Impression cytology (IC) | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Study | Location | Year | Study design | Number of eyes | Main findings |
Nolan et al. [14] | Australia | 1994 | Observational | Invasive squamous cell carcinoma (6) Conjunctival intraepithelial neoplasia (49) No OSSN (21) |
IC can be used to demonstrate the morphology of normal and abnormal conjunctival cells. Cytology report was positive in 77% of histopathology reports in the moderate dysplasia to microinvasive carcinoma group. There were no false positives. |
| |||||
Tole et al. [15] | Australia | 2001 | Prospective case series | Squamous cell carcinoma (SCC) (1) Carcinoma in situ (2) Keratinizing dysplasia (15) Nonkeratinizing dysplasia (7) |
IC is accurate in predicting the diagnosis of OSSN. Correlation rate of IC with histological findings was accurate in 80% of cases, poor in 12% of cases, and not correlated in 8% of cases. There were no false positives. |
| |||||
Nolan et al. [16] | Australia | 2001 | Retrospective observational | Intraepithelial OSSN or corneal/conjunctival intraepithelial neoplasia (142) Invasive OSSN or SCC (23) |
The cytomorphology of OSSN is described in detail. For intraepithelial lesions, these include (1) keratinized dysplastic cells often accompanied by hyperkeratosis (55%), (2) syncytial-like groupings (35%), and (3) nonkeratinized dysplastic (10%) cells. Meanwhile, invasive cases had a tendency to be more highly keratinized and to have a greater degree of inflammation than the keratinized high grade intraepithelial cases but it was not possible to confidently predict invasion on IC. Sensitivity of IC in diagnosing OSSN was 78% overall but was lower (70%) when the lesion was invasive by histopathology. |
| |||||
Tananuvat et al. [17] | Thailand | 2008 | Retrospective case series | OSSN (50) including SCC (20), dysplasia (20), squamous papilloma (4), and nondysplastic changes of the epithelia (6) Pigmented lesions (5) including nevus (4) and malignant melanoma (1) |
Compared with histologic findings, IC had a high positive predictive value (PPV) of 97.4% and a fair negative predictive value (NPV) of 52.9%, making it a good screening tool but inadequate gold standard. Moreover, IC is less sensitive for keratotic lesions and invasive disease. |
| |||||
de Nadai Barros et al. [18] | Brazil | 2009 | Transverse, observational | Pterygium (1) Actinic keratosis (AK) (9) Corneal/conjunctival intraepithelial neoplasia (CCIN) (9) SCC (20) |
Cytological features related to malignancy were applied to determine an index score that best differentiates invasive SCC from preinvasive lesions. With an index score of ≥4.25, sensitivity was 95%, specificity was 93%, PPV was 95%, and NPV was 93% for predicting SCC. However, in two preinvasive lesions (one AK lesion and one CCIN lesion), IC sampling was not sufficiently deep to reach atypical cells and presents a limitation to diagnose disease affecting deeper tissue. |
| |||||
de Nadai Barros et al. [19] | Brazil | 2014 | Transverse, prospective, observational | Pterygia without atypical cells (19) Pterygia with associated OSSN (13) |
IC showed high agreement with histopathology in detecting unsuspected OSSN in pterygia patients (sensitivity 92%, specificity 94%, PPV 92%, and NPV 94%). |