Table 2. Characteristics of cases†.
Characteristics | N [%] |
---|---|
Main reason for catheter insertion | |
Monitoring | 10 [35] |
Retention | 10 [35] |
Post-op | 5 [17] |
Trauma | 1 [3] |
C-section | 1 [3] |
Comatose patient | 1 [3] |
Not mentioned | 1 [3] |
Alleged breach of standard of care | |
Trauma/improper insertion | 14 [48] |
Removal related | 8 [28] |
Mechanical failure | 3 [10] |
Lack of consent | 3 [10] |
Non-sterile insertion | 1 [3] |
Damages claimed by plaintiffs ‡ | |
Pain | 8 [28] |
Urinary tract infection | 7 [24] |
Fistula | 6 [21] |
Extra surgery | 4 [14] |
Incontinence | 4 [14] |
Death due to sepsis | 4 [14] |
Impotence | 3 [10] |
Stricture | 2 [7] |
Hematuria | 2 [7] |
Other | 3 [10] |
Trial outcome | |
Defendant verdict | 19 [66] |
Plaintiff verdict | 8 [28] |
Settlement | 2 [7] |
Mean indemnity award for plaintiffs [range] | 112,991 [4,000-325,000] |
Mean settlement amount [range] | 55,750 [25,000-86,500] |
†, all missing data in cases were excluded from analysis; ‡, plaintiffs had more than one claim in some cases.