et al., 2015) | Review | Residential segregation | Overweight/obesity | USA | African American adults | 11 | - Only 4 of the 11 studies used valid measures of both segregation and overweight/obesity and also controlled for area-poverty. Though not without methodological limitations, those 4 studies suggested that segregation contributes to overweight and obesity among African American adults. |
Black & Macinko 2006 (Black & Macinko, 2008) | Review | Neighborhood level factors | Obesity | Global | No restriction | 37 | - In 15 studies, neighborhood-level measures of economic resources were associated with obesity. Also, neighborhood features that discourage physical activity were consistently associated with increased body mass index. - Inconsistent results for neighborhood income inequality, racial composition, and availability of healthy food. |
de Vet et al 2011 (de Vet et al., 2011) | Umbrella review | Environmental factors | Physical activity and dietary behaviors | Global | Children and adolescents | 18 reviews (671 studies) | - Consistent evidence supporting the associations between school and neighborhood characteristics and physical activity, but not for dietary behaviors. |
Safron et al, 2011 (Safron et al., 2011) | Umbrella review | Social and physical micro-environmental (neighborhood, school) characteristics | Diet, physical activity, and body weight | Global | Children and adolescents | 8 reviews (132 studies) | - Stronger support for several neighborhood and school characteristics (e.g., community opportunities to exercise, lower costs of physical activity facilities, physical activity built environment, low crime level) and adolescent physical activity. |
Kramer and Hogue, 2009 (Kramer & Hogue, 2009) | Review | Black-white residential segregation | Health outcomes | USA | African Americans | 39 | - The health effects of segregation are relatively consistent: isolation segregation is associated with poor pregnancy outcomes and increased mortality, but clustered segregation (black neighborhoods) seemed to have health-protective effects. |
Papas et al., 2007 (Papas et al., 2007) | Review | Objective measure of the build environment | Overweight/obesity | USA, Australia, Europe | No restriction | 20 | -Most (17/20) studies reported associations between the built environment and BMI, though the direction of the association was mixed. Most (18/20) studies were cross-sectional. One of the two longitudinal studies found a negative association between produce prices and weight gain; the other (sprawl and BMI) was null. |
Pickett and Pearl, 2001 (Pickett & Pearl, 2001) | Review | Local area social characteristics | Health outcomes | Developed countries | No restriction | 25 ML studies | - Consistent evidence to support modest neighborhood effects on health. |
Casagrande et al. 2009 (Casagrande et al., 2009) | Review | Built environment | Health behaviors | USA | African American adults | 17 | - Inconsistent relationships found between physical activity and light traffic, presence of sidewalks, and safety from crime. - Perceived barriers to physical activity were associated with obesity. |
Yen et al 2009 (I. H. Yen et al., 2009) | Review | Objective and perceived neighborhood environment | Health outcomes | Global | Older adults | 33 | - Among different categories of neighborhood characteristics (socioeconomic composition, racial composition, demographics, perceived resources and/or problems, physical environment, and social environment), neighborhood level socioeconomic status was the strongest and most consistent predictor for elderly’s mortality and morbidity, self-reported health or quality of life, mental health, cognition, disability, and physical activity/body mass index. |
Kim, 2008 (Kim, 2008) | Review | Neighborhood characteristics | Depression | Global | Adults | 28 | - In general, studies support for harmful effects of social disorder and, to a lesser extent, protective effects for neighborhood socioeconomic status. |
Mair et al, 2008 (Mair et al., 2008) | Review | Neighborhood characteristics | Depression/depressive symptoms | Global | No restriction | 45 | - 37 studies reported associations of at least one neighborhood characteristic with depression/depressive symptoms. - The associations of depressive symptoms/depression with structural features (socioeconomic and racial composition, stability and built environment) were less consistent, smaller in number of studies, than with social processes (disorder, social interactions, violence). |
Truong & Ma 2006 (Truong & Ma, 2006) | Review | Neighborhood characteristics | Mental health | Developed countries | Adults | 29 | - 27studies found statistically significant associations between mental health and at least one measure of neighborhood characteristics (sociodemographic characteristics, physical environment). Though the effect estimates attenuated after adjusting for individual-level characteristics, they still remained significant. |
Christian et al, 2015 (Christian et al., 2015) | Review | Neighborhood built environment, green spaces, and the home outdoor area | Child health outcomes | Global | Children | 32 | - The presence of child relevant neighborhood destinations and services and parents’ perceptions of neighborhood safety were positively associated with general health and social-emotional development during early developmental periods. |
Sellstrom & Bremberg 2006 (Sellstrom & Bremberg, 2006) | Review | Neighborhood context | Child health outcomes | High-income countries | Children and adolescent | 13 ML studies | - Neighborhood socioeconomic status and social climate were shown to have small to moderate effects on birth weight, injuries, behavioral problems, and child maltreatment. - On average, 10% of variation in health outcomes was explained by neighborhood determinants, after controlling for important individual and family variables. |
Vos et al 2014 (Vos et al., 2014) | Review and meta-analysis | Neighborhood deprivation | Birth outcomes | Global | Birth outcomes | 24 in review; 7 in meta-analysis | - Living in a deprived neighborhood was consistently associated with increased odds for preterm delivery (OR: 1.23, 95% CI: 1.18–1.28), small-for-gestational age (OR: 1.31, 95% CI: 1.28–1.34), and stillbirth (OR: 1.33, 95% CI: 1.21–1.45). |
Meijer et al, 2012 (Meijer et al., 2012) | Review and meta-analysis | Area-level socioeconomic status | All-cause mortality | Global | No restriction | 40 in review; 18 in meta-analysis | - No clear evidence to support the associations for area-level income inequality or social capital and all-cause mortality. - There was a significantly higher risk of mortality for individuals living in neighborhoods with low socioeconomic status. |
Jackson et al, 2014 (Jackson et al., 2014) | Review | Neighborhood environment | Alcohol use | Global | Adolescents | 23 | - The majority of studies found no associations with residential mobility, neighborhood disorder or crime, employment or job availability, neighborhood attitudes to drinking, social capital and collective efficacy. - There were mixed results in studies examining neighborhood-level socio-economic disadvantage and alcohol use. |
Beyer et al, 2015 (Beyer et al., 2015) | Review | Neighborhood environment | Intimate partner violence | Global | Adults | 36 | - 30 studies reported a positive association between one or more neighborhood characteristics and intimate partner violence. This was true for majority of the 17 studies that adequately adjusted for individual and neighborhood variables. |