Table 2.
Study Characteristics
Author, Year | Participant Details |
Training Details |
Protein/EAA and Placebo Supplement Details |
||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Number of Participants | Mean Age, Years | Frail/Mobility Limited/Sarcopenic | Baseline Protein Intake (g·kg−1·day−1)∗ | Study Length and RT Frequency | Type of RT | RT Intensity | Functional/Balance Training | Type of Protein | Frequency (Daily/With Training) | Timing of Ingestion | Amount | Control Treatment | |
Fiatarone et al, 199421 | 50 | 86.7 | Y | NA | 3 d/wk × 10 wk | LL | 80% 1-RM | N | Soy-based | Daily | Evening | 15 g approx. | Water |
Godard et al, 200222 | 17 | 71.5 | N | 1.14 | 3 d/wk × 12 wk | LL | 80% 1-RM | N | EAA (1.86 g L-lysine, 2.24 g L-leucine, 1.40 g L-valine, 1.86 g L-phenylalanine, 1.76 g L-threonine, 1.30 g L-histidine, 1.2 g L-isoleucine, 0.38 g L-methionine) | Daily | After training | 12 g | Exercise only |
Bunout et al, 200423 | 47 | 74.1 | N | NA | 2 d/wk × 1 year | LL + UL | Light | N | Undisclosed protein | Daily | Between meals | 15 g | Exercise only |
Rosendahl et al, 200624† | 91 | 85.2 | Y | NA | 5 d/2 wk × 13 wk | LL | 8–12 RM | Y | Milk-based | With training | After training | 7.4 g | CHO |
Verdijk et al, 200925 | 28 | 72.0 | N | 1.10 | 3 d/wk × 12 wk | LL | 60%–80% 1-RM | N | Casein | With training | 10 g before, 10 g after training | 20 g | Water |
Zak et al, 200926 | 40 | 78.7 | Y | NA | 5 d/wk × 7 wk | LL | 80% 1-RM | Y | Undisclosed protein | With training | Before training | 12 g approx. | Water |
Kim et al, 201228 | 77 | 79.2 | Y | NA | 2 d/wk × 3 months | LL + UL | Moderate | Y | EAA (42.0% leucine, 14.0% lysine, 10.5% valine, 10.5% isoleucine, 10.5% threonine, 7.0% phenylalanine, 5.5% other) | Daily | Twice daily | 6 g | Exercise only |
Tieland et al, 201229 | 62 | 78.5 | Y | 1.00 | 2 d/wk × 24 wk | LL + UL | 50%–75% 1-RM |
N | Milk-based | Daily | 15 g after breakfast, 15 g after lunch | 30 g | CHO |
Arnarson et al, 201330 | 161 | 73.9 | N | 1.00 | 3 d/wk × 12 wk | LL + UL | 75%–80% 1-RM | N | Whey | With training | After training | 20 g | CHO |
Chalé et al, 201331 | 80 | 77.7 | Y | 0.97 | 3 d/wk × 6 months | LL + UL | 80% 1-RM | N | Whey | Daily | 20 g after breakfast, 20 g after dinner | 40 g | CHO |
Leenders et al, 201332 | 60 | 70.0 | N | 1.15 | 3 d/wk × 24 wk | LL + UL | 60%–80% 1-RM | N | Milk-based (80% Casein, 20% Whey) | Daily | After breakfast | 15 g | CHO |
Daly et al, 201433 | 100 | 72.8 | N | 1.08 | 2 d/wk × 4 months | LL + UL | Moderate | Y | Red meat | 6 d/wk | Meals, after training | 45 g‡ | CHO |
Franzke et al, 201534 | 64 | 82.7 | N | NA | 2 d/wk × 6 months | LL + UL | Light to heavy | N | Whey | Daily | Morning and after training | 20.7 g | Exercise only |
Mitchell et al, 201535 | 16 | 74.4 | N | NA | 3 d/wk × 12 wk | LL + UL | 75%–85% 1-RM | N | Chocolate milk | Daily | After breakfast or after training | 14 g | Placebo drink |
Trabal et al, 201536 | 24 | 84.5 | N | 1.20 | 3 d/wk × 12 wk | LL | 65% 1-RM | Y | Leucine | Daily | 5 g after lunch, 5 g after dinner | 10 g | CHO |
1-RM, 1-repetition maximum; CHO, carbohydrate; d, days; LL, lower limb; N, no; RT, resistance training; UL, upper limb; wk, weeks; Y, yes.
NA indicates studies did not report baseline protein intake.
Approximately 220 g (raw weight) or 160 g (cooked weight) lean red meat equated to 45 g protein.