Table 1.
Characteristics of eligible studies.
Study | Mean Age (Range), Years | % Male | Participants | n-PUFA dose grams/day | Trial duration | Control oil | IS Measure | Mean Baseline IS | Dropout |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Abete 200845 | 36 | 56.20% | Non-diabetic, obese subjects |
Experimental group had fish based diet 3 days a week, while control did not. | 8 weeks | NA | HOMA IR | 2.65 | E -20% C-20% |
Ingrid LM 200626 | (40–75) | 50% | Type 2 Diabetic |
2.42 g per day | 9 weeks | Corn oil | Glucose utilization measured by hyperinsulinemic isoglycemic clamp | NA | E -7.7% C-0% |
Ingrid T 199540 | 53.67 | 64% | Non-diabetic, untreated HTN |
4 g per day | 16 weeks | Corn oil | ISI -hyperglycemic clamps | 0.17 | E -9.5% C-4.8% |
Josune 201036 | 75 | 20% | Required TEN |
0.138 g per day | 6 months | NA | HOMA IR, QUICKI | a1.14 b0.41 | E -47% C-39% |
Maiken 201041 | 14.3 | 100% | Slightly over weight |
1.5 g per day | 16 weeks | Mixture of Palm, soy and rapseed oil | HOMA IR | 1.1 | 10.3% combined |
Morvarid 200742 | 55 | 0% | Type 2 Diabetic |
1.8 g per day | 2 months | Paraffin oil | HOMA S | 69.1 | 10.3% overall |
Spadaro 200843 | 50.73 | 52.80% | NAFLD |
2 g per day | 6 months | NA | HOMA IR | 3.75 | E -10% C-10% |
Stefano 200935 | 29.9 | 50% | OPD |
2 g per day | 12 weeks | Olive oil | QUICKI | 0.35 | E -0% C-0% |
Tracy 200744 | 38.49 | 20% | Abdominally obese | c11 g per day | 8 weeks | NA | QUICKI | 0.34 | E -0% C-3.6% |
Woodman 200237 | 61.2 | 76% | Type 2 Diabetic with treated HTN d |
4 g per day | 6 weeks | Olive oil | ISI measured by low-dose insulin and glucose infusion test | 5.46 | 28.8% overall |
Rosalba 200625 (MUFA and SAFA diet groups combined) | 48.74 | 53% | Healthy subjects, non-diabetic MUFA: SAFA: |
3.6 gper day | 3 months | Olive oil | ISI measured with MINMOD program | 4.44 | 3.7% overall |
– subjects in experimental group who completed the trials, – subjects in the control group who completed the trials, E - Intervention group, C – Control group, HTN – Hypertension, NA – Not Available, ISI – Insulin sensitivity index, OPD – Offspring of patients with type 2 diabetes, TEN – Total Enteral Nutrition, NAFLD – Non-alcoholic Fatty Liver Disease.
– HOMA IR score.
– QUICKI score.
– Flaxseed oil.
– Combined EPA and DHA groups.