Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2016 Oct 17.
Published in final edited form as: Clin Nutr. 2011 Sep 29;30(6):702–707. doi: 10.1016/j.clnu.2011.08.013

Table 1.

Characteristics of eligible studies.

Study Mean Age (Range), Years % Male Participants n-PUFA dose grams/day Trial duration Control oil IS Measure Mean Baseline IS Dropout
Abete 200845 36 56.20% Non-diabetic, obese subjects
ne-16
nc-16
Experimental group had fish based diet 3 days a week, while control did not. 8 weeks NA HOMA IR 2.65 E -20% C-20%
Ingrid LM 200626 (40–75) 50% Type 2 Diabetic
ne-12
nc-14
2.42 g per day 9 weeks Corn oil Glucose utilization measured by hyperinsulinemic isoglycemic clamp NA E -7.7% C-0%
Ingrid T 199540 53.67 64% Non-diabetic, untreated HTN
ne-38
nc-40
4 g per day 16 weeks Corn oil ISI -hyperglycemic clamps 0.17 E -9.5% C-4.8%
Josune 201036 75 20% Required TEN
ne-17
nc-20
0.138 g per day 6 months NA HOMA IR, QUICKI a1.14 b0.41 E -47% C-39%
Maiken 201041 14.3 100% Slightly over weight
ne-38
ne-40
1.5 g per day 16 weeks Mixture of Palm, soy and rapseed oil HOMA IR 1.1 10.3% combined
Morvarid 200742 55 0% Type 2 Diabetic
ne-12
nc-14
1.8 g per day 2 months Paraffin oil HOMA S 69.1 10.3% overall
Spadaro 200843 50.73 52.80% NAFLD
ne-18
nc-18
2 g per day 6 months NA HOMA IR 3.75 E -10% C-10%
Stefano 200935 29.9 50% OPD
ne-26
nc-24
2 g per day 12 weeks Olive oil QUICKI 0.35 E -0% C-0%
Tracy 200744 38.49 20% Abdominally obese c11 g per day 8 weeks NA QUICKI 0.34 E -0% C-3.6%
Woodman 200237 61.2 76% Type 2 Diabetic with treated HTN
ne-29d
nc-13
4 g per day 6 weeks Olive oil ISI measured by low-dose insulin and glucose infusion test 5.46 28.8% overall
Rosalba 200625 (MUFA and SAFA diet groups combined) 48.74 53% Healthy subjects, non-diabetic MUFA:
ne-35
nc-39
SAFA:
ne-40
nc-42
3.6 gper day 3 months Olive oil ISI measured with MINMOD program 4.44 3.7% overall

nc subjects in experimental group who completed the trials, nc subjects in the control group who completed the trials, E - Intervention group, C – Control group, HTN – Hypertension, NA – Not Available, ISI – Insulin sensitivity index, OPD – Offspring of patients with type 2 diabetes, TEN – Total Enteral Nutrition, NAFLD – Non-alcoholic Fatty Liver Disease.

a

– HOMA IR score.

b

– QUICKI score.

c

– Flaxseed oil.

d

– Combined EPA and DHA groups.

HHS Vulnerability Disclosure